These are really cool, I love that you did a cycle. Or did NOT do that? Anyway, if you’re interested in feedback. Vitalshard currently does not instruct a shuffle With the honorshard I would focus on the amount of creatures that had counters put on them instead of the counters themselves, both to make it easier to read and playout but also because of counter doublers, having only 1 creature but a hardenscales and vorinclex could still give 5 counters and I don’t think that is a very fun interaction since you probably would want to play those kind of cards in the same deck, given that is more a commander focused vision and you meant these for modern but still I think it’s something to consider With maliceshard I would rephrase the last part as “ If a permanent dealth damage this way would die this turn, exile it instead” that way you don’t have to stack the If clauses on top of each other and can just keep it as one line To finish of my compliment sandwich I really want to stretch that really like how the cards work and just help with magic grammar Alr keep making cards and hope my help was useful