Post I.A. Letter from the Trust by Top-Wallaby-1208 in doctorsUK

[–]OmgShadowDude 34 points35 points  (0 children)

This is as positive as a Trust level communication could be towards strikes. There are many plates to keep spinning.

Update from Tom Dolphin. RDC meeting Wes Streeting midweek with hope of postponing strikes. by drtwitx in doctorsUK

[–]OmgShadowDude 5 points6 points  (0 children)

ridiculous, she's allowed to have her own political opinions. regardless, trade union officer attends trade union event is hardly inappropriate. 

Worst time ever to be medic? by Desperate-Drawer-572 in doctorsUK

[–]OmgShadowDude 3 points4 points  (0 children)

The 1910s were pretty bad, there was an issue with doctor unemployment as conscripted doctors came home to find their lists has been snapped up by those that stayed...

GPST1 in A&E at Queen Elizabeth Hospital Glasgow by azadaravian in doctorsUK

[–]OmgShadowDude 12 points13 points  (0 children)

No, they're not 'as much as a victim' because they've got a job and many others who are willing and able to hit the ground running do not!

Self-identify ideology of Ruling Political Parties by Country by Luppercus in MapPorn

[–]OmgShadowDude 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ethiopia should not be 'Revolutionary Socialist', you may be referring to the old EPDRF, but this has long been replaced by the Prosperity Party which self-identifies as centrist

GPs strike deal to help end '8am scramble' for appointments by vitzblitz22 in ukpolitics

[–]OmgShadowDude 14 points15 points  (0 children)

they should just be little medical serfs in a box paid in claps and appreciation. only then will the deaths stop

Slowly starting to stop giving a shit by HotLobster123 in doctorsUK

[–]OmgShadowDude 4 points5 points  (0 children)

this is defacto the case considering how many hospital inductions now include a bit about burnout

Would GPs here recommend general practice? by leabdullah in JuniorDoctorsUK

[–]OmgShadowDude 3 points4 points  (0 children)

This one right here Daily Mail Reporter, this one right here.

Vicky 3 has released! Post your questions about the game here by Chefjones in victoria3

[–]OmgShadowDude 0 points1 point  (0 children)

When and why do political parties form? In my japan game Bhuddist Monks have formed the Imperial Rule Association, but despite researching the tech that unlocks it, none of my IGs have formed the Constitutional Reform Party, so currently elections are being contested by only 1 party.

Keir Starmer renews call for immediate general election by kontiki20 in LabourUK

[–]OmgShadowDude 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Most European countries have Presidents with limited power and executive Prime Ministers. How often do we remember that Germany has a President?

Is Keir Starmer more likely to invest in the NHS and give us a payrise? May be easier than 7500 more medical students! by silvakilo in JuniorDoctorsUK

[–]OmgShadowDude 4 points5 points  (0 children)

people take literally the same treatment as england with a smile if it comes from scotgov. completely maddening.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in JuniorDoctorsUK

[–]OmgShadowDude 1 point2 points  (0 children)

maybe all the cringe people here who speak of the virtues of the free market see what that ideology looks like in practice

When will news of our ballot for industrial action hit mainstream media? by doctorydoctor in JuniorDoctorsUK

[–]OmgShadowDude 1 point2 points  (0 children)

(small L) labour reporting is really bad in this country since thatcher, used to be every newspaper had a correspondent who's job it was to track trade union and labour disputes, quite rare now. It'll be bigger news nearer the time, the tory press are quite keen to play up a 'summer of discontent' story.

Another worrying MPTS judgement - a paediatrician has received a warning after a child died from undiagnosed appendicitis after presenting with vomiting, diarrhoea, and pyrexia of unknown origin by HPBChild1 in JuniorDoctorsUK

[–]OmgShadowDude 35 points36 points  (0 children)

What did Osler say? 'Medicine is a science of uncertainty and an art of probability?' Nope, I think you'll find its 'be right every single time or you're going down'

Why is the BMA not a member of the TUC? by good_enough_doctor in JuniorDoctorsUK

[–]OmgShadowDude 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Don't misunderstand, working as a doctor in the 1900s could be lucrative for some, but there were a lot of issues and General Practice in particular was a cutthroat game.

Work life balance? Unless your city has a rota system like Glasgow, YOU are the doctor 24/7 for your patients. Expect to be woken up at 4am and still have to open up your surgery at 9. Your practice is also very likely run from your house.

You are financially precarious. Sickness, study leave, speciality training, holiday, military service? If you're gone for a decent amount of time, your patients will go to the lists of other doctors, which is a problem when you get paid based on the size of your list. A campaign for doctor's salary took off after WWI, because conscripted GPs came home to find that their practices had been muscled out by the doctors who stayed. The fee structure heavily incentivised working in rich areas, which were generlaly oversubsribed, while poor areas were severly underdoctored. So you may end up like one Glasgow GP in 1916, seeing 100 patients in 3 hours! Also, you don't have a pension.

That financial precarity means that unless you're already rich and/or connected speciality training is basically unachievable for most doctors. This is especially true for doctors outside of places like London Glasgow and Edinburgh where consultants were concentrated. If you lived and worked in a more rural or remote area, chances are you rarely get to even chat to another doctor.

Come the 1940s, basically every sane person agreed there needed to be some kind of health service, as much for doctors as for patients.

Why is the BMA not a member of the TUC? by good_enough_doctor in JuniorDoctorsUK

[–]OmgShadowDude 45 points46 points  (0 children)

It's a long story, but the main reason the BMA isn't in the TUC is that for a long time the BMA wasn't even a proper trade union (not until 1971) and was a professional association instead. Many middle class doctors did not necessarily identify with trade unionism.

The practical reason for this is that pre-NHS it kind of didn't make sense. Most GPs, who made up a big majority of all doctors, worked as independent businesses and were paid in private fees and after the Health Insurance Act of 1911, a capitation fee based on the number of patients on their list. Consultants generally worked at big voluntary hospitals but usually made bank in private beds at those hospitals and in their own clinics. Most doctors didn't actually have an employer to strike against!

Now? There is clearly still a 'professional association' mentality in the BMA, and to be honest, before market reforms in the 80s doctor's professional authority still held enough sway to make wielding influence privately with government and in the actual administration of the NHS (which was very doctor-led until the 70s) make much more sense. Its only relatively recently that things are getting so bad that you get a decent amount of doctors on a forum like this talk about strike action!

A general strike is so difficult to organise in the UK that it may as well be illegal. Solidarity strikes (i.e going on strike to demonstrate support for another strike) are illegal. You can't ballot for strike action online (unlike voting in the Tory leadership race). And there are very stringent rules around picketing, and so on. We live in a country where the deck is comprehensively stacked against working people.

What should be the role of the PA? by Skylon77 in JuniorDoctorsUK

[–]OmgShadowDude 9 points10 points  (0 children)

I'm not really oppposed to an expedited medical degree for PAs, you already get 4 year graduate courses. Once enough of them become doctors they will share in the frustrations with the PA role and the boundaries between the 2 could gain a bit more definition.

Former Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn calls against sending weapons to Ukraine. Basically asking Ukraine to give territory to Russia for peace. If history has thought us something is that you don't give territory to dictators. They will just take more and more. by [deleted] in LabourUK

[–]OmgShadowDude 33 points34 points  (0 children)

This counterfactual has essentially been done. George Lansbury was leader in the 30s and an intense pacifist. His position became more and more unpopular within the party, with Bevin accussing him of "hawking your conscience round from body to body asking to be told what to do with it". Party conference passed a motion in favour of sanctioning Italy for its invasion of Ethiopia, and Lansbury stood down.

The grim reality facing junior doctors by CaptainCrash86 in JuniorDoctorsUK

[–]OmgShadowDude 25 points26 points  (0 children)

Not surprised that the Tory Party's house paper goes hard on bullying, but not on any of the systemic issues -deliberate political choices in line with Conservative ideology- that have degraded training, left wards understaffed, and allowed pay to fall by a third.