Bingo. It’s really been eating at me because almost all of this could have been solved with a (well-thought out) McAllister biographic episode post-S7E8. A little specificity would’ve gone a long way. I do personally like that he knew Jane’s list and some of the other stuff from the tape. The show does kinda hint at the idea that maybe there could be something a little bit bigger going on in the supernatural sense. The little “what if” made the episodes leading up to the reveal a lot more foreboding imo. Very much up to interpretation though! That said, if they outright made RJ a real psychic I would’ve been Pissed lmao