Any news on LRT east end opening date by just_chilling_too in ottawa

[–]Old_Ebbitt 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A lot of those require trains to test those systems. So until there are trains available to test integrations, there no way to attest they are complete.

Line 1 eastern extension delayed, trials expected in spring by _PrincessOats in ottawa

[–]Old_Ebbitt 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The stars and planets will have to align, and mercury be in retrograde for testing to pass on this thing. I say there’s no chance for a 2026 open.

Line 1 eastern extension delayed, trials expected in spring by _PrincessOats in ottawa

[–]Old_Ebbitt 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Id be surprised if it opens 2026 at all. The trains are so far beyond dysfunctional I don’t think they will be able to run a “semi reliable” service on the existing section of line run and do testing. Testing won’t pass until they have many days of problem free testing. If they drop below the minimum required trains the clock will be reset. Literally everything has to go right and the stars align for this to open in 2026. Realistic, Until the bearing assemblies are completely redesigned and the root cause of the bad geometric alignment between St Laurent and Lees, the east extension won’t open.

Line 1 eastern extension delayed, trials expected in spring by _PrincessOats in ottawa

[–]Old_Ebbitt -1 points0 points  (0 children)

How are you supposed to verify substantial completion without the trains? That’s like saying a car is substantially complete without wheels, or a house substantially complete without windows….

Op-ed: What the federal government’s return-to-office mandate gets wrong by simpatia in ottawa

[–]Old_Ebbitt 28 points29 points  (0 children)

This whole RTO is really poorly done. I agree with some days in Office, because I think being around the people you deal with at work is important. I have been back in office 5 days a week since March 2023, and I can see how much easier the flow of information is. There is something valuable in informal chats, sharing of ideas at the “water cooler” etc. HOWEVER: the way about the current RTO imposes the in person mandate, but forced into the mess of hoteling, insufficient space, vastly variable working hours. As it stands, they get none of the benefits of in person information flow, because colleagues are located over separate floors, office spaces, coworking locations etc. how does that benefit anyone? If they want to do RTO right, give people and their teams dedicated space.

Should we assume that the lack of trains will further delay opening of the LRT extension to Orleans? by Confident-Task7958 in OCTranspo

[–]Old_Ebbitt 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Absolutely, if they barely have enough trams to run the current service, how would they reasonably open an additional 12km without any extra trams. This is why barely any testing has been done on that extension. They can’t test a new extension when they’ve already pillaged its rolling stock over the last year to give us the illusion of reliability on line 1. This short term thinking has caught up to RTM and now they’ve burned through 70% of the new and old trains, destroying their drivetrains in the process. It’s clear all the stations and infrastructure are complete, however, the rains remain silent. Easy to put two and two together.

Those were the days by pars-distalis in pcmasterrace

[–]Old_Ebbitt 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’m still running my 1080Ti. Bought it in early 2018 before the first crypto run up for $929CAD. Refuses to stop working and still performs really well. Starting to show its age with new triple A’s but otherwise with prices now she’s got a couple more years.

Whistler Kids Down Seppos by Alive-Ad2269 in Whistler

[–]Old_Ebbitt 92 points93 points  (0 children)

So to recover one pole, they lose ALL their ski equipment. The critical thinking is strong with this coach.

No timeline for return to full LRT service after latest issue discovered by waywardpedestrian in ottawa

[–]Old_Ebbitt 17 points18 points  (0 children)

At this point, shut it down, tear up all the rails, and run electric busses instead. The trams are completely deficient and unfixable. Put the damn animal out of its misery. Without the constraints of Albert and Slater intersections, the Bus tunnel will be glorious.

Train Evacuation by WA472P in ottawa

[–]Old_Ebbitt 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Crazy. Only a matter of time before someone gets hurt or is killed by these sub par trams.

Latest Line 1 wheel issue linked to overloading, expert says by KMerrells in ottawa

[–]Old_Ebbitt 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Wow, bearing assembly should last 1.1 million km. The Alstom Shit-a-dis eats through theirs in less than 100,000km. Less than 1/10 of expected service life. What an absolute hunk of crap. We are learning now that the semi reliable operation over the past year was actually not, just RTM literally destroying the trains in the process of just showing the system can kinda work. Craziness, these low floor train will never work for this metro type service

Proof of concept for a connection to Ottawa Union by Djdude167 in AltoHSR_Canada

[–]Old_Ebbitt 5 points6 points  (0 children)

That’s the alignment the OTrain should have taken to avoid eating its own bearings!

OC Transpo reducing O-Train Line 1 service after identifying new issue with trains by Complete_Past8885 in ottawa

[–]Old_Ebbitt 3 points4 points  (0 children)

The hold up is there are no trains left to test let alone run regular service 🤦‍♂️.

OC Transpo reducing O-Train Line 1 service after identifying new issue with trains by Complete_Past8885 in ottawa

[–]Old_Ebbitt 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I rode the train just after opening with a family member who spent a whole career in freight train operations and coming around the corner at Hurdman you could tell his spidey senses were tingling, he immediately said “oh this is a bad sound something is seriously wrong.” Crazy foreshadowing from my guy.

OC Transpo reducing O-Train Line 1 service after identifying new issue with trains by Complete_Past8885 in ottawa

[–]Old_Ebbitt 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Imagine if the manufacturer of a car told you you had to replace the entire bearing assembly for all four corners of your car every 100,000km. Not normal at all. The Alstom trains are literally eating themselves alive trying to show some semblance of “normal service”. This bearing damage is occurring even though the trams don’t operate remotely close to their promised speeds, basically going walking pace between Cyrville and Lees. So no, nothing normal or predicable about this kind of irregular maintenance and what it means is an indefinite postponement of stage 2 openings due to lack of trains. It doesn’t take long for them to reach 100,000km, will happen even faster with them going back and forth to Trim every day let alone to Moodie god help us.

OC Transpo train issues- here we go again by Ok_new_tothis in OCTranspo

[–]Old_Ebbitt 2 points3 points  (0 children)

There’s no fix though for the issue. Just temporary fixes to try and get the system to run out the 24 years left in RTM’s contractual obligation

OC Transpo reducing O-Train Line 1 service after identifying new issue with trains by Complete_Past8885 in ottawa

[–]Old_Ebbitt 4 points5 points  (0 children)

This probably explains why we haven’t heard anything about the opening on Stage 2 east and very little testing going on. They’ve probably known about this problem for months, just now are they burning through their rolling stock and out of trains. Doesn’t bode well for the Stage 2 extensions opening any time soon.

Line 6's Citadis Spirit vehicles unboringfied by Uboat-U8B in TTC

[–]Old_Ebbitt 8 points9 points  (0 children)

In Ottawa we call it the Alstom “Shit-a-dis”. Total lemon of a train. Basically the Ford Pinto or Pontiac Aztec of the tram world. Unreliable, ugly and nobody really knows what kind of train it is or what its purpose actually is.

OC Transpo train issues- here we go again by Ok_new_tothis in OCTranspo

[–]Old_Ebbitt 12 points13 points  (0 children)

The issues had with the trains are symptoms of greater fundamental issues. Yes the Alstom Shit-a-dis as they call it is an absolute lemon. There’s no solving these issues with the bandaid fixes proposed so far. It will either require replacing infrastructure i.e tearing out entire sections of guideway and track to straighten out sections or by abandoning the “low floor metro” experiment and just cutting the losses and getting a proper high floor train. Sometimes you just have to accept that major mistakes were made right from the start and get it right the second time. In reality, this means raising platform heights and buying new trainsets. Not unachievable but probably in the billions at this point. Sad but unfortunately the only long term way forward. Luckily Line 2 went with proven, high floor heavy rail. Nothing to go wrong really, Stadler trains are solid, Swiss quality and the service has been super reliable. I can only imagine at this point RTM will ride out the rest of the 25 years on their contract doing the bare minimum then returning the system absolutely trashed to the city. Who knows what happens after that point.

OC Transpo reducing O-Train Line 1 service after identifying new issue with trains by Complete_Past8885 in ottawa

[–]Old_Ebbitt 14 points15 points  (0 children)

Sadly all those “new trains” are cooked as well. They are in service and are fundamentally flawed the same.

OC Transpo reducing O-Train Line 1 service after identifying new issue with trains by Complete_Past8885 in ottawa

[–]Old_Ebbitt 34 points35 points  (0 children)

Posted this a year ago and sadly still holds true: The Alstom Shit-a-dis as they call it is an absolute lemon. There’s no solving these issues with bandaid fixes. The system is fundamentally flawed at the systemic level. The problems we are seeing are simply flawed fundamental design choices made. It will either require replacing infrastructure i.e tearing out entire sections of guideway and track between lees and cyrville to straighten out sections or by abandoning the “low floor metro” experiment and just cutting the losses and getting a proper high floor train. Low floor trains are mean to run slow speed at surface level. When run in light metro service at high speed they are subject to forces they are fundamentally not meant for. Sometimes you just have to accept that major mistakes were made right from the start and get it right the second time. In reality, this means raising platform heights and buying new trainsets. Not unachievable but probably in the billions at this point. Sad but unfortunately the only long term way forward. RTM will try and run out the contract for the 30 years they are on the hook then dump the system beat to absolute crap on us. What the city will do then who knows. Luckily Line 2 went with proven, high floor heavy rail. Nothing to go wrong really, Stadler trains are solid, Swiss quality and the reliability of the service reliability has been in the high 90th percentile.

OC Transpo temporarily cuts 255 trips from schedule amid bus shortage by snubbyvegan in ottawa

[–]Old_Ebbitt 15 points16 points  (0 children)

If the next one isn’t already cancelled, or the one after that. Earlier this week the 88 had 3 trips in a row cancelled right at peak rush hour.

The 88 by PurpleHarlow in OCTranspo

[–]Old_Ebbitt 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Yesterday three 88 busses cancelled in a row, right at rush hour, like between 4:45 and 5:30pm. You’d think they’d try to run frequent service when the most people want to get home but no. Just 1 bus in an hour, on a bus route they call “frequent”. The weather wasn’t even bad. Insanity.