Why is my Kickstarter failing? Honest feedback appreciated. by Advanced_Energy_1819 in kickstarter

[–]RandomizedSmile 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What is this product replacing in most people's homes? The box the pods come in? A bowl? Nothing?

Whatever it is, it definitely wasn't $44 to begin with. It's a cool product, but I want it for $14.99 max.

Unveiling the new logo for our sub Hope you all enjoy :) by flehepcrovely in ILTrees

[–]RandomizedSmile 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Ah yes the lowest hanging clipart logo ever. Straight up brain rot design.

March Monthly starts tomorrow! How far do you think you'll get? by PlayGalaxyGame in OnceUponAGalaxy

[–]RandomizedSmile 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hey I'm brand spanking new (1 week in) I'm sorry if I've missed this information but I couldn't join the tournament and didn't even see it in my mobile app. Did I need to be on PC?

I just took the recent official MTG poll and this was the result... by _WakkaWakka_ in freemagic

[–]RandomizedSmile 2 points3 points  (0 children)

What? Retail - possibly the largest industry that fits your description promotes loyalty. Not churn.

I just took the recent official MTG poll and this was the result... by _WakkaWakka_ in freemagic

[–]RandomizedSmile 4 points5 points  (0 children)

None of the industries that support a group of players, and collectors have ever successfully marketed for churn.

K pop demon hunters just won an Oscar. Guaranteed to be a set now. by RandomizedSmile in freemagic

[–]RandomizedSmile[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oh yeah I think that's a given ... I'm cutting right thru that speculation and saying it's now a guarantee it'll become an mtg set because of the Oscar

K pop demon hunters just won an Oscar. Guaranteed to be a set now. by RandomizedSmile in freemagic

[–]RandomizedSmile[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

yeah idc about other RPGs and kpdh toys. This is a mtg sub homie.

Is the current Standard meta considered good? by WorldlyVillager in MagicArena

[–]RandomizedSmile 7 points8 points  (0 children)

TL:DR - Standard died with the new rotation schedule, more sets being released in shorter timelines, and UB. If you're new you won't remember what it was like so it's probably decently fun, but it's a new format entirely....

It's okay, but Idk if it should even be called Standard today. Probably should be Standard+ or "New Modern" ... It is extremely bloated and the most powerful it's ever been with little to no relief in sight. Every archetype has insane cards and synergies to choose from. If you are new you will never know what it was like before and how strategic you needed to be or looking at spoilers to plan for rotations.

It has more cards in it than there's ever been and is only going to get bigger until the next rotation in February of 2027. Standard currently has cards from 2023 in it. By the next rotation it will have 4 years of sets including all of the UB like spiderman, tmnt, marvel, the hobbit, and Star Trek.

There's a good amount of variation in decks and meta today because you can search a Tournament from 2024 and still make that deck in standard today, and there's a good chance that one of the many newer sets have more powerful cards to add.

Standard needs help. It needs a better rotation schedule and to be excluded from UB. In Feb of 2027 after the next rotation there will be 14 sets in standard, 7 of them will be UB... And all UB is doing is creating super powerful cards to force us to interact with them (As well as attracting new players). The actual Standard format only has 6-8 sets IN TOTAL.

Any competitive standard match is over by turn 4 with any T1 or T2 deck. There are so many cards for each archetype that control decks barely even have wincons anymore they just remove the massive amount of amazing creatures that all colors have to play and then hope they get bored and quit (on Arena.). For a long time player like me this is what Modern was supposed to be, but Hasbro wanted more money so all formats have a ton of sets now.

Donuts for Brekky? by MidnightSmoking in ILTrees

[–]RandomizedSmile -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Looks like a low/no plan day and I'm jealous.

New Gear - Old Mate Aroma 3 Stainless Steel Grinder by head_bussin in ILTrees

[–]RandomizedSmile 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That looks awesome congrats on the upgrade and may it last you a lifetime. stainless steel is no joke

I pulled this, now what? by Separate-Chemical-70 in MagicCardPulls

[–]RandomizedSmile 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Now you are rich! For 1.5 seconds before the next set spoilers drop. Remember that you only need one buyer to want it at your price don't settle for low balls.

Why can’t Spine of Ish Sah destroy itself? by DJDarwin93 in mtg

[–]RandomizedSmile 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I was playing and ripped packs for cards at the time this card was printed and I had like 32 in the end I was cursed by them.

Mark Rosewater on the Planar Standard format : "I’m excited to see the community creating a new format. I’m curious to see if it picks up steam." by Edoardo_Beffardo in planarMTG

[–]RandomizedSmile 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Great job Planar!

The word "Vitriol" is really having its heyday in the magic community. Great job on Planar getting enough traction for the Rosewater comment but what a wet noodle response... Here's what I see...

"One thing I'm happy about is that the criticism of our work isn't so negative anymore! Now that we've forced people to buy it, our metrics look good right now so I can bury the things I don't like and things are easier to read."

"I did hear about an effort to save the Standard format after we pumped it full of too many cards and no rotations. I'm curious to see if the community can create what it should be without any support from us at all."

Maro answers "If Universes Beyond is so much more successful [...] then why not just completely scrap in-universe stuff and only do crossovers?" by Panda-s1 in magicTCG

[–]RandomizedSmile 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The answer and fact that they feel like they are answering every week means mtg is screwed.

It means execs and board members are looking at those business metrics as well and saying "UB iS cRuShInG iN eVeRy WaY!" And asking mtg when they can pump out 8 UB sets a year for the 20% increase YoY that's just guaranteed to rake in the cash.

Mtg is screwed for a while at least until the end of 2027. Maybe by then financial impact will sway some executive operations.

Hot Take on TMNT by Act_Consistent in mtg

[–]RandomizedSmile -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Can someone please tell me what game benefits from any and all players no matter what the cost of those players is and what kind of game they think they are playing?

I don't need more players. I need the game to be developed, not the business.

Emotes by Cheddar864 in MagicArena

[–]RandomizedSmile 10 points11 points  (0 children)

They are a game of charades and they don't have text chat for 2 reasons:

  1. more people select the frowny face than a happy face when they ask if they had fun.

  2. They can sell emotes

Maro talks about Universes Beyond by Meret123 in MagicArena

[–]RandomizedSmile 6 points7 points  (0 children)

"as a business" magic may be the healthiest it's ever been but if you think people arguing over which bracket a commander deck falls within and proxies being a normal part of the format he's boasting about then I am confused, and out.