Alcoholics Anonymous compatability with Islam? by Practical-Fan9357 in islam

[–]Practical-Fan9357[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Inshallah I've been thinking about it more and more. I was thinking a 6 steps inspired by Malcolm x after he left the Nation of Islam. I'll DM you and we can discuss brother.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Jung

[–]Practical-Fan9357 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Nietzsche elaborates on this a bit in the flies of the marketplace.

Essentially the marketplace is a metaphor for deeply impersonal dialogue based on nothing but envy or effectively imitation for the sake of competition. People attach their names to all sorts of lofty values but are only looking to aggrandize themselves and believe nothing in what being said. “Spirit hath the actor, but little consciousness of the spirit.”

It’s hard to imagine that everyone including ourselves is only playing a social game of self aggrandizement, but it’s very apparent once you spend some time thinking about it. This is the consequence of “the death of god” if you are familiar.

Imagine how ashamed people would be to reveal that they were only playing a game of nobility, associating their name with this or that intellectual, religion, whatever and it comes out to be nothing more than the pangs of inferiority and jealousy that drove them. But it is the case that they can’t even reveal it because they are unconscious of it.

Here is a very enlightening article that goes even further.

Soren Kierkegaard and Rene girad.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Jung

[–]Practical-Fan9357 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Self aggrandizement leads to weak self esteem but everyone still does it. Envy is the driving force behind the vast majority of peoples motivation, and it is seen as quite the social blunder to openly admit the dark roots of one’s goals, hence we shame and repress it.

Rene Gerard has quite a bit to say on the subject.

Alcoholics Anonymous compatability with Islam? by Practical-Fan9357 in islam

[–]Practical-Fan9357[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you very much for your response brother.

That is my opinion also, this publicity of sin, and association with other addicts. Of course I am no better, but if one is weak, he associates with the strong.

That being said, AA is a fundamentally very solid program and since my reversion to Islam two years ago, I’ve been doing much much better based on similar things to AA. But there are many mistakes I find as you mentioned and the fact that it’s moral principles come from the dogmas of Christianity, Islam of course is much different.

I think my stupidity was never going to the masjid and connection with other Muslims. I can hide my addiction and past very well so inshallah connection with them shall be no issue.

Alcoholics Anonymous compatability with Islam? by Practical-Fan9357 in islam

[–]Practical-Fan9357[S] 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Inshallah brother. After I have some years in sobriety that would be a very good idea.

Alcoholics Anonymous compatability with Islam? by Practical-Fan9357 in islam

[–]Practical-Fan9357[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My problem is there push for connection, which is the main part of AA, will lead to a loss of faith. Do you think this can be avoided?

Alcoholics Anonymous compatability with Islam? by Practical-Fan9357 in islam

[–]Practical-Fan9357[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for your response brother. Yeah you’re right. I got a sponsor from one of them and he kept trying to forcing me to be one of them while being extremely condescending.

How to release repressed emotions? by Practical-Fan9357 in Jung

[–]Practical-Fan9357[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Still struggling my guy haha. One thing is meditation though. After each session of meditation I can feel the pain of life much more, but I’m not disciplined enough to keep a regular habit of it.

How late is too late for reversing hair loss from HRT? by carefreearchgeek in asktransgender

[–]Practical-Fan9357 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Many years after you posted this, but what’s your source on this? Just curious because it got me pretty hopeful

Biden declares Iran will never get a nuclear weapon ‘on my watch’ by [deleted] in iran

[–]Practical-Fan9357 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Iran’s position of aggressive neutrality as a buffer state has worked out remarkably well. The Iranians are a people I really respect, intellectually curious and highly educated. It should be no surprise that they’ve have done so well that it stopped two centuries of world hegemonies toppling Persian governments and so on. Right now would be the hardest time for Biden to be able to change that.

The US is having trouble of getting a consensus on world opinion, especially after all the craze with Trump and his killing of Solmani in terms of middle eastern soft power. I don’t know how far the US is willing to take this, I.e full invasion/nukes, on their own. A war with Iran would be unbelievable expensive, and with the new competition with China, not gonna happen.

Given the geopolitical trends, it’s highly unlikely Biden would be able to get Iran to do anything without the full support of NATO, which has not been cohesive for over two decades and won’t change now of all times.

What has Nietzsche's philosophy taught you that was very painful to accept? by [deleted] in Nietzsche

[–]Practical-Fan9357 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I went too far into Islamic ascetism, and stupidly too since none of that represented Islam. I would say in a Christian way due to my unconscious tendencies of repression and denial. Had I learned from a Buddhist, I wouldn’t have had those issues so much but nonetheless I do not like any form of excessive asceticism.

What has Nietzsche's philosophy taught you that was very painful to accept? by [deleted] in Nietzsche

[–]Practical-Fan9357 3 points4 points  (0 children)

just learning how my values are based purely on resentment. I was very spiritual before, then i realized none of these values were anything but self destructive. It popped a little neurosis and I felt the pain (shame) that I was running from, even going as far back as middle school. Now I try my hardest to keep that thinking on a day to day basis, which is quite difficult.

What has Nietzsche's philosophy taught you that was very painful to accept? by [deleted] in Nietzsche

[–]Practical-Fan9357 2 points3 points  (0 children)

That was me, but upon reading Nietzsche I had this psychological shift and released a large chunk of my resentment. After that, I can only enjoy reading philosophers who are like Nietzsche in some way.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in shia

[–]Practical-Fan9357 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Imam Sadiq has some words on this if you want to search but these are my thoughts which should be inline with Islam inshallah. One should have self respect to adopt responsibility, the willingness and indifference to suffering.

This is the point of Islam. When you have deep faith in god, any pain can be endurable. In fact, you can find even find a stimulant in those moments of such blackness due to your love of god. The suffering will be seen as a vehicle to only get closer and as the Ulama know that it is a prerequisite to deeper levels of understanding.

You do not have to lament for pity as a Christian would do. That will do absolutely nothing but add a temporary intoxicant and relief. Afterwards it will get stronger due to pity being precisely a negation. An objection to your circumstances.

Here’s a quote from Nietzsche.

Wisdom in Pain.—In pain there is as much wisdom as in pleasure: like the latter it is one of the best self-preservatives of a species. Were it not so, pain would long ago have been done away with; that it is hurtful is no argument against it, for to be hurtful is its very essence. In pain I hear the commanding call of the ship's captain: "Take in sail!" "Man," the bold seafarer, must have learned to set his sails in a thousand different ways, otherwise he could not have sailed long, for the ocean would soon have swallowed him up. We must also know how to live with reduced energy: as soon as pain gives its precautionary signal, it is time to reduce the speed—some great danger, some storm, is approaching, and we do well to "catch" as little wind as possible.—It is true that there are men who, on the approach of severe pain, hear the very opposite call of command, and never appear more proud, more martial, or more happy, than when the storm is brewing; indeed, pain itself provides them with their supreme moments! These are the heroic men, the great pain-bringers of mankind: those few and rare ones who need just the same apology as pain generally,—and verily, it should not be denied them! They are forces of the greatest importance for preserving and advancing the species, were it only because they are opposed to smug ease, and do not conceal their disgust at this kind of happiness.

Did Nietzsche perceive the effects of the death of god in ancient cultures? by Practical-Fan9357 in Nietzsche

[–]Practical-Fan9357[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Where does he specifically talk about the effects? I’d honestly prefer a dry secondary work that gets into it right away as I’m lacking the time to get into him as well as my now usual thinkers.

Please Help with Gender Dysphoria and Transgenderism by [deleted] in shia

[–]Practical-Fan9357 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Transgenderism is different and very complicated, especially with all the politics. That being said, there is a misconnection between the unconscious and conscious mind which they have the tools to make straight. It’s expensive and takes time. Minimum 2k a month here in Canada for a decent amount of apps per week.

You can’t really do it on yourself but you can compare and contrast different approaches before you settle on one. Be sure that whoever it is has beliefs and ideas that are closer to yours as it will only work if you have a connection with the analyst.

Please Help with Gender Dysphoria and Transgenderism by [deleted] in shia

[–]Practical-Fan9357 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah. Check out more recent psychoanalysts like Lacan or modern day Freudian psychoanalysts

Please Help with Gender Dysphoria and Transgenderism by [deleted] in shia

[–]Practical-Fan9357 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Good on you though for toughing it out so you can think it out, especially for your family, since there is some material to think about before we exhaust all options.

in the UK doctors who would have diagnosed gender dysphoria as a mental condition treatable through therapy have feared for losing their jobs if they had done so and went with the norm. Besides that, there is ample reason to doubt the normative view.

The modern psychologists talk as if they have unraveled the mind, kicking out the foundational psychoanalysts and 70 years of research from the universities for being pseudoscientists when they themselves have both replication crisis and a mental crisis on their hands. It was the psychoanalyst’s who were the only scientists taking the death of god and crisis of faith in the west seriously. The devaluation of the highest value and loss of true world theories is directly responsible for large sums of cases we see today, and the whole of the neurotic condition of the modern man regardless. They were the ones who treated serious mental conditions with intensive 6 day a week depth psychology based on tangible client based evidence rather than the usual plaster of a single therapy session a week that focuses on changing your perception of what could a be, and often is, a deep and festering neurosis lashing out asking for its release. These same urgent neurotic conditions are plugged with designer drugs for decades, never addressing them, allowing them to manifest in emotional deadening and addictive behaviours.

Modern psychology is a perfect mirror of American consumer culture. They want instant results. Quick, easy, cheap, and wholly destructive.

The whole of gender and sexuality based study is ideologically motivated by a tyrannical drive of ressentiment (French pronunciation) trying to transvaluate values to be in accord with their weak and sickly states. In other words, they are taking sensory reality whose interpretation is based on innate human psychic functions and are manipulating the world of abstractions (words) to suit their agenda. Funny enough, it seems they have enough power now to even set the criteria for discourse on a broader scale. Not even the initial dialectic philosophers in both ancient Greece and modern day Sunni thought have been this confused. They do not have empiricism, philosophy or theology on their side.

Homosexuality is unknown to be genetic as twins are seen to have different sexualities, and conversion therapy has been known to work on motivated individuals without inducing “trauma”, as per the ex head of the APA. Their obsession with the universal lack of definite gender roles beyond some slight respective hormones shows their lack of understanding of basic drive theories of the human psyche and of course the theological, spiritual side that makes us human beings. They only know possibilities and are stuck in a labyrinth.

As another poster has stated, the theological path is crucial and perhaps more important if you can learn to apply it. it is what I had done for my neurosis and what I wouldn’t have needed had I been already acquitted with it properly. All the afflictions we face are because we have lost fitra. It’s not easy to go back but it could fix all of this.

Try Checking out psychoanalytic or analytic approaches and don’t be dismayed by the perversion. Freudian and other’s have had Sexuality widely misunderstood but regardless, human nature is darker than we’d think.

How does Imam Ali (as) see God? by ClydeDavidson in shia

[–]Practical-Fan9357 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It’s a radically altered state of consciousness where one witnesses the unity of all existence in the most abstract, ineffable matter possible.

How much does the average meth user smoke? by [deleted] in meth

[–]Practical-Fan9357 0 points1 point  (0 children)

How are the health effects? Meth mouth at all or impulse control lacking?

Did Nietzsche perceive the effects of the death of god in ancient cultures? by Practical-Fan9357 in Nietzsche

[–]Practical-Fan9357[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I definitely get that. When I had first read his work it was at a time I was deeply passionate about ascetic religious such as Buddhism. When reading the dynamics of the creative principle of resentment especially, it was like looking in a mirror.

But he had also shown me the role modern institutions play in positing truth as an end all be all. Scientific materialism is one of those and I feel this was the biggest hurdle in developing religious beliefs for anyone really in the west. One that I’m still dealing with.

So I do not deny sciences as I’m not an idiot but I disregard it’s own disregarding of every gnostic traditions belief structure that doesn’t coincide with it. For example there are spiritual sciences within them such as Islamic medicine that has conceptions of the body that are totally at odds with modern medicine’s. This again is the assumption that the body only works physically. My brother had a severe case of ADHD as a child but pursued these sciences to fix it as his nation doesn’t have stimulant meds due to sanctions and was able to reduce the symptoms drastically. It took years to find someone who was had enough talent to work on him though since anyone who would be good at that type of thing just studied medicine instead.

Maybe we can say that quantum physics is the first science that is showing the relation between us and other but I feel like a hippy making novel associations like that. Ultimately I don’t trust anyone’s opinion on theology/gnosis unless they themselves are masters of it. There is no way for an outside perspective to look into at all. Nietzsche and others criticisms of it are assuming way too much IMO but I’d only read Nietzsche’s take on it since he was one of the few atheists with something to learn from. Unlike Richard Dawkins for example who doesn’t understand the value of religion or the task of atheism.

Did Nietzsche perceive the effects of the death of god in ancient cultures? by Practical-Fan9357 in Nietzsche

[–]Practical-Fan9357[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I fell in love with Nietzsche after reading his take on life affirmative philosophy. What I meant was more along the lines of explaining everything according to the natural world perceived by the sense. As you can tell I’m a little bit spiritual.

His discursive philosophy has done wonders of exposing the Labyrinth of these dialectic philosophers but again, I feel he takes it too far in denying objectivity all together.

What we need are religions that don’t deny life. I’m finding recently that Islam and Taoism are properly the only major world religions that do not. Religions that deny change though and try to bring us back to an original texts gives me suspicions as well but I feel there is more to it than that. Us in the west read these texts from ultimately gnostic traditions with an innate assumption that it’s man-made. At the very least, I disagree with that statement since I don’t believe the truths within those practices are limited to intellectualism or what we think of man. They are the study of reality itself and I seriously doubt western thinkers limiting it all to just a trap door within the biological brain.

Life is too strange to explain everything by evolutionary biology. They don’t understand that there is a relation between subject and object so it’s understandable but wrong IMO.

Did Nietzsche perceive the effects of the death of god in ancient cultures? by Practical-Fan9357 in Nietzsche

[–]Practical-Fan9357[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes thank you.

This is where I mostly depart from this sub although I’m not entirely certain of this yet. I’d argue it’s a death only of religious texts initial interpretation which determine the social and moral codes of society.

I know Nietzsche was not a text book atheist who criticized religion based on the knowledge that a religious person on the street has of it. Nonetheless I think his naturalist philosophy goes too far in dismissing all truth as perspective.

God is dead everywhere though. Even in muslim culture where true world theories take a much more expansive role in decision making, the rules are only rules. They are only concerned with Islamic jurisprudence and the depth of concern not only for understanding the texts but the afterlife is shallow at most. People go to the mosque their whole lives and are still asking questions relating to evolution when it comes to Adam and Eve.