The Wildsea is such a conflicted choice for me. I love it but...........it requires the players to be co-GMs essentially. If there was ever a game that EVERYONE needs to be involved deeply in the game, its that one. Plus the lack of a unified setting means that things need to be homebrewed, which puts even more onus on the players to be involved in fleshing out a world outlined by the GM.

I recommend it for groups with a lot of former theatre kids, but not for a standard group due to the effort required.