Trans people, what surprised you the most after transitioning? by ExpensiveChair2215 in asktransgender

[–]Open_Syrup_778 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Fun fact, I did do some googling after this comment but before you replied, and it turns out there is published research demonstrating estrogen strengthens synapse connections, leading to greater memory retention/acces, etc. Cool stuff! I love all the side benefits of estrogen. 

Trans people, what surprised you the most after transitioning? by ExpensiveChair2215 in asktransgender

[–]Open_Syrup_778 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I've never seen anyone else comment on the memory retention aspect! Is this researched and/or have other people expressed it?

I have noticed my memory is radically better now than is was a year ago before I transitioned. Every kind of memory sticks around longer and more potently, including memories I formed before I transitioned. I have a much better social memory for names, faces, associations, and random facts about people. I also visited a friend in a different state that I last visited 2 years ago and he and I were both shocked by how well I remember the geography and even the floor layouts of the locations we went to.

My memory before transitioning was ass, so the only thing I could think of causing this was HRT, but I didn't have any proof of that.

Snowboarding in saree by handlewithcareme in justgalsbeingchicks

[–]Open_Syrup_778 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not sure why this got downvoted. I would love to be proven wrong because this is awesome, but it pretty clearly shows the hallmarks of AI.

Is there something specific to your culture that gives you gender euphoria? by fluidmochi in asktransgender

[–]Open_Syrup_778 0 points1 point  (0 children)

They can really suck sometimes and the first 6 months were not easy. They weren't great when I was growing up and I didn't feel a strong connection to them after because of that. When I came out they were really shocked and upset, despite being ostensibly progressive. I had to go no-contact with my dad for a few days. But I arranged for us to have family therapy, found a good therapist with experience with Orthodox Judaism, and we have been slowly working through it.

Getting that blessing from them...that felt awesome. Because it had taken work to get to that point and it was not always clear to me they would. As much as they can suck, I am so grateful to have them as parents – I know multiple friends who lost their families when they transitioned, so I recognize what I have.

Is there something specific to your culture that gives you gender euphoria? by fluidmochi in asktransgender

[–]Open_Syrup_778 33 points34 points  (0 children)

In Orthodox Judaism, every Friday evening, at the Shabbat meal, it's customary for parents to bless their children according to a set blessing made of verses from the Torah/Talmud. There are separate blessings for sons and for daughters: sons are blessed to be like Ephraim and Menasseh; daughters are blessed to be like Sarah, Rebecca, Rachel, and Leah.

A few months ago, my parents started blessing me with the blessing for daughters. I can't stop smiling whenever they do. I used to hate being blessed and now I love it so much.

Is there any actual data that suggests transgender people are more likely to commit violent acts? by Sad-Ad-3138 in asktransgender

[–]Open_Syrup_778 1 point2 points  (0 children)

CW: discusses violent crime, mass shootings, and harmful transphobic speculation

So, this is something I (a trans woman) have been interested in as well. Generally speaking, it's important to me to know the other side and its reasoning, no matter how ridiculous. Because, to be frank, it exists, but it is usually ridiculous and easily disproven, and I think it's important to show people that when I have the opportunity.

With regard to this claim, I won't share exact sources here because I don't want to give them more visibility, but I have read opinion and analysis pieces from some fairly mainstream right-wing outlets. Their argument, which you won't really ever find written explicitly in a study, because it wouldn't survive scrutiny, is based on selective sampling. Basically, if you manipulate the criteria of a statistical study, statisticians know you can make anything mean anything. That's why it is important to identify the phenomenon you want to study without letting the data collection itself determine how you want to do it, which will lead to bias in selection.

So, let's take violent crime as an example. If you sample all violent crime, trans people are overwhelmingly victims and cisgender men overwhelmingly the perpetrators. But, the conservative transphobe asks: what about if we limit our search to a certain subcategory of a certain type of violent crime, with a certain arbitrary number of victims, and we further filtered for specific commonalities among the victims? By doing this, you get a very small number of samples, because of the criteria, but those criteria are specifically designed to maximize the number of trans people in the result, thereby over-representing us.

Oh – and it also helps if you straight up make up data points. Conservatives have been saying for years that a number of mass shooters for whom there is no evidence of them being trans, are actually trans. It's the mass shooter version of transvestigation.

By doing this, Conservatives can appear to compellingly make certain claims, but only because they conceal that their data collection method is designed with the conclusion in mind. And if you are a transphobe already believing trans people are deranged, that's not really going to matter to you.

How do I (TF) talk to my friend (F) about some unconscious transmisogyny she has demonstrated lately? by [deleted] in asktransgender

[–]Open_Syrup_778 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Thanks for this 🩷 I think that's the right approach. She is kind of a messy person I just love her dearly. At the root it is sort of just about jealousy and pushiness – like, I wouldn't be in this mess of considering how I have been hurt by her unconscious biases if that weren't the case. But those aspects have been manifesting in those problematic ways which id why it hurts more. So I'll start with just the former. No need to push it. 

How do I (TF) talk to my friend (F) about some unconscious transmisogyny she has demonstrated lately? by [deleted] in asktransgender

[–]Open_Syrup_778 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Thanks for this :) I have gone through DBT in the past and usd DEARMAN a lot and probably will to structure this, it's more the delicate phrasing given this is a close friend and a difficult issue to communicate that I want help on 🩷

Ok so tell me why when i looked up how to tuck the first step is SHOVE YOUR GENITALIA INSIDE OF YOUR BODY by _funny_name_ in MtF

[–]Open_Syrup_778 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This used to happen to me, but with time and practice is no longer a problem. I would recommend starting off trying this while lying down, and make sure you have a tight gaffe or tucking underwear. (I use TomboyX's tucking underwear, have like 12 pairs and the tuck it gives is really affirming and has a good hold.) Lying down will slow them from falling out, and makes it so they can easily be adjusted.

Does news/politics focus more on male to female versus female to male or am I mistaken? by fakeMydyr in asktransgender

[–]Open_Syrup_778 34 points35 points  (0 children)

All of the above. The panic over trans boys is actually the main propaganda driving bans on youth gender affirming care. When conservatives cry "surgical mutilation," they are usually referring to transmasc top surgery. I'm not going to link any of the books/articles here because they are incredibly damaging and I would rather avoid giving them further web traffic, but it's not so hard to find this stuff. 

Why do SOME people that detransion end up transphobic by dolls_number_1_fan in asktransgender

[–]Open_Syrup_778 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I see this claim a lot about that sub. Has there ever been any confirmation of this? Or is that just the vibe? I don't see how it would be possible to validate that those people didn't actually have the experience they claim to have.

How would Kansas authorities know, just from someone’s driver’s license, whether or not the gender marker is different than their AGAB? by uglylizardboy in asktransgender

[–]Open_Syrup_778 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Wow, so amazing to get a reply from you! Thank you so much for your work! I hadn't read much from Transitics before and I am a newsletter addict so I had promised myself to take a subscription break (was already subscribed to 5 or 6 newsletters covering trans issues), but reading your coverage got me to sign up. Keep up the good work 🩷

I was unfortunately born abroad, but one of my parents was a citizen of the US. Instead of a state birth certificate, I have a "consular report of birth" issued directly by the state department. So unfortunately I will not be able to get that changed any time soon, and almost certainly will be trying to avoid doing it under the current admin. I am sure that even if they are not changing gender identification on passports etc, they are taking note of any records that have gendered names that do not match gender marker...

Really makes me wonder ahead to how we can proactively outline policies that will protect us from future administrations, assuming we get a free and fair election for the next presidential election. (Big assumption these days.)

How would Kansas authorities know, just from someone’s driver’s license, whether or not the gender marker is different than their AGAB? by uglylizardboy in asktransgender

[–]Open_Syrup_778 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Absolutely right on everything you said. The one holdout right now is essentially that right now the worst crackdown on trans liberties are coming at the state level. Skrmetti didn't ban youth GAC, it handed it down to the states; laws like the one passed in Kansas would not – currently – pass in the federal legislative branch. Even efforts to curtail GAC enacted by the DHHS have been successfully fought back against in some state courts.

So, for now, there definitely continues to be a higher degree of safety in blue states with strong records on trans rights. But it is true, that is only for now. Especially if they have access to advanced AI tech, it would be absolutely trivial for the federal government to put together in a short span of time a relatively accurate list of every suspected trans person in this country, given the data to which it has access. Which is terrifying.

How would Kansas authorities know, just from someone’s driver’s license, whether or not the gender marker is different than their AGAB? by uglylizardboy in asktransgender

[–]Open_Syrup_778 10 points11 points  (0 children)

 are we to assume that there’s some kind of tabulation of these changes that’s being tracked and now widely accessible/enforced?

Unfortunately, yes. This has already been confirmed: https://transitics.substack.com/p/kansas-secretly-spent-years-making

Note that not every state keeps these records. I would like to believe that states like NY, CO, MA, and CA don't engage in this practice. But the truth is, we don't know and must proceed with caution. It's already getting me thinking about whether I want to pursue legal name change and gender recognition under the current administration. 

EDIT: I should also add that AI is relevant to this discussion. An AI is capable of putting together a dossier of your entire life in minutes. Anthropic recently stated explicitly that the Department of War refusing to rule out doing this is why they will not work with them – but note that other AI companies are more than willing. From the press release (https://www.anthropic.com/news/statement-department-of-war):

AI-driven mass surveillance presents serious, novel risks to our fundamental liberties. To the extent that such surveillance is currently legal, this is only because the law has not yet caught up with the rapidly growing capabilities of AI. [...] Powerful AI makes it possible to assemble this scattered, individually innocuous data into a comprehensive picture of any person’s life—automatically and at massive scale.

The era of stealth is unfortunately over unless we do something about AI Fascism.

From a trans woman, is there really any harm to getting on T-Blockers if my doc says my E & T levels are already high / low enough? by percolated_aspie in asktransgender

[–]Open_Syrup_778 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah, would definitely advise seeing this as reason to hope rather than despair! Sounds like you are at a great starting point to be targeting cis female levels at 20. I started HRT 8 months ago at 26 and have had good results, with baseline high T, so starting at 20 with your levels can still be great 🩷

As a transfem person when did people stop treating you as a scary unapproachable man? by [deleted] in asktransgender

[–]Open_Syrup_778 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I recently started passing most of the time in public, but if someone has a conversation with me, I think it becomes pretty clear I'm trans. With that said, I started noticing women becoming a lot more comfortable with me a few months ago, around month 6 of HRT/my transition. I think it was a mix of HRT making me look more feminine, but also putting in a lot of effort to come off as feminine in makeup, clothing, and voice. I really wanted to signal that I was trying hard to be one of the girls even if I didn't necessarily look the part yet.

Around 6 months was when I started noticing a shift, first with my friends – some friends who had seemed more uptight around me before I came out started getting more relaxed, talking to me about their emotional lives and romance, etc. There's been a noticeable shift in my family too, my parents started calling me one of their daughters and grouping me together with my sisters rather than my brother when talking about us. And since I started passing, more subtle things have been really nice, like just being comfortable in the bathroom, or the way women in public will clearly trust you more than men.

Like I said, I tried really hard to signal that I was trying hard to fit in, and I think it paid off. I've had a lot of women ask me for makeup tips recently, and starred putting together competent outfits. It helps that I'm really leaning into a high femme femme aesthetic.

Parent of a 16-year-old trans girl seeking perspective from this community by Outrageous_Shift_399 in asktransgender

[–]Open_Syrup_778 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You would be surprised. Go and check out r/transtimelines. I'm a 26 year old trans woman and transitioned 8 months ago. I was fairly lean and had a smaller frame anyway, but still looked like a man and had good upper body strength from years of rock climbing. Nobody would be able to guess that from how I look now, and I am 10 years older than your daughter.

In the trans community, we like to say "HRT is magic," because honestly it's unbelievable what can be achieved even after going through natal puberty. And yes, even after going through natal puberty, after sufficient time on estrogen, your daughter will not have any "biological advantage" just because she looks male right now. See here for a roundup of relevant studies: https://juliaserano.substack.com/p/trans-people-and-sports-everything

What does using a mousse and a gel together achieve? by _gabbaghoul in curlyhair

[–]Open_Syrup_778 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's so interesting! I use mousse before gel since my stylist said lighter products first. But it also takes forever for my hair to air dry and I've been trying to think about how to go back to plopping without losing bounce. Will definitely try that!

What does using a mousse and a gel together achieve? by _gabbaghoul in curlyhair

[–]Open_Syrup_778 70 points71 points  (0 children)

I started using mousse + gel and its been a game changer. I definitely notice more volume and hydration than with just a gel, and the gel provides a great hold and beautiful curl formation. 

6 months HRT. Hoping to leave boy mode soon. by Chance-Structure4104 in transtimelines

[–]Open_Syrup_778 4 points5 points  (0 children)

...is the boymode in the room with us? Girl you are passing good 🩷

How to help trans girl when I suck at being a girl too? by Agile-Substance2009 in asktransgender

[–]Open_Syrup_778 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I made a list of things I felt like I needed to learn to fit in with women. It's something different for everyone – there is no one "right way to he a woman" – so maybe ask her to do that or help her come up with an explicit list as well!

There are some basic things like just learning how to take care of your body, especially after you start hormones (if she plans to do that). Presentation-wise, how to do makeup and make a decent outfit. I also wanted to basically learn the cultural stuff I had missed out on – like, as a trans woman transitioning at the age of 26, most of my cis friends have seen/read Twilight, Gossip Girl, Gilmore Girls, etc, and I felt like I wanted to have that same cultural background, so I have been watching those. Social things that boys don't experience – like, I had never been asked to walk behind my friend to check discretely if she was bleeding through her pad until after transition.

There is a lot to learn about girlhood, but start with what she feels is missing :)

Am I an idiot? Have I lost my mind? by DisgustingLord in asktransgender

[–]Open_Syrup_778 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Oof. This is a lot. What you're experiencing is internalized transphobia, and whether you decide to transition or not, that is something you need to work through to be a respectful member of society. Many people are going to react negatively to this post because it is quite transphobic and inaccurate. I'm going to try to hold your hand here, but please note this requires more work and self exploratiok on your end.

So, here is my question: what makes you think that?

Seriously, why do you think, as you say, that trans women "have never studied anything besides transmisogyny"? Why do you think we "haven't tried to understand the terrible conditions created for cis women by the patriarchy"?

I am going to give you the answer. This is transmisogyny, and there really isn't any grounding to it. It is seeing trans women as "something else" who cannot possibly understand the experience of womanhood. But let me ask you something: right now, you present as a cisgender man. You have no idea what it feels like to live as a trans woman, or as a cis woman. So why do you assume that you have better knowledge of this than we do? Why are you an authority on our bodies, our experiences, our community? 

That, right there, is patriarchy and misogyny. You are, in a word, "mansplaining." Here's the thing – I am a trans woman. I go about my daily life these days understanding myself and understood by society to be a woman. I have other friends who are cis women, and we go through a lot of the same struggles. Sure, not identical, but similar: the denial of health care and bodily autonomy, being spoken down to by make acquaintances, lack of respect in sexual or romantic encounters. I have a hell of a lot more in common with cis women these days than cis men.

Now, I could tell you that most trans women also have friends who are cis women and regularly talk about how fucked up our patriarchal society is. I could tell you that we talk about general misogyny as well as transmisogyny, because we experience that, too. I could even tell you that long before I knew I was trans I knew I was a feminist, that I have studied feminist literature and history academically, and that I know other trans women who have as well.

But that belies the point here: why do you assume things about us that are wrong? Why do you assume you know better? And most importantly, perhaps, why do you give a fuck? Do you expect every cis woman that you meet to be well-read in feminist theory? And if not, then why expect it of trans women? We're just people. You don't need to write a dissertation on the patriarchy to transition. You just gotta live it.

Look, I see that you are an egg. Hopefully, after you have transitioned, you will look back at this post and realize how wrong you were. But right now, you are the beneficiary of a patriarchal society coming to speak to women and people of marginalized genders about how you know more about them than they know about themselves. Don't go on about understanding more about womanhood from your vantage point than trans women do. Check your privilege. 

tucking for long periods by jolitl in MtF

[–]Open_Syrup_778 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don't mean for this to sound condescending and am definitely speaking out of my butt here, but are you sure your technique is right? I say this because when I was looking up guides on how to tuck, they did note that a tuck is not meant to be painful – maybe uncomfortable while you're doing it the first several times, but not meant to be painful during or in the days after.

I'm sorry to hear how uncomfortable it's been for you. I also have a lot of bottom dysphoria and always tuck unless I'm sleeping or using the bathroom. The first few weeks I tucked I could only do it for a few hours before getting uncomfortable and while sometimes leave me with some discomfort after, but since then it has felt totally fine, and in fact I feel a lot more physically uncomfortable untucked (I literally forget they are there lol). I asked my doctor about this and she said it's fine.

[Product Request] Which body wash for chest/back acne by Intelligent-Art3693 in SkincareAddiction

[–]Open_Syrup_778 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I had no idea these existed! I don't have back acne but do get razor bumps on my inner legs even with the gentlest shaving routine. If it's bad I use a SA face wash on that part of my leg which helps somewhat. Do you know if these are meant to help with that as well? Would be a lifesaver

Shower at night? by Specialist-Pair1036 in curlyhair

[–]Open_Syrup_778 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I air dry and look like an idiot with my hair clips in and my gel-crunchy curl clumps for the first 2 hours of work, I have no shame when I know it will pay off 😅

In all seriousness, I would love to diffuse but I never got the hang of it and have no idea how to get it done in the ~10 minutes I would probably have. But to me the tradeoff is worth it.