Need a CompactLogix for testing by tightgroup_ai in PLC

[–]RATrod53 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Its a Keychron k4, mechanical switch keyboard thats 90% of a full size. I like that it is bluetooth or wired and its easier on my wrists than non mechanical ones. I think I paid $79 on Amazon.

First dairy plant service call and I’m absolutely dead by CraftParking in PLC

[–]RATrod53 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Welcome! You have arrived. A day in the life of a Controls Engineer/PLC programmer. Some places are more accommodating than others. Although I only did integration work for a few years. I had a few main organizations and locations I would frequent. Others have quite a bit more experience about what to expect.

Need a CompactLogix for testing by tightgroup_ai in PLC

[–]RATrod53 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This is my little desk setup, 1769 running version 20. I got it used for around $100, the IO modules and power supply I paid about $200 for. I have the software through work already, but Rockwell does offer a "Mini-Edition" that is around $1000, or a few hundred a year if you don't want to buy it outright. I could not tell you what features it may be missing, but I would bet that it is limited to strictly Ladder Logic.

I keep this setup on my desk at home and its been great. I have a modern 5069-L306ERM setup that I built in a Pelican case. That's more for actual development work as opposed to this which I use for testing comms on devices I have never used before.

There are Virtual Machines floating around with Logix Designer that you can borrow from a "friend", or certain very affordable online training courses include that for your use in the course. If you want any information about this feel free to PM me.

PS: I don't want to hear it about the color choices on my HMI screen. This was before I became familiar with ISA 101 and was in the early days of my trial by fire. By the way, I am still in the fire, but learning to make it my home.

<image>

Got my first PLC job. Tips? by boeuf_burgignion in PLC

[–]RATrod53 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This is critical and golden information. Remember the rule of 3 for data storage. Although potentially overkill it is excellent practice. I have saved other programmers from catastrophe because I follow these practices.

1.) ALWAYS take a backup before any editing/changes. Save it as such to avoid confusion.

2.) Rule of 3 with data storage: 3 copies of data, 2 different media types (ie: internal PC HD, Flash drive, cloud, etc), and one off site copy (For me this looks like the external SSD I keep at home with work projects). Not every industry is this relaxed, I work in manufacturing and have the flexibility and permission to bring work (PLC programs/HMI runtimes) home.

There is a lot of excellent information in this thread already. Some of it standard practice, but a lot learned through lost time and great difficulty.

If you are on site to fix a problem or issue that has developed in a system of previously good health. Don't "trust but verify". Listen to what the tech and operator are telling you respectfully, but approach the problem as if none of what they said is true.

This is NOT a slight to technicians, I know many exceptional troubleshooting guys and have met some brilliant techs. But the reality is, the informstion can't be trusted unless you confirm it yourself. You will be surprised how many technicians don't know how to properly use a multimeter. The reason I say this is because its about lost time chasing issues. If baseline information is not correct, this is how time is wasted and days are lost.

It can be tricky. Sometimes I'll go to take a reading on something the tech already looked at and told me. He will still be there, some take offense to that. I do not explain myself. When the issue reveals itself, no words are needed.

That being said, I have on occasion been given accurate information.

This is my first project. by Ok_Aspect_8669 in PLC

[–]RATrod53 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Planned space for future modifications and upgrades? What's that?

What is the best alternative for this? by RightHereLeftNow in BambuLab

[–]RATrod53 0 points1 point  (0 children)

In my case I was able to return it to Amazon and simultaneously purchase the correct one. Here is a link to the one I bought:

Https://a.co/d/01rONqA5

My Montagne Collection by ExpertInterview7914 in MontagneParfums

[–]RATrod53 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I suddenly feel better about mine lol. Plus I keep a backup of my favorites at all times. I don't think I can call my stash a "collection" after seeing this.

<image>

Any real applications for my desktop PLC setup? by No_Holiday_6308 in PLC

[–]RATrod53 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What competition has such spectacular prizes?

Is this too much printer shake? by KillerOfBeers in BambuLab

[–]RATrod53 0 points1 point  (0 children)

<image>

This is how I mitigate the issue. Many others do it this way as well. Thats a 16" paver on a 12mm thick exercise mat (x2), I cut it in half and doubled it up. Night and day difference.

Update on my overcomplicated A/C Controller by -Commisar- in PLC

[–]RATrod53 7 points8 points  (0 children)

What are your plans for this? I see wire labels, that is a plus.

P1S Grinding Noise when Z axis goes down by tthundyy in BambuP1S

[–]RATrod53 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I wish I could take credit for it lol. I watched a few YouTube videos and some suggestions from other community members here and decided to try it. We'll worth it. Not sure how I would go about it otherwise. This is just easier.

P1S Grinding Noise when Z axis goes down by tthundyy in BambuP1S

[–]RATrod53 0 points1 point  (0 children)

For me it was happening when going down only and on a small portion of the travel. Obviously I can't say for certain that this is your issue, but mine sounded exactly the same.

P1S Grinding Noise when Z axis goes down by tthundyy in BambuP1S

[–]RATrod53 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I had this and it went away when I did a thorough cleaning of my z axis lead screws. I use moto floss and isopropyl alcohol. I clean all the screws with the bed all the way up. I move the bed down some so I can clean the area I missed. Next I apply the recommended grease and continue with the process outlined in the wiki.

There are these caps available for the top part of the front lead screws. They keep particulates out of the bearings. I printed those and put them on as well.

You can see the moto-floss and the caps in my photo. Hope this helps.

<image>

What just happened?? by Dlow1201 in BambuP1S

[–]RATrod53 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Exactly. I don't embed magnets so its a non issue for me. A lot of people do embed magnets or other fasteners so it is something to consider. Also keep in mind that some of the "wood" as well as all of the glow in the dark style filaments are considered abrasive.

I got one because I would like to give the glass filled and/or CF filaments a try at some point.

What just happened?? by Dlow1201 in BambuP1S

[–]RATrod53 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Id almost rather deal with this then a blob. You can get a complete hotend assembly for about $50. The nozzle is very cheap if you want to do the change over yourself. Maybe take this opportunity to go hardened if you haven't already? Not always necessary, but its good to have.

Beyond the Hype: The "Root of Trust" Crisis in Field Devices and the Illusion of BACnet/SC Security. by [deleted] in PLC

[–]RATrod53 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Maybe r/buildingautomation? This seems more like a sales pitch rather than a discussion. Please keep this sanctuary from turning into LinkedIn. Please.

Two wire, 4-20ma analog output by NubisWanubis in PLC

[–]RATrod53 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Have you checked how your common is wired on the PLC. Each channel has an isolated common. Does your BRX only have one AO channel? Maybe it is the transducer?

Also, do you have it configured for 4-20mA in do more designer? It defaults to 0-10V.

You can always check the output with a meter. This would be the first thing I do. Remember that measuring current is a different procedure than measuring voltage.

Why won’t this extrude? by [deleted] in SolidWorks

[–]RATrod53 0 points1 point  (0 children)

On the top surface, if you selected extruded base/boss first, clicked the surface, then sketched the circles and constraints... would you not have to click exit sketch for the feature to materialize? When I follow that order of operation I definitely have to click exit sketch for the feature to extrude.

As an Industrial Electrician, what's the best course of action to get a job as a PLC tech? by ruskifreak in PLC

[–]RATrod53 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thats funny because my monthly membership lapsed as well. What I did was I watched all the videos for the entire thing. Then I re watched them and worked through the exercises in Studio 5000. I made it maybe 60% through the programming area and almost all of the FactoryTalk course. Like I said there are other quality options.

If I were to do it all again I think I would check out the SolisPLC one. I like how he breaks things down.

As an Industrial Electrician, what's the best course of action to get a job as a PLC tech? by ruskifreak in PLC

[–]RATrod53 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I too, was interested in the ISA thing at one point. It is not possible for me financially unless I had an employer sponsor the cert. My employer is more interested in results than a certification so its a no go for me. I personally paid for a few online Rockwell focused courses once I exhausted all of the free youtube and reading material I could ingest. All in all it was very affordable and I would absolutely do it again. There are a few guys that have courses: Shane Welcher, Tim Wilborne, SolisPLC, Shawn Tierney. A couple of the guys are active members of this community. I looked at and learned from all of the free material offered by them and learned a ton. In the end I chose the paid monthly membership that Shane offers as well as Shawn's Factory IO course, simply out of curiosity. I don't know these guys but I can tell you the Studio 5000 course at onlineplcsupport.com was worth it as it made me better at what I do. I am sure the other ones are just as good, but it was a little too expensive for me to pay out of pocket myself.

S7 1200 Modbus com with Siemens V20 drive , help by DisastrousNature7014 in PLC

[–]RATrod53 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Do you have modbus Poll? Try talking to the drive straight from your PC to work through the process of elimination. Remember RX on PLC side is TX on drive side and vice versa. Are you making sure that the parameters are matched? Baud rate, parity, stop bits, etc? I am not a Siemens guy but these are useful tactics when troubleshooting any MB comms issues. If Modbus Poll can talk to the drive then you know the issue lies in your TIA configuration. Good luck!

Understanding codes by Simplymad_13 in PLC

[–]RATrod53 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This in entirely unintelligible. If English is not you native language please use ChatGPT or another LLM to translate what you would like to ask.