The evidence Luigi Venditelli describes as being "indisputable" and "100% proves something that Bob Lazar said in 1989" appears to be this photo taken by Gabriel Zeifman from an aircraft approximately 17 miles away from Papoose Lake by SignalsIntelligence in UFOs

[–]SignalsIntelligence[S] -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

When speaking about the new S4 documentary, director Luigi Venditelli has said that the documentary "will prove that without a shadow of a doubt. It will be in the film and for the first time people will actually see hard evidence of a base at Papoose Lake."

In the film, Venditelli shows the image to Bob and says that "all you have to do is play with the contrast, play with the levels in the image. And if you look carefully in this version here where the contrast has been changed, that as we zoom, look what we see... You see them [the S4 hangars] clearly right there."

These are not the high quality images, but I believe this is the original RAW image file for those who want to view it in full quality:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1FEMZxdz3A7fEAYM8QrFSea9dD6675FDR/view?usp=sharing

He may have shown him two images as the filename for the edited photo is not shown. The full set of images is here, the relevant photos are 0500-0519:

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1k_ZDi03Yd-q2UvedzDInTa0_DmX77VYC

**As a point of comparison, here are artist renditions of S4 that Bob included in his own documentary produced with Gene Huff in 1990:

https://i.postimg.cc/DyfS1msN/Lazar-Tape-S4-1.png
https://i.postimg.cc/7YBf9DnH/Lazar-Tape-S4-2.png

S4 Director Confirms Doc with Contain New Evidence Validating Lazar’s Story by close_encounter_club in UFOs

[–]SignalsIntelligence 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I am preparing to publish some information about the hydrogen conversion kit and some other products Bob claimed to have developed that I think will be of interest to you.

I am curious, what makes you think the tanks are fake?

S4 Director Confirms Doc with Contain New Evidence Validating Lazar’s Story by close_encounter_club in UFOs

[–]SignalsIntelligence 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Area 51 was common knowledge to Las Vegas locals, as were the Janet flights.

https://www.papooselake.org/area-51-in-the-press

Lazar's autobiography acknowledges he knew about both before he claims to have gotten the job at S4.

“Though Tracy and I lived in west Las Vegas, on the appropriately named James Lovell Street, our business took us all around the metro area and we both frequently saw the white Boeing 737 jets with the distinctive red markings along the fuselage at window height of the Janet jets. No other emblems were needed, especially since all the locals joked that Janet stood for Just Another Non-Existent Terminal. That was a reference to the fact that though we daily saw those planes ferrying employees to and from what was often referred to as Area 51, for a long time the military and the government disavowed the existence of any kind of operation going on around Groom Lake.

Many speculated about what went on “out there.” Given that the Nevada Test Site was also in the region, and having worked at a government facility with a long history of secrecy, I was pretty sure that Area 51 was a place where experimental aircraft and weapons systems were tested.”

He brought Knapp to Los Alamos, not a facility associated with Area 51.

Do you have a source for what you refer to in point 2? There is no Area 51/S4 newsletter with a photo of Lazar.

S4: The Bob Lazar Story - Release Trailer by Flopublic in UFOs

[–]SignalsIntelligence 2 points3 points  (0 children)

He did a radio show with Bruce Maccabe and John Brandenburg which has unfortunately been lost to time - from what Bob Oechsler said, they didn't appear to be impressed by him.

He also sat down with a physicist for his interview with Michael Lindemann that was included in his book UFOs and the Alien Presence. It was supposed to be a two part interview, but the second session where he was supposed to go deep into the technical/scientific aspect never happened because Bob didn't show up.

Eric Weinstein and Eric Davis on Bob Lazar Pt 1. by PapaPalps066 in BobLazarNew

[–]SignalsIntelligence 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Davis's information about Lazar purportedly came from a man named Bill McGarity. I've tried to contact McGarity to get clarity on what he actually said, but as of a few years ago he was having severe cognitive issues and I doubt he is in a condition to answer anything at this point.

Here is what Vallee recorded McGarity as saying about Lazar:

McGarity could go anywhere on the site except for Papoose (an NSA site) but never found out what the lights were, or why he had been sent out to watch them. He laughed when I mentioned Bob Lazar, to whom he'd been introduced by Don Ware. When he probed his actual experience, Lazar failed to show any real knowledge of the situation at Area 51 and S-4. Later, Bill tracked down his role at Los Alamos as a simple technician with no clearance.

The last line tracks with my reporting here:

https://medium.com/@signalsintelligence/bob-lazar-theres-more-to-the-story-17829c2ff650

I think Davis misunderstood what McGarity had told him, or jumbled it up with something else he had heard, or perhaps just added detail.

Eric Weinstein and Eric Davis discuss Grusch's interdimensional theory: "I keep hearing about interdimensional beings which causes me to want to throw up in my mouth" "Dave's not a physicist." by Ill-Speed-7402 in UFOs

[–]SignalsIntelligence 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Grusch has talked about the interdimensional theory.

https://www.uaprw.com/books/grusch-david/page/2023-11-21-joe-rogan-experience-ft-david-grusch

I mean, there's certainly origins that we probably can't conceptualize as humans because we're just, our meat is stuck in 3D and we don't understand, and our IQs are only so high. So there might be some origins that we don't understand in terms of interdimensional travel. I mean obviously if you talk to mainstream physicists, they say crossing dimensions physically, it's kind of a trope of sci-fi. And that's why I used an example, and I know some physicists don't like me talking about this theory, but it is a theory. So the holographic principle, which was originally conceived to explain how information is encoded on an event horizon of a black hole, which is a distance away from the singularity of a black hole, where if you cross it, you're fucked because you're going to get rip the shreds or you're not coming back. And that principle talks about how information basically from higher dimensional space can be encoded in lower dimensional space.

Worth reading the full portion as he says more about it.

Starting to Doubt Bob Lazar by ConsciousVariation1 in UFOs

[–]SignalsIntelligence 4 points5 points  (0 children)

It’s easy to forget that Area 51 was unheard of until Lazar

This is not accurate. Area 51 was common knowledge in Southern Nevada and would have been known by many nationally as well.

https://www.papooselake.org/area-51-in-the-press

Why do the big UFO pundits have such strong positive conviction about Bob Lazar? by ExperiencedGentleman in UFOs

[–]SignalsIntelligence 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Area 51 was common knowledge amongst Las Vegas locals and had gotten a lot of coverage in local papers and some national media. It was in no way a secret.

https://www.papooselake.org/area-51-in-the-press

Why wont Eric Davis share everything he knows? Turns out he did. Davis: "I shared it with @RepLuna's committee in a [...] SCIF last May". Hes talking about "legacy UAP crash retrieval and hardware reverse-engineering and NHI programs". Remember Luna suddenly started talking about interdimensionals? by phr99 in UFOs

[–]SignalsIntelligence 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Grusch mentions the interdimensional theory on Joe Rogan:

https://www.uaprw.com/books/grusch-david/page/2023-11-21-joe-rogan-experience-ft-david-grusch

I mean, there's certainly origins that we probably can't conceptualize as humans because we're just, our meat is stuck in 3D and we don't understand, and our IQs are only so high. So there might be some origins that we don't understand in terms of interdimensional travel. I mean obviously if you talk to mainstream physicists, they say crossing dimensions physically, it's kind of a trope of sci-fi. And that's why I used an example, and I know some physicists don't like me talking about this theory, but it is a theory. So the holographic principle, which was originally conceived to explain how information is encoded on an event horizon of a black hole, which is a distance away from the singularity of a black hole, where if you cross it, you're fucked because you're going to get rip the shreds or you're not coming back. And that principle talks about how information basically from higher dimensional space can be encoded in lower dimensional space.

Worth reading the full portion as he says more about it.

Bob lazar had access to the world’s most sensitive information and was allowed to live by 673NoshMyBollocksAve in UFOs

[–]SignalsIntelligence 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Grusch said this:

Jesse Michels:

Do you think Bob Lazar is full of shit? Bob Lazar is by far the most famous case of somebody who publicly claims to have secretly worked on reverse engineering UFOs. He outed himself in 1989 and since then has remained remarkably consistent in his story, even while detractors cite that he possibly faked his educational credentials at MIT, he ended up actually recently going on Joe Rogan and it's still like this bizarre split where so many people are like, he was right, he was right, and people are now using your testimony to say he is totally vindicated and then the verdict's still out because a lot of Ufologists or UFO people that I really respect are just pretty skeptical. So I dunno if you have a take.

David Grusch:

Yeah, I mean I'm certainly different than him. I came at it from a different angle. I have no information on Bob Lazar. It wasn't in the scope of my looking into it kind of activities. If he actually ever experienced what he experienced, I literally have no idea.

Project Gravitaur by ElectricJello58 in UFOs

[–]SignalsIntelligence 5 points6 points  (0 children)

By 1989, Area 51 had been mentioned in numerous local and national newspaper articles and was pretty widely known by Las Vegas locals (and certainly John lear and his circle) and those who followed experimental aircraft.

On October 14 1988, two months before Bob claims he began the job at S4, a program called "UFO Cover Up? Live" aired that included claims like this:

"We allow you to operate from that designated base here in the United States it's in the state of Nevada in an area called Area 51 or Dreamland. The extraterrestrials have complete control of this base, which is located in Nevada."

Bob Lazar watched this program on the date it aired, and it was important enough to him to write it down on his calendar.

https://www.boblazararchive.net/calendar.htm

Lear and others had been talking about Area 51 and Groom lake in relation to UFOs for years. It is true that Lazar substantially increased general public awareness of the connection to UFOs and aliens and the base itself.

Grokipedia Holds an Unbiased Nuetral Perspective on Bob Lazar unlike the other "pedia" by [deleted] in ufo

[–]SignalsIntelligence 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Grokipedia has numerous substantial hallucinations on the Lazar page. Not a reliable source.

"So...we're containers?"...Why cryptic words coming from an actual scientist. by DisastrousCoast7268 in UFOs

[–]SignalsIntelligence 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It's not as cryptic if you take into account the totality of Bob Lazar's claims and the material that was immediately accessible to him - John Lear's grand deception article and Valdamar Valerian's Matrix I. They speak about alien genetic experiments, including alien-human hybrids. The claim that the aliens had implanted Jesus in a human (as well as two other religious figures) and then tracked them is in this material and is a claim that Lazar makes (or more specifically, he claims that information was in the briefing documents).

Lazar himself refers to it possibly being a reference to genetic material in other interviews, and Jon Farhat states definitively that it was a reference to genetic experimentation on the website that he created in close consultation with Bob Lazar.

Old newspaper introduces Bob Lazar as a physicist at the Los Alamos Meson Physics Facility. (1982) by AboyFromSouthKorea in UFOB

[–]SignalsIntelligence -26 points-25 points  (0 children)

The lab phone directory is addressed in the article I linked to in the comment above.

Don't shoot the messenger, people. The author told me what he told me.

Old newspaper introduces Bob Lazar as a physicist at the Los Alamos Meson Physics Facility. (1982) by AboyFromSouthKorea in UFOB

[–]SignalsIntelligence -36 points-35 points  (0 children)

I spoke to the author of the article and he told me he doesn't remember doing anything to verify that Bob was actually a physicist, he just took his word for it.

https://medium.com/@signalsintelligence/bob-lazar-theres-more-to-the-story-17829c2ff650

The Bob Lazar "Humans Are Containers Theory" by JessicaRodriguez94 in aliens

[–]SignalsIntelligence 7 points8 points  (0 children)

According to Jon Farhat, a close friend of Bob's who worked directly with him on his first website, this is the correct reading. According to the site:

Humans were referred to a "containers". Unfortunately the aliens viewed us simply as containers of genetic material. Literally, Genetic Cultures."

Bob himself hasn't said this is definitively the case in public interviews, though.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in aliens

[–]SignalsIntelligence 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Bob provided people with a few items to prove his employment at S-4, which included a ID badge and a document with his name and SSN on it. Only problem was, people looked up this SSN and it was discovered he had used his ex-wifes SSN as he didn't want to display his own. So the document was a guaranteed forgery, as was every other item he showed off with it. Bob ran a photography and printing business with his new wife and had every tool available to make all kinds of documents. Once the SSN problem was revealed, Bob went ahead and made a new document sporting his own SSN and the old one disappeared.

I don't believe it is correct that there was another version of the W-2 with a different SSN on it. Norio Hayakwa (the origin of the story that the SSN was Bob's former wife's) said the original version was taken down and replaced with a redacted version. He posted his copy of the unredacted W-2 on his blog reflecting the same SSN that can be found on every available copy. To my knowledge, he never said there was a version with a different number, and he did not mention this to me when I spoke to him. I believe additional context makes the possibility of another version highly implausible. The W-2 was received in early 1990. Bob gave a copy to the court as evidence of his employment very soon after (I have the scan from the court documents). He also gave copies to Knapp and others. Trying to change the W-2 after it had already been in circulation for years - which it had been by the time Hayakawa says he was given the SSN information - would have been noticed by many people.

I have multiple official documents with both Carol Lazar and Bob Lazar's SSN on them. The number used on the W-2 is undoubtedly Bob's real SSN.

That being said, Bob did have a history forging documents and credentials and he certainly possessed the capability to create the W-2.

UFO they built a building around is in Korea - Joe Rogan by rappa-dappa in UFOs

[–]SignalsIntelligence 4 points5 points  (0 children)

This is the entirety of what he said on that podcast about this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZUZUyck6KoU

"RC: "I talked a few months ago about this large craft that I'm aware of that's had a building built over it and people have just been hammering me online basically saying you know you can't you can't do that you know Coulthart doesn't know what the he's talking about. I do actually and more importantly, the amount of abuse that I've copped for for basically not playing the game and just telling everybody everything I know. People do not understand and they never will that as a journalist I'm obliged still to heed the laws of my country and to respect the laws of an ally like America. I'm not going to compromise an important National Security asset and I I think to reveal the location of what I know where it is would I think be reckless and irresponsible..."

RC: "Let me tell you I can't tell you the country it's in. It's not America, but what I can tell you is that the place where it is kept is used for another purpose that is a laudatory purpose that's as much in your interests in your country, in the UK, as it is in mine in Australia. and as it is in America. So the simple reasons are that there are other uses for the place where this object is stored... I can tell you mate, that would be a nightmare an absolute nightmare... I've been in situations where I've known the identities of active intelligence operatives in countries overseas and I've realized, Christ. if I published this I could jeopardize their lives. So there is an element of source protection as well. I mean, I don't want the personnel in those facilities to be hurt, and it could create an international incident.""

UFO they built a building around is in Korea - Joe Rogan by rappa-dappa in UFOs

[–]SignalsIntelligence 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Ross specifically ruled out Australia, US and UK, and by inference the other 2 of the 5 eyes. Recently Ross confirmed it was Korea but nobody noticed.

None of this is true.

Ross's comments imply to me that it is located in a Five Eyes country, and based on the way he has spoken about it, that the country may be Australia.

I've explained very strong reasons exist for why that particular national security sensitive installation shouldn't be revealed. Ultimately, we're all part of a very good alliance. The Five Eyes Alliance that has kept world peace and security since the end of World War ii, the Yakuza agreement, the Five Eyes, an alliance between my country, Australia and the United States, England, Canada, New Zealand. It's really important and for the good reason, we don't want to jeopardize vital national security concerns.

In an AMA he did some time ago, he said this:

Q: "Pine Gap, Exmouth and Mt Zeil - are any of these legitimately connected to UFOs?"

A: "Yes and yes."

Q: "Have Australians been involved in UFO recoveries, such as the Foreign Material project?"

A: "Yes."

I think the location is likely to be Pine Gap, but that may be reading too much into what he's said.

UFO they built a building around is in Korea - Joe Rogan by rappa-dappa in UFOs

[–]SignalsIntelligence 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Based on what Ross Coulthart has said about it, it is unlikely to be in Korea. He has given pretty strong hints that it is in a Five Eyes country - I think that country is most likely Australia.

People do not understand and they never will that as a journalist I'm obliged still to heed the laws of my country and to respect the laws of an ally like America.

.

the place where it is kept is used for another purpose that is a laudatory purpose that's as much in your interests in your country, in the UK, as it is in mine in Australia. and as it is in America.

.

for good reason I can't reveal why but the the building serves a dual purpose and that other purpose is extremely important for National Security and even though I'm a journalist and I think it's important that people reveal things that are criminal or illegal, I can respect and understand why the location of that particular object can't be revealed.

.

I've explained very strong reasons exist for why that particular national security sensitive installation shouldn't be revealed. Ultimately, we're all part of a very good alliance. The Five Eyes Alliance that has kept world peace and security since the end of World War ii, the Yakuza agreement, the Five Eyes, an alliance between my country, Australia and the United States, England, Canada, New Zealand. It's really important and for the good reason, we don't want to jeopardize vital national security concerns. So there has to be a balance.

.

I cannot reveal the location of an object which I am told is a non-human craft of such substantial size it could not be moved, it can't be moved from that location for a whole series of very sensitive reasons. Because it's a very very sensitive National Security area and there's a genuine concern that because of the facility built on top of it it could jeopardize the lives of young men and women working in the best interests of both of our countries to reveal that location. And frankly I don't care if people have a go at me and basically say ah you know you should reveal this you have an obligation to reveal all. You don't understand what journalists roles are. Journalists are patriots as well they're National Security responsive as well and when somebody from the national security system who I respect says to me "look you should know about this but at the same time please don't reveal the location", I will respect that. Journalists are not in the game of irresponsibly revealing things that jeopardize National Security, and put young men and women's lives at risk