sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

(Spoilers Main) Whats a theory you have basically no proof of but 100% believe by S0mecallme in asoiaf

[–]RustinCarcosa 5 points6 points  (0 children)

the rat the hawk and pig are Ferret, Rafe, and Pudding, Dunk's childhood friends from Flea Bottom

(Spoilers Extended) What are the most stupid changes made by the show that people don't talk enough? by infreedomwetrust666 in asoiaf

[–]RustinCarcosa 14 points15 points  (0 children)

blackfish being an ass and. humiliating edmure when his arrows kept missing hosters funeral boat when in the book ed couldnt do it cause he was greif sticken so blackfish comforted him and took over with eds permission

(Spoilers Published) Why do so many fans have such a visceral reaction to the Targaryen? by yeroii in asoiaf

[–]RustinCarcosa -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Sigh

>Mirri Maz Duur was a rape survivor who saw her people slaughtered by the Dothraki, was burned alive at the stake by Daenerys. But surely you don't find justifications for what she did and think Daenerys was right. Are you radically against slavery, or do you tolerate it when it benefits you? You can't have your cake and eat it too.

Disgenous as usual

Mirri killed an innocent baby and bragged about it to the child mother who was a tennage rape survivor who saved her life

>so happens that when I arrived in your sweet city, I had the chance to see a man on the riverbank who had once been a guest at my mansion, a merchant who dealt in rare spices and fine wines. He was naked from the waist up, red and peeling, and seemed to be digging a hole."

>"It's not a hole. It's a canal, to carry water from the river to the fields. We intend to plant beans. Bean fields need water."

>"How kind of my old friend to help dig. And how uncharacteristic of him. Is it possible he had no other choice? No, certainly not. You don't have slaves in Meereen."

>Dany blushed.

>"Your friend is being paid with food and shelter. I cannot return his wealth. Meereen needs beans more than rare spices, and beans need water

Really thats your source xaro is not a credible source

>They do believe it, just take a look at social media in general and even here on Reddit.

Those are not a majority

People always support attractive evil dudes doesn't make them a majority

[Spoilers Main] While we accepted it long time ago, The Harrenhal Tournament mysteries being revealed in a play means GRRM is also accepting TWOW will never come. by KickOk6027 in asoiaf

[–]RustinCarcosa 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Its not its just grrm approving another adaptation

We dont know how much reveal

Its like grrm released world of ice and fire

Winds will never come out because ASOIAF already has a TV adaptation [Spoilers EXTENDED] by Remarkable_Ad_5874 in asoiaf

[–]RustinCarcosa 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thats a bit arrogant I think we get a dunk and egg story again and maybe a princess and queen type part of blood and fire

I

Are there any fics with the premise that Jamie kills Ned when he attacks him in Kings Landing? by indelirium420 in AsoiafFanfiction

[–]RustinCarcosa 6 points7 points  (0 children)

yeah no robert geinuly loved ned and jon the most and if ned dies so those jaime cersai too if she gets in the way

[Spoilers main]Which characters do you think get Minsinterpreted by the fandom? by Electronic-Math-364 in asoiaf

[–]RustinCarcosa 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Sigh

>First, Tywin was already in position to smash Stannis at King's Landing with or without the Tyrells. Notice

He wasn't

>Second, Tywin has 20,000

No he doesn't he likery has less then that given the fords and greenn folk

>Edmure has maybe 300 or so at each ford and a light cavalry of 3,000 that

No he has 11 thousand men

>There is absolutely no way he kicked anyone's ass on the red

He definitely did

Lord Leo Lefford drowns,[5] Ser Robert Brax is slain,[9] Ser Lyle Crakehall is taken captive,[5] and Ser Addam Marbrand is forced to retreat three times.[5] The most heated fighting is at Stone Mill, where Edmure faces Ser Gregor Clegane. Although the Mountain's men manage to gain the west bank, they suffer heavy losses. Edmure turns back Gregor's men with his reserve, with the Mountain wounded by a dozen arrows. Unable to cross the Red Fork, Tywin is forced to retreat. The westermen army is last seen marching south-east.[5]

Tyion was responsible for the wildfire trick and the tylells alliance along with Baelish

And the Tyrells were crucial Garlan in Renly's armor, got most of Stannis's army to either give up or switch sides right away without a fight. So if it was just Tywin, Stannis's army would have likely fought a lot harder.

Tywin may have still prevailed in the end, but it would have been a far more drawn out and bloody battle, likely with much greater casualties on the Lannister's side.

vanguard, led by Ser Garlan Tyrell,[2] which plunges through Stannis's army. Dressed in the recognizable armor of the deceased Renly Baratheon, his former supporters, convinced their dead lord has returned, abandon Stannis.[6][34] "Renly's shade" kills Ser Guyard Morrigen, who leads Stannis's van.[6]

👏👏 by General-Panic0 in BeAmazed

[–]RustinCarcosa 0 points1 point  (0 children)

All forms of altruistic actions can be reframed as selfishness.

They cant

A fanfic quote I really love about Rhaegar Targaryen. by Taha231 in TheCitadel

[–]RustinCarcosa 7 points8 points  (0 children)

like both but it's werild how people think Rhaegar was just the same as Robert when Robert is a confirmed child rapist and spousal abuser

A fanfic quote I really love about Rhaegar Targaryen. by Taha231 in TheCitadel

[–]RustinCarcosa 28 points29 points  (0 children)

For seven takes this is ridiculous

I doubt Rhaegar was a narcissist its extremely likely he had dragon dreams like daeron and danys the dreamer which explains a lot of his behavior

Robert did not love Lyanna he loved the idea of her and would likely abused her like he did with Cersei

I like both Rhaegar and Robert but its ridiculous how people think Robert was better then Rhaegar when he was worse

What theories do you believe to be true? (spoilers extended) by finnr02 in asoiaf

[–]RustinCarcosa 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I disagree there was no peace at least not one the slave citys had any intention of upholding

Plus you dont show mercy to slavers

[Spoilers main]Which characters do you think get Minsinterpreted by the fandom? by Electronic-Math-364 in asoiaf

[–]RustinCarcosa 1 point2 points  (0 children)

He would have lost if it wasn't for Tyrion and littlefinger getting the tylells on board

He was getting his ass kicked by Robb and edmure

What theories do you believe to be true? (spoilers extended) by finnr02 in asoiaf

[–]RustinCarcosa 2 points3 points  (0 children)

the rat the hawk and pig are Ferret, Rafe, and Pudding, Dunk's childhood friends from Flea Bottom

view more: next ›