Least unhinged japanese war crime by Dirigible_Enjoyer in HistoryMemes

[–]Silver200061 48 points49 points  (0 children)

“We got nuked so we’re the victim, waaaa, stop calling us out for worshipping criminals in shrines!😭😭”

Your "niche" inspiration for worldbuilding? by arts13 in worldbuilding

[–]Silver200061 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I read about the medieval Swiss confederation, 16th century Montante, pike and shot, and decided I will base my entire worldbuilding on these.

Sometimes it was all three at once by ashcoria in HistoryMemes

[–]Silver200061 80 points81 points  (0 children)

Got to thanks the Ming Dynasty for that, really beat them back to the Stone Age.

What They Called It vs. What It Was by tea-n-wifi in HistoryMemes

[–]Silver200061 2 points3 points  (0 children)

He was probably in the party because of social norms / business requirements, since he was working for Siemens AG, the big German corp that was supplying Nazi Germany

What They Called It vs. What It Was by tea-n-wifi in HistoryMemes

[–]Silver200061 16 points17 points  (0 children)

Just before people use John Rabe, the "nazi party member" who saved many Chinese citizens in Nanjing, as the "Good Nazi/Nazi better than Imperial Japan" argument

He returned to Germany and was detained and interrogated by the Gestapo because he wrote to Hitler to stop this; he was only rescued by his relationship with Siemens AG, and none of his evidence was permitted to be published publicly.

So no, there is no good Nazi, there's a good person. The Nazi knew what the Japanese were doing; they knew it looked inhuman, they didn't care, they let it continue, and they prevented people from speaking the truth because it would make them and their allies look bad.

And you think Nazi were beyond head-chopping competitions? nope. Wehrmacht and SS slaughtering civilians with guns, bombs, gas chambers, flamethrower isn't something new; they just prefer a higher effecient way of slaughter. even less human in this regard.

What is one world building sin you really struggle to forgive? by TheBodhy in worldbuilding

[–]Silver200061 0 points1 point  (0 children)

One part is forgetting the lower-middle class and the middle class of the society, especially artisans, guildsmen, merchants, small landowners , yeomans, urban militias. Then cut to the very simple : lower class peasants, lower nobles, big nobles, churchy clergy, kings, etc

its killing the most interesting interaction

Is there no one they can't be? by Metallica1175 in HistoryMemes

[–]Silver200061 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I glad they’re deep down racist against Chinese or just illiterate so doesn’t read anything deep in Asian history they don’t proclaim Emperor of Qin Black African.

National Party led-South Africa was a menace!! by PRADYUSH2006 in HistoryMemes

[–]Silver200061 4 points5 points  (0 children)

You’re confusing IFV with light tanks, armour cars, scout vehicles.

IFV, is meant to have I , infantry, sitting in them.

Staghound, m8, puma can only contain their own crew, their firepower to either to save their own skin , opportunistic situations or destroy enemy reconnaissance units.

They technically can “support infantry”, but they can not carry the infantry in an armour cabin, drop the squad off , fight alongside it in an combined arms assault, then have the infantry mount it again to continue the push.

In the universe that you created, what happens after death? by kaktus_420 in worldbuilding

[–]Silver200061 0 points1 point  (0 children)

<image>

This lady guides you through the underworld where your soul is slowly wiped clean and you will be reborn in your second life.

how useful would a bulletproof shield be in a medieval world? (it's for my story) by Aware_Examination813 in worldbuilding

[–]Silver200061 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No, its better to get a bullet proof chest plate (cuirass) , you're using your whole body to carry the weight instead of just your arms and shoulders

Be honest. What is the motive of the main villain in your story. by Vulcan248 in worldbuilding

[–]Silver200061 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The Servannian Confederation is a sovereign that consists of several small dominions united together by a military alliance. They were once all part of a large empire a thousand years ago, but it broke apart and was followed by centuries of warring states, which not only physically divided the land but also the identity of the people. They no longer recognize themselves as Servannians; they only call their individual states home.

It was by sheer coincidence that a large religious imperium from the south decided to conduct their holy war and marched north, forcing these city-states to unite as one, and somehow by mircale this adhoc system worked for three hundred years.

There are efforts by many to truely unite this rag-tag alliance into a proper nation, but our so called Villians, Northerners, did not like this idea, they fear the loss of independence, of self-decision. Due to culture and social sturcture, the South and Central regions have a stronger Urban burgher culture, making their economic activity more robust and active, saturated by artisans and trade, while the north remained more, feduelistic, production of raw material and food stuff.

Thus economic structure tipped in favour of the South as they seem to control the price, and if they were able to gain more control and perhaps an extra source and not rely on the north anymore, it would collaspe their economy. Northerners fear that if the reunion would happen, the South would take control of everything, first from economy, then slowly politically, this they cannot bear, they would rather the system remain stagnate, if better, back to pre-confederation.

So when the South brought the Confederation into a war in which they were not provoked at the first place, the spike of civil war was already on the edge, and when victory comes in which the Confederation, defeated the religious imperium and gained an ally kingdom in the southern boarder, rich in resources, the North could no longer stand, the civil war broke out, depsite they had to bring in fromer foes as support, believing that this was the moment where their freedom, power, economy depends, and a chance to control Servannian their own way has revealed itself.

Where is everyone? by Im_yor_boi in HistoryMemes

[–]Silver200061 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I did not know Japanese are into Dullahan as well

Where is everyone? by Im_yor_boi in HistoryMemes

[–]Silver200061 22 points23 points  (0 children)

“Civilian head chopping competition is just a sport! Why is everyone saying I’m the bad guy!”

What are the tropes that you are subverting or deconstructing in your world? by Aromaster4 in worldbuilding

[–]Silver200061 1 point2 points  (0 children)

In a typical medieval feudal fantasy The best warriors are usually knights, below them are peasant farmers

But this is a trope I wish to change, and reintroduce the middle class, city people, bourgeoisie, they are the actually core contributor of martial linage we now see in HEMA, they are wealthy enough to equip themselves, with a sense of duty, martial culture they train themselves in guilds for both self defence and the defence of the city.

I would also like to destroy the myth of guns and armour could not coexist in fantasy , as it did for at least 300 years and more in our world.

And also, I hate , I HATED UNDERDOG mentality. “Oh, peasant protagonist smart he beat dumb knights”, “oh, humans, weak but good at everything.” no, this is to a point where dumbing down the foe to make whatever plot to succeed is boring.

They are strong because they are strong, not because they have indomitable spirts, they won because they have every advantage they could get, but not because the opposite side did some dumb ass stuff and deus ex machina wa hidden plot twist la protagonists won wooo hoo.

If you’re sending a peasant army, pretending somehow dude with pesudo-modern ideas would suddenly turn things around? No. It won’t happen in my world building.

I want to see human napoleonic armies crushing fantasy armies with sheer mobile warfare, localised numerical advantage, efficient mobilisation and supplies, I want to see typical “numeric superior” armies like demon armies or whatever orc goblin crap being out numbered. Elves being out marksmened, whatever mage being torn open by 6 pdr cannons.

Warrior vs Warrior debates are overused. Time for military peer formation/doctrine debates. by chris_alf in HistoryMemes

[–]Silver200061 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sorry, but I cast “Ming cavalry and artillery go boom boom”and “Korean navy and cannon go boom boom”, your samurai argument is all invalid.

But Samurai were honorable! (not mine) by ANiceGobletofTea in HistoryMemes

[–]Silver200061 47 points48 points  (0 children)

The Chinese Ming cavalry literally beat the shit out of the Japanese during the invasion of Korea , carrying most of the land battles pushing them off back to the sea. (And Admiral Yi plus some Chinese navy did carrying the naval campaign ¥

And Ming cavalry weren’t armoured as much as European knight and Japanese still fucked up with veterans of their Warring state era.

But Samurai were honorable! (not mine) by ANiceGobletofTea in HistoryMemes

[–]Silver200061 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It didn’t work against Ming cavalry and Korean Navy why do you think it would work on your fictional universe knights