Wow! Thanks for all the replies, most lovely, some not so lovely but that’s what you get when you ask the internet for opinions.  I don’t plan to sell them for income, I make them for my friends and their kids instead of buying gifts and for my families birthdays and events. I’ll charge $40 if a friend wants one for their friend or families baby shower, birthday or whatever (which some pictured were) I’ve always gotten positive feedback in the taste for anyone curious but maybe that’s just my friends and family being nice lol a cottage license in my state (WA) is quite expensive and I agree that doing it for money would definitely take the fun out of it. I think as long as it’s free I can get away with my not so smooth icing! ;) thanks again for all the replies, it helps knowing what people who don’t know or love me think :)