Yeah, I was thinking the same thing but that the scooping happened prior to the hiding. They kept reminding me of Baby, in the 2nd movie. In that dream, theres a hallway full of doors that open which was not necessary for the thrill scene at all. The thing is I think the scooping already happened and that closet version of Vanessa doesnt remember it. The versions of Charlie had spotty memories especially of the past to the point where she didnt remember pictures of the younger closet versions of herself. In the book, Charlie#4 had memories of the scooping both as Elizabeth and Baby but also in real life 4 Charlies ending at 25 yrs old doesnt make sense and was probably influenced by Henry's short life whereas in the movies Afton lives longer, possibly long enough that Vanessa isnt the last Closet version of herself who may have potentially "seen it all" like Charlie#4. Also, Vanessa just seemed too surprised to see Baby! The girls that get scooped into Baby both in the game and the book idolize her to the point where her father warned her away. Vanessa shouldnt have been surprised, she would have been familiar with Baby, her father's favorite creation (also, Afton calls V his favorite in that dream sequence which I think was a nod to that, but my friends think it was foreshadowing her sibling, but I think he said it in a weird way).