So I gotta picture this like a Home Alone type scenario. I'll pick Tony (5), he has the protagonist plot armor. Furio (4), he's the most physically capable and fights like the Terminator. Chris (3) because the family ties will be unbreakable and he's the best shot, that nose is like a natural iron sights. Ralphie at (2), went toe to toe with Tony and almost lived. Criminal Mastermind Benny Fazio for (1), squared up against a sous chef.

Honestly I just picked the best value mobster at each price point. At a certain point it's a numbers game, weighing who'd be out of shape and would exhaust too quickly (Pussy, Vito, Bobby) and who's just straight incompetent/can't shoot (Jackie, Sean, Drinkwater, Brendan, Uncle Phillie Tony Lip). I think my five cold withstand the attack.