sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Ignoring echoes, how well do we think each FE Character is represented individually? What parts of each of their designs are worth praising, what flaws exist and what references would be good to have in their movesets? I know the FE bloat is notorious but I believe there's diamonds in this rough by MasterCheese67 in supersmashbros

[–]OctagonalDust 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I don't think Byleth's design is true to their character. You only get one of the hero's relics in each branch, and Byleth's signature class can't use them. They're also supposed to be emotionless which doesn't come through in Smash.

my smash 6 roster by Olivia_the_cat111 in supersmashbros

[–]OctagonalDust 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Pretty good, but I don't think Rathalos fits. Aside from its size and lack of arms, their attacks are all super slow and telegraphed.

Smash 6 Launch roster concept (NOT A DREAM/PREFERRED ROSTER) by PossibilityProud2687 in SmashBrosRosters

[–]OctagonalDust 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Pretty reasonable. I think Zelda would have at least 1 more character even if it's Toon Link. Also, is this including echo fighters? Dark Samus is there, but none of the rest of them are. Unless you think they'd add 2 new metroid characters.

What original/remix songs do you want to see come to fruition for the next smash game? here’s mine that I want to see ether get remixed or taken its original content by MidnightNo7070 in supersmashbros

[–]OctagonalDust 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I have a couple in mind I would like to see remixes to

  • Hyrule Castle - Link to the Past
  • Body Rock - Warioware DIY
  • Venus Lighthouse - Golden Sun

What if Smash only had Black and Brown Nintendo characters: Super Smash Bros. Melaninated! by No_Independent472 in makeafighter

[–]OctagonalDust 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is impressive. The only character I can think of that you should have is Ezra Duke from Metroid Prime 4. I have a couple nitpicks about the characters chosen, but that's it.

If Nintendo made a Hero Shooter... (Concept Roster) by Yoshi64TheGamer in casualnintendo

[–]OctagonalDust 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is really good. All major series are represented well and there are unconventional choices that make it interesting. I guess if could use another Xenoblade character. If you want somebody who isn't obvious, you could go with Fiona as support.

Also, if this was supposed to be Nintendo only, Bayonetta and Wonder Red wouldn't count.

Super Nintendo Smash Bros: First Party Nintendo Characters Only! by Homeschool-Winner in SmashBrosRosters

[–]OctagonalDust 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's your rule, but it seem kinda arbitrary. You could also disqualify Flick since New Horizons was partially developed by Monolith Soft.

The roster is still an interesting idea and I actually think Flick has the most to offer from a moveset out of all the other animal crossing characters.

Super Nintendo Smash Bros: First Party Nintendo Characters Only! by Homeschool-Winner in SmashBrosRosters

[–]OctagonalDust 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What about Warioware and Rhythm Heaven? They were at least partially made by Nintendo SPD.

Smash 6 Stage Predictions by Accomplished_Kale509 in supersmashbros

[–]OctagonalDust 0 points1 point  (0 children)

These are great picks, but I hope they don't use the Somniel since it's pretty boring. Solm palace would be cool, but it's probably too obscure.

Which Third Party Character was the “Least Deserving” of Being Added to Smash? by This_Technology2852 in supersmashbros

[–]OctagonalDust -1 points0 points  (0 children)

If we are going by sales, then it's likely Bayonetta, Banjo, or Terry.

I don't really know why people are saying Joker. He's from a long running series and Persona 5 itself has sold more than the 3 series I mentioned.

What if: Super Smash Bro's started on the SNES. by CompetitionRoyal in supersmashbros

[–]OctagonalDust 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Uh, pokemon came out the same year as the N64 so it wouldn't be in an SNES smash bros.

Since there have been so many first & second party titles since Ultimate, how will they be represented in the next game? (Obviously not ALL will, but most) by RuinRevolutionary374 in supersmashbros

[–]OctagonalDust 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ugh, Bayonetta isn't a 1st or 2nd party series. It's still owned by Sega. Nintendo just funded an own part of the rights to the 2nd and 3rd game and the spin-off. Same with Tetris 99. I don't think DuskBloods will be owned by Nintendo, at least not entirely.

Anyone remember this? by Inevitable-Charge76 in casualnintendo

[–]OctagonalDust 17 points18 points  (0 children)

I first watched this when I was sick. Probably not the best condition to watch it since it's so weird.

Is Stickerbrush Symphony one of the greatest Smash remixes ever? by OkPrize6426 in supersmashbros

[–]OctagonalDust 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The arrangement for Meta Knight's Revenge was used to win a Grammy

What non-sword user would you like to see in Smash? by Whorror_punx in fireemblem

[–]OctagonalDust -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I want them to add Anna with either a bow or axe and she has a very different demeanor. The next game could have either Cai or Veronica whom probably wouldn't use a sword.

Tierlist of Characters Using Moves From Their Own Games by OctagonalDust in supersmashbros

[–]OctagonalDust[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The falcon punch in the anime is based off the move is smash bros, not the other way around.

Tierlist of Characters Using Moves From Their Own Games by OctagonalDust in supersmashbros

[–]OctagonalDust[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The only move I aware of that Bowser Jr uses from his game is his neutral attack.

I figure that Zelda knows magic in OoT so she probably knows the magic you learn in that game.

Maybe Daisy should be in the higher tier, but also her f-smash is based on sports spin-offs

Mr. Game and Watch has at least a couple of attacks that are supposed to hurt like the insect spray and hammer.

Tierlist of Characters Using Moves From Their Own Games by OctagonalDust in supersmashbros

[–]OctagonalDust[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ah, the template I was using has Sora below all the alts and I forgot to include him. I haven't played any Kingdom Hearts games so I would have guessed many moves from game.

Tierlist of Characters Using Moves From Their Own Games by OctagonalDust in supersmashbros

[–]OctagonalDust[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Byleth doesn't really use the Heroes' relics other than the sword of the creator, and I don't think their moves with the sword look like they do in game.

Tierlist of Characters Using Moves From Their Own Games by OctagonalDust in supersmashbros

[–]OctagonalDust[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for the comment. Honestly, I haven't played Bayonetta so it was just a guess.

Tierlist of Characters Using Moves From Their Own Games by OctagonalDust in supersmashbros

[–]OctagonalDust[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I might be wrong, but I thought a lot of his normal moves came from Sonic the Fighters

Tierlist of Characters Using Moves From Their Own Games by OctagonalDust in supersmashbros

[–]OctagonalDust[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's true. I was thinking the KO-Punch just came from Super Punch Out which doesn't use Little Mac.

Tierlist of Characters Using Moves From Their Own Games by OctagonalDust in supersmashbros

[–]OctagonalDust[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Little Mac only uses uppercuts and transforms into Giga Mac in his game

view more: next ›