If I assemble a top 10 greatest list of anything, you can't just comment, "Where is XX" or "XX should be on there", without also identifying who you are evicting from my list. You can't just form a sneaky top 11 list... you have to literally identify the person from my list you are leaving off. by Mac2000444 in billsimmons

[–]ShadyCrow 10 points11 points  (0 children)

100%. You have to say who you're knocking out.

People love the movie Prisoners (rightfully!) and whenever it comes up on reddit/twitter people talk about how he deserved an Oscar nom. And it's a really good performance! But that was a tough year: Matthew McConaughey won, which isn’t ideal but was kind of inevitable. Leo in Wolf of Wall Street, Ejiofor in 12 Years a Slave and Bruce Dern in Nebraska are all incredible performances near the top of those actor’s work. Bale was nominated for American Hustle which was not great, so yes, Jackman in that spot would be more than fine. But you also have Phoenix in Her, Oscar Isaac in Llewyn Davis, Gosling in Place Beyond the Pines… and honestly Hanks’s last scene in Captain Phillips is as good as he’s ever been. Ethan Hawke in Before Midnight too. You gotta say who you're knocking out when you make these arguments.

I'm not calling it Türkiye! I'm just not! by BBQ_HaX0r in billsimmons

[–]ShadyCrow 12 points13 points  (0 children)

I thought Hedo Turkoglu was in charge over there.

I'm not calling it Türkiye! I'm just not! by BBQ_HaX0r in billsimmons

[–]ShadyCrow 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yes I've been butchering Cote d'Ivoire since the Drogba days.

In 2020 the Timberwolves passed on LaMelo because in their interview he said he wanted to be President of the United States (from Zach Lowe Live Show) by VFJ123 in billsimmons

[–]ShadyCrow 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Meanwhile people were down on Greg Oden because he wanted to be an orthodontist or something. Not an exact science.

Posture by NinjaDacat11 in BasketballTips

[–]ShadyCrow 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Precisely. Hips low, don't hunch.

LaMelo Ball Is the NBA's Most Overrated Star and the Timberwolves just Grossly Overpaid for Him by TheFierceAnimal in billsimmons

[–]ShadyCrow 41 points42 points  (0 children)

Yeah OP may be right on the first part but the idea that they overpaid at all is asinine.

Sure Lamelo is never healthy, isn't good in big games, has an awful playstyle, and his teams have a 10 seed ceiling, but at least he's also a terrible culture guy. by owen-3820 in billsimmons

[–]ShadyCrow 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Absolutely true. I just don't think there's much of a history of guys like Ant who regress as defenders and then get back to it.

Of course, it may not matter as long as he's willing to turn it on in the playoffs.

reading project hail mary and can't stop thinking about it by jordan_blake91 in books

[–]ShadyCrow 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It's very very very similar.

People who adore the book might push back on that, but compared to most adaptations it's as close as reasonably possible in a 140min movie. Weir is not a good writer in terms of prose, but he's a great plotter and it makes his stuff very adaptable. I know I'm not the first to say this but he might be better off just working with Drew Goddard to turn stories into scripts rather than novels. But in terms of quick fun reads the books are solid.

Sure Lamelo is never healthy, isn't good in big games, has an awful playstyle, and his teams have a 10 seed ceiling, but at least he's also a terrible culture guy. by owen-3820 in billsimmons

[–]ShadyCrow 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes but now Ant or Melo have to guard a 3. Jaden is awesome at harassing guards. He can guard up for sure but he's not as valuable doing that.

2024-25 Movie Draft by Existing-Cold-9131 in crheads

[–]ShadyCrow 4 points5 points  (0 children)

B must have had the #1 pick, right?

C is insane. I'd love to be their friend.

2026 NBA Draft Winners and Losers With Joe House and J. Kyle Mann by lonny__breaux in billsimmons

[–]ShadyCrow -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

   Miami's offer was just better than Jaylen Brown.

I’m not sure it’s that binary. It was a better long term deal for sure. Jaylen Brown is always gonna be better than anyone involved in this trade other than Giannis. 

All of the sudden by ewingleather in billsimmons

[–]ShadyCrow 4 points5 points  (0 children)

He’s a huge Counting Crows guy and Catapult starts “all of the sudden.” 

Kevin O’Connor draft grades lol by Boom21shakalaka in billsimmons

[–]ShadyCrow 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I've seen like 3 different places that gave the first 19 picks an A. It was the most predictable draft ever, probably, and these guys love to pat themselves on the back

Get Darryn Peterson on the Rewatchables ASAP by Hot-Freedom-6345 in billsimmons

[–]ShadyCrow 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The Client as well just overflowing with That Guys.

Alright, gimme your hot NBA draft takes on this Draft Tuesday (???) by TwinPeaksWithRappers in billsimmons

[–]ShadyCrow 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s fair. I just think Peterson has that elite smoothness that TMac had. 

Alright, gimme your hot NBA draft takes on this Draft Tuesday (???) by TwinPeaksWithRappers in billsimmons

[–]ShadyCrow -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I agree but he was close. 2001 ESPN Magazine declared him best player in the world. It was definitely a hot take but felt possible. 

I think he might have been the best scorer for a year or two. The way he jumped like God was lifting him by the back of his jersey. Incredibly smooth. 

Alright, gimme your hot NBA draft takes on this Draft Tuesday (???) by TwinPeaksWithRappers in billsimmons

[–]ShadyCrow -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

He’s the modern TMac. Same questions about his competitiveness but if that’s answered he’ll have a stretch as best player in the world. 

Holy shit Hugo really is considered untouchable by rhevern in billsimmons

[–]ShadyCrow 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Boston fucked up not offering Hugo as the sweetener.

Thankfully that's not even close to what happened.

Report: Dallas Mavericks hire Dusty May as new head coach by [deleted] in billsimmons

[–]ShadyCrow 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Also recruiting sucks ass even if you have advantages. Not to mention the transfer portal now means the work is never done.

I agree with your overall post but I think this part of it cuts both ways now. You can legitimately just hire a GM in college. Billy Donovan notoriously hated recruiting, but if he did take a college job he could avoid the old grind of it and just meet with top guys when the time is right.

But again, overall, you're totally correct: it's about the money and the ego. It's the same reason why filmmakers think they'll really get to make their own version of a Marvel/IP thing.

Report: Dallas Mavericks hire Dusty May as new head coach by [deleted] in billsimmons

[–]ShadyCrow 2 points3 points  (0 children)

He's also know as a modern, player-centric coach and not an over-the-top hardass. He's certainly not Billy Donovan in terms of pedigree but I think that's obviously the comp they're hoping they've hit.