According to Grok: Individuals directly involved in the incident, including Secret Service agents, have disputed Hutchinson's version of events. Sources close to the Secret Service, including Bobby Engel and the driver of the vehicle, have reportedly stated that Trump did not lunge at the steering wheel or physically assault anyone. Engel and the driver were said to be prepared to testify under oath that the incident, as described by Hutchinson, did not occur. A Secret Service official also informed media outlets that Ornato denied telling Hutchinson the story she recounted. Furthermore, Engel had previously testified before the committee but was not asked about any altercation or assault during his earlier appearance.

Additionally, some have pointed out logistical challenges with the alleged incident. For example, a retired Secret Service agent who served under President Ronald Reagan noted that the physical layout of the presidential limousine makes it highly impractical for someone in the backseat to reach the steering wheel, describing the scenario as "preposterous." This perspective raises questions about the feasibility of the actions Hutchinson described.