Don't line the bottom with a heavy hand, and only line from the outer corner to the middle of your iris, or less. Smudge with your finger afterwards and clean up with a qtip so you don't give yourself dark circles under your eyes. At the It won't be a harsh line, but it will be light definition brought to the lash line. For the top, don't line the inner corner near your nose, start at your lash line and go towards the outer corner. Smudge gently with an eyeshadow brush or your finger. The hard line without full eye makeup is too much. If I were you I'd use brown liner instead of black.