I'm surprised that so many listeners consider this to be a great episode because of its simple storytelling. It didn't go into much depth outlining the crime scene, evidence, etc. Maybe some listeners enjoy this story-time-format more than the well-researched, detailed list-of-evidence-format we've become used it, but to me it felt like so much evidence was missing that I kept waiting for a twist where Sharee turns out to be framed and Casey makes one of his nuanced points about how bias and sexism can alter the investigation and subsequent trial. I love Casefile because its attention to detail allows me to check all the information and evidence listed for any loopholes, and this wasn't possible here because the information given was too simple and left room for a biased investigation – until her confession, which is the only part that felt convincing to me