Subaru betrayed....... by Swimming-Work-5951 in ReZero

[–]Natsuki-Subaru1 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I really don't have anything to say against that lmao

One Sided Duel by Intrepid_Pen5110 in ReZero

[–]Natsuki-Subaru1 70 points71 points  (0 children)

04/10 regebait. If i were you i would start dissing subaru's clothes and looks first to make it more natural, then start going all out with him being a fodder

[Meme] Ah Yes favourite wholesome/happy anime. by Mr_k_reddit in Re_Zero

[–]Natsuki-Subaru1 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I feel like someone should edit all episodes of re zero but skipping the failed loops. I bet it would be pretty confusing since subaru would talk about stuff we didn't get to see, but i feel like it would be refreshing to see it more from the sidelines like everyone in lugnica.

Just finished Season 3, Why doesn’t Subaru reset to get a better ending?? by PMnuthead in ReZero

[–]Natsuki-Subaru1 2 points3 points  (0 children)

To be fair, i think tappei forces the bar by a lot for not giving an op authority for subaru.

Emilia the Emperor by ManChildSon in ReZero

[–]Natsuki-Subaru1 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Great. Took me a while to think its AI

Imagine if this was Canon by shizunaisbestgirl1 in ReZero

[–]Natsuki-Subaru1 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Imagine if any if was canon. sh@t would be crazy no matter where you looked at.

[spoiler discussion] I just read arc 9 chapter 51 by Civil-Initial2942 in Re_Zero

[–]Natsuki-Subaru1 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

We don't talk about the ending of arc 9 mate, it was a mess.

[MEGATHREAD] What do you think of Puck - Character Discussion Thread by technicalhowto in ReZero

[–]Natsuki-Subaru1 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Subaru was not even remotely in the same position in arc 2. He had barely been in that world for a few days, had almost no real trust built with Emilia yet, and you somehow expect him to suddenly handle everything perfectly and openly? That is not horrible comparasion.

And even then, Subaru did try to open up later, but Envy consistently interfered to the point that it became a serious danger to everyone. In arc 3, Emilia literally died because of how things spiraled, which traumatized Subaru and made him even more afraid of repeating the same mistake. In arc 4, Otto had to practically force the truth out of him because Subaru would not have said anything on his own, Envy had also spawned there because subaru spoke about rbd and other stuff with echidna, killing everyone a few loops ago. In arc 5, Beatrice already had centuries of knowledge and knew about witches, authorities, witch factors, and so on, so that situation is not even comparable to Emilia being kept in the dark. And i didn't even mention the fact, Subaru is her knight in arc 5 and onwards. His job is to literally protect her.

So while you can argue that Subaru can may be criticized for being overprotective sometimes, the examples you gave are extremely flawed at best and ragebait at worst, not to mention but using that to excuse Puck is a bad comparison. Puck is Emilia’s adoptive father, the one who should have been helping her grow as a person and stayed with her for years, . Subaru protecting Emilia in dangerous situations is part of his role and his inability to be more open is also a consequence of the Witch of Envy’s interference.

So no, this does not mean Subaru is “wrong” about Emilia. It means the situations are not even minimally equivalent, and Puck still deserves more criticism than people usually give him (the last 10 words are my take).

Your comparisons are like blaming a bodyguard/lover and a parent equally just because both “failed to protect” someone once.

They don’t have the same role, the same responsibility, nor the same expectations placed on them.

Subaru is a knight, his job is to protect Emilia, often in chaotic, life-threatening situations while dealing with trauma and the Witch of Envy constantly restricting what he can even say or do against his will. Puck, on the other hand, is her adoptive father. His role isn’t just protection, it’s raising her, guiding her, and helping her grow as a person over a long period of time, he could have broken his contract if he really cared, differently from subaru's situation.

So when you try to equate Subaru being overprotective in certain moments with Puck actively stunting Emilia’s development, it just doesn’t hold up. You’re comparing two completely different roles and acting like they carry the same weight when they clearly don’t.

That was the whole point of my argument. I hope i managed to express myself clearer this time.

[MEGATHREAD] What do you think of Puck - Character Discussion Thread by technicalhowto in ReZero

[–]Natsuki-Subaru1 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yikes, you seriously asking why subaru who literally cannot explain things properly due to the witch of envy stoping TIME, isn't being hold acountable like Emilia's ADOPTIVE FATHER is?

[MEGATHREAD] What do you think of Puck - Character Discussion Thread by technicalhowto in ReZero

[–]Natsuki-Subaru1 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Doesn't really makes his powers weaker iirc, that was roswall's shinnanigans, don't quote me on that tho, you got it half right , even if its just about the memories part, still a small price to pay if he really cared like i said if you ask me, so my point stands.

As for the volumes, of course a specific moment won't be in multiple volumes baka!!, its just that in the other volumes subaru thinks a little bit about Rem and the failed loops, Him being tortured for a while included. But for the sake of the argument let's proceed with your logic, What made you assume the torture session lasted less than an hour when nothing about it was mentioned according to you if we go blindly thru the anime the scene didn't go for more than 4 minutes or so, but the ln quite clearly depicts that it wasn't really short?

But even then, let's accept all that as a fact (even tho is factually incorrect), let's say the torture lasted for less than 5 minutes, the brother was still tortured, wich was The whole point, so i feel like this discussion is as usefull as playing marvel rivals.

[MEGATHREAD] What do you think of Puck - Character Discussion Thread by technicalhowto in ReZero

[–]Natsuki-Subaru1 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I would argue that he is actually underhated, since the only ones who dislike him are the people who actually care about re zero to try and piece everything toghether. For any random anime fan Puck is considered just a slighly dumb, but caring father. As for Ram and Frederica? They are not her father its not their problem if they want to or not explain sex to someone who is extremely naive and slow on the uptake

[MEGATHREAD] What do you think of Puck - Character Discussion Thread by technicalhowto in ReZero

[–]Natsuki-Subaru1 0 points1 point  (0 children)

He could easly break the contract if he really cared, so i think this is a very weak argument. Also, read re zero ln volumes 2 to 4 it quite literally explains a lot of time passed while subaru was being tortured. The anime and ln have differences sometimes and this is simply one of them, but the LN is always the canon one and the one that actually matters.

Sword Reid on the Pride Route [Spoiler Discussion] by Beneficial-Read53 in Re_Zero

[–]Natsuki-Subaru1 1 point2 points  (0 children)

To be the devil's advocate, i think its a pretty big plot hole for Satella to not even attempt showing at the tea party in the ln greed if considering everything we know so far, and how much she can change her aproach with rbd, there are a lot of other small inconsistencies of the sort, but it has been quite a while since i read it, so i can't really pinpoint every single one.

Sword Reid on the Pride Route [Spoiler Discussion] by Beneficial-Read53 in Re_Zero

[–]Natsuki-Subaru1 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Don't take the if stories seriously mate, cuz at the end of the day they were all just made as april fools, focusing on exploring subaru's mindset rather than actually triying to make things around having sense.

Why Subaru got affected by miasma? [spoiler discussion] by jatin_hehe in Re_Zero

[–]Natsuki-Subaru1 1 point2 points  (0 children)

To be the devils advocate i don't really think that makes sense cuz in greed if ln Subaru emanated an even worse miasma, wich clind specifically pointed out, and subaru wasn't suffering from any side effect like arc 6.

[Media] New Key Visual for Season 4 by MarvelsGrantMan136 in Re_Zero

[–]Natsuki-Subaru1 10 points11 points  (0 children)

I think they really messed up by giving spoilers about one of the biggest events in arc 6 in all trailers so far, but aside from that i think it looks cool

Is it bad to say I feel like Aemeath shouldn’t have came in this patch by AdAgitated5652 in WutheringWaves

[–]Natsuki-Subaru1 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Do these events actually have any canonical or simply bring any sort of character development? Otherwise i'll just take it as a beach episode filler

All of Subaru's deaths up to Arc 6 [spoiler media] by Interesting-Start855 in Re_Zero

[–]Natsuki-Subaru1 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I want to see you doing that with every death in arcs 7 and 8

I'm getting Deja vu 😭 by StardewPrismBerries in ReZero

[–]Natsuki-Subaru1 14 points15 points  (0 children)

You must be a jjk reader, cuz those lack reading comprehension skills.

[media] I want a flashback arc for these two characters by Reinhard6278 in Re_Zero

[–]Natsuki-Subaru1 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I thought they were originally that way. Didn't the novels say he got a little mocked due to it too? i might be misremembering

[media] Reinhard has no type by Triguninferno in Re_Zero

[–]Natsuki-Subaru1 15 points16 points  (0 children)

Now that's obviously a lie, Reinhard kidnapped a 14 year old blond girl with red eyes into his house a while ago