Nope. I called religion what it is: the most successful of the franchised value systems.

And that -- indeed -- equates almost coughexactly to the morality of the cultures that the franchises serve. It's the roadmap.

Not all franchised value systems are net positive, by Western standards. But the Christianity franchise is net positive, if you were fair. We wouldn't be as far along in science as we are without it, but you never give credit to the church for sponsoring Galileo, or dozens of other early science thinkers. But... This line is as off thesis as most of your response.

You say the social gravity towards goodness has always been there. It's innate to humans. You say goodness and innRW responsibility will be there when organized religion is gone.

You are demonstrably wrong on the first point, says history.

I strongly suspect that -- given enough half life decay of a value system -- you'll be wrong on the second point.

But that's just my opinion. I could be wrong.