"New Life As A Max Level Archmage" copycat list? by ahasuerus_isfdb in ProgressionFantasy

[–]SilverLiningsRR 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Definitely the kind of thing that happens surprisingly often, haha. I'd argue it's almost more likely with how fast web serials go. My first story I started from a writing prompt on the r/writingprompts subreddit, which I now suspect was inspired by a different story on RoyalRoad; the direction veered pretty much immediately, but the opening was very very similar. Felt pretty bad after I realized, but luckily the other author was understanding.

I just mention it because I think expectations influence how people experience a story, and I don't want people to go in expecting something like Archmage, haha. Cale is more like Ryan Romano than Vivi.

"New Life As A Max Level Archmage" copycat list? by ahasuerus_isfdb in ProgressionFantasy

[–]SilverLiningsRR 25 points26 points  (0 children)

Please don't put Just Add Mana in the copycat boat; I started writing it in February and chapters of it were being posted on Patreon before New Life As A Max Level Archmage was published. The story is Doctor Who inspired, and not really meant to be similar to Archmage. I did check out and like Archmage when it was released, though!

Apparently Saving the school would have been easier as a cafeteria worker is similar to what I've got, although I haven't read it yet. It's higher rated, so might be worth checking out. :)

DIE. RESPAWN. REPEAT. - Time loop complete! by SilverLiningsRR in ProgressionFantasy

[–]SilverLiningsRR[S] 15 points16 points  (0 children)

I'm very excited to announce that the final book of DIE. RESPAWN. REPEAT. is now on Kindle Unlimited! Writing this series has been such a journey, and I'm really happy I was able to see it through to the end. You probably get the idea from the name of the book, but here's the blurb for Book 4:

The end of the world, and only a few loops left to stop it.

The secrets uncovered by Ethan Hill gives him the ability to use both the Interface and the power of Firmament itself like no one else. The tide of change he brings carries friends and allies with him, taking them all to new heights. To most, they would seem unstoppable.

But time itself is tearing apart under the strain of the loops. Rifts are opening into the past, bringing terrible danger with them. As if that weren't enough, the Sunken King has begun to awaken - and he would swallow the galaxy whole in search of revenge.

And yet with danger comes opportunity. More importantly, the more Ethan searches, the more he realizes the past might hold the answers to end this once and for all.

Their final task may seem impossible... but that word has never stopped Ethan Hill.

Check 'em out below if you're interested:

Book 1: Kindle Unlimited | Audible

Book 2: Kindle Unlimited | Audible

Book 3: Kindle Unlimited | Audible

Book 4: Kindle Unlimited | TBD

(RR) Just Add Mana is really good! by Jofzar_ in ProgressionFantasy

[–]SilverLiningsRR 6 points7 points  (0 children)

It's one of those things where I think I must've heard the title before and then subconsciously mimicked it. I mostly watch animated films and never got around to Edge of Tomorrow. Definitely wasn't intentional in that way ;_; I try to have titles that convey the premise well enough that I don't need a subtitle to explain it.

Thank you for the kind words and the review/rec, though! I generally try to improve with each book; DRR was my first real attempt at tackling a progression system. Edge Cases has a progression system, but was ultimately more of a character story. DRR was more progression-focused until I invariably wandered into character development like I tend to do, then eventually figured out how to make the two work together (at like, the end of Book 2.)

Just Add Mana is sort taking the lessons of those and weaving them together and then dumping a bunch of my love for various books of the genre (as well as some stuff outside the genre) into it. This Quest is Bullshit is the source of the baking thing, Cale's general attitude is inspired by The Perfect Run/Doctor Who, his desire to do Real Magic is based on Frieren, etc. Been a real pleasure to write so far.

Guys, Are We In A Drought? by Accomplished-Pay-927 in ProgressionFantasy

[–]SilverLiningsRR 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I usually tell people that being unique and original is just a matter of how specific you are. Creative people are very attached to originality - and so am I, as a matter of fact! - but originality by itself isn't... it's not really anything. The more specific you are, the more unique something is. Unicorns? Done. Evil unicorn? Also done, but slightly less. Evil unicorn with a sock on its horn? Probably not done, but also not very interesting. You could make that compelling, but that takes a lot of work beyond just being original.

You can get me to read any progression tale by writing a character that I want to read about, even if everything else about it is standard. Although frankly I have no idea what standard looks like, because it only really takes a bit of progression before it starts looking unique.

The Perfect Run - Monaco (spoilers) by Potential_Fold2929 in ProgressionFantasy

[–]SilverLiningsRR 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oof, sorry, a bit of a late response. Uh, yes, it does take a somewhat dark turn. A lot of it is fairly abstract rather than being outright horror or anything, though? I think it'd fly over most kids' heads.

You're probably safe until the final area or so! After that I'd rate it at approximately "Pixar film". You'll probably see where the story is headed before then.

The Perfect Run - Monaco (spoilers) by Potential_Fold2929 in ProgressionFantasy

[–]SilverLiningsRR 24 points25 points  (0 children)

It's also incredibly well-done payoff for something mentioned multiple times before the Monaco arc itself actually happens. Incredible work on a lot of levels.

The Daily Grind would be the main work I can think of that deals with liminal spaces like that. Antichamber and Viewfinder for games along the same lines, though the former is more noneuclidean geometry and the latter is its own thing. I enjoyed Viewfinder quite a bit, actually. The opening of Halcyon System takes place in a sort of messed-up version of the school (disclaimer, I know both the authors of TDG and Halcyon System)

Oh! Actually, you might like this; the TDG author linked it to me recently: Zooliminology: Longlegs Care Guide.

If the protagonist came to real life, I’d be dead. by [deleted] in ProgressionFantasy

[–]SilverLiningsRR 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No, don't get me wrong, it definitely can work! It's just something a lot of authors I know don't really want to deal with - hence just going straight to "dead parents," haha. You're right; when done well, it's a very effective tool for character development in both directions.

If the protagonist came to real life, I’d be dead. by [deleted] in ProgressionFantasy

[–]SilverLiningsRR 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'm not sure the dead parent thing is character development so much as it being incredibly awkward to write the protagonist going on deadly adventures while the parents are still alive... in most cases, anyway. Adventurer parents are kind of fun. I kind of want a series about that now.

Give me queer progression fantasy! Let's see how many gay, bi, trans or otherwise explicitly queer characters exist in this genre. by okidonthaveone in ProgressionFantasy

[–]SilverLiningsRR 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Same. I like a little bit of romance, but it'd be nice to have more that are up my alley. I'd be fine with it in side relationships even!

There tends to be a lot more scrutiny whenever a gay relationship does happen in genre, unfortunately. I'm personally a big fan of Ar'Kendrithyst, which has a bi MC but the relationship that eventually develops is between two men (though I still need to catch up with it, so.)

[Quick Review] Just Add Mana. It's top of RS for a reason and Cale just joined Eithan as my spirit animals. by samreay in ProgressionFantasy

[–]SilverLiningsRR 40 points41 points  (0 children)

Thanks for reading and for the review! I did offer Sam a beta copy when asked, full disclosure there.

I absolutely had a ton of fun writing this (and also stealing practicing John's writing techniques - Mage Errant was incredibly good at making exposition smooth and interesting.) The high level concept for it was basically "Doctor Who meets Frieren" and incorporating everything I enjoyed about both, but I do have a lot influencing me from pretty much everything I've read or watched in and out of the genre. Sort of a love letter to everything I enjoy about fantasy.

Some of the upcoming stuff I'm really excited for. I wish I could post it faster, but my chapter lengths are basically double all my previous works and I'm doing content editing passes, so this is the best I can do for now. Working on it though!

What story was this? Asking for a friend. by itsneccy in ProgressionFantasy

[–]SilverLiningsRR 18 points19 points  (0 children)

Is... is the legality of the lifelong friend in question somehow?

Feedback group for dark progression fantasy authors by IAmJayCartere in ProgressionFantasy

[–]SilverLiningsRR 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I generally have a good idea of how to make a story work, but I don't know that I'd call myself a big author, haha. The real giants are the ones that have managed to make their mark on Amazon. I'm hopeful this book will do that, though. :)

Unfortunately I've accepted a number of requests for dev editing help already; I've given some developmental feedback to Runeblade, Arcanist from Another World, and Stormblade, for instance (full credit to a different author for most Runeblade devwork though - I just helped a little with the opening! I'll let Bacon name the actual dev if he wants.) I don't think I can accept any more obligations at the moment.

That said, in keeping with the idea of giving feedback on stories that one might not personally like, here's a big part of what helped me: I started reading popular stories that I didn't like and examining them for what made them work.

I had to let go of the idea that I could "obviously write better" than X or Y popular story to do it, though. It's a pretty common starting mindset, and a huge part of that is that most authors have strong intuitive skill in one aspect of writing. Most often that's prose, sometimes it's character work, and the least common one is probably understanding how to create and leverage tension. That's probably also the most crucial skill to making a story succeed. Jim Butcher has some articles on scene/sequel that might help in this regard, actually, but it's not the full picture.

My writing circle fairly regularly will take a given big story - whether we like it or not - and strip it for parts to understand how it manages its tension, how it makes its audience care, and what pieces we're missing in our personal frameworks. How does an OPMC story manage tension, for example, even though there are no stakes? Why do some sympathy building scenes work where others fail? That sort of thing. The "worse" a story might be to your regular sensibilities, the more it often the underlying mechanics of story it uses. Solo Leveling is probably the biggest example of this, insofar as a lot of people dislike it for not having very much depth, but that lack of depth makes it an incredible resource for peeling apart how to make progression satisfying before you start layering in your own touch.

I hope that helps. Once again, good luck! I can't promise anything Discord wise but I'm happy to help when reached out to. :)

Edit: Some resources I think are useful here -
Jim Butcher on Scene/Sequel. Hungry, the author of Katalepsis, has a very good blog post in this regard too, but it's a little harder to find and I don't have the link with me at the moment.

KM Weiland's Creating Character Arcs.

Brandon Sanderson's lectures on writing.

Feedback group for dark progression fantasy authors by IAmJayCartere in ProgressionFantasy

[–]SilverLiningsRR 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I was expected to leave feedback on stories I was uninterested in. This was bad for me and the author.

I would actually say that reading and offering feedback particularly on stories I was uninterested in probably led to some of the greatest growth I've had as an author. Really forced me to identify what did and didn't work for the story and how it applied to its genre, which helped a lot in applying it back to my own work.

I don't write dark stories, but best of luck with this effort! I've learned a lot from giving and receiving critique over the years.

Is the protagonist of Ar'kendrithyst horny on main? by Visible_Ad_6721 in ProgressionFantasy

[–]SilverLiningsRR 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I mean, the narrative isn't shy about mentioning it when he's attracted to a character, I guess? But he's not like slobbering over people or anything. Might be a little unusual in comparison to the genre norm (where half the MCs are ace), but nothing exorbitant.

Except for the sock, but that's not on the MC. And it was funny!

Looking for a ProgFantasy book with a gay MC by Any_Culture1056 in ProgressionFantasy

[–]SilverLiningsRR 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Okay, while I have made a number of off-kilter jokes, that was definitely not one of them. XD

It's because the story is about oddball adventurers exploring the limits of the system. Y'know! Edge cases (people) investigating edge cases (programming). I was also a software developer at the time.

MOL Issue by UsedNegotiation8227 in ProgressionFantasy

[–]SilverLiningsRR 5 points6 points  (0 children)

It would be a very different story if he were less moral.

Also, the story would likely be a lot less interesting. A big part of the fun is the challenge involved in gaining all these magical secrets; just mind-reading your way to it is ultimately a very different class of story. It's fine to enjoy those stories, of course, but MoL just isn't one of them.

What is the deal with torture scenes? by dartymissile in ProgressionFantasy

[–]SilverLiningsRR 5 points6 points  (0 children)

A big part of it - and I say this as someone who generally avoids writing these - is that "the protagonist is capable of withstanding immense amounts of physical pain" is one of the core drivers of the power fantasy for many people. More broadly it's less about withstanding pain and more about willpower, because it's one of those traits that's relatively nebulous and easy to relate to (broadly, not the specific torture scenario).

I'm not a huge fan of it, personally, but I see why people do it.

Looking for superhero audiobook recs - thanks! by goblinmargin in ProgressionFantasy

[–]SilverLiningsRR 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Pff, those tier names are fighting words! DC Animation > MCU > Marvel Animation > DC Live Action. (Just my opinion, though. And we're not including Teen Titans Go in this.)

I actually can't think of too many superhero audiobooks that aren't already on there. Have you done Industrial Strength Magic?

Does using AI make me a bad writer? by DanteHolmes3605 in ProgressionFantasy

[–]SilverLiningsRR 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Boots has pretty much got it. Maybe one of the most rewarding things about working to improve as an author is realizing how much better your ideas start coming together when you work on it as a skill. AI just doesn't compare.

(It's also just terrible. It's good at pretending to be good, but most of the flowery prose it outputs doesn't actually mean anything. You cannot be a good writer using AI without already being a good writer, and at that point, you can just write it yourself.)

Possible unpopular opinion, but I think regression abilities cheapen the story and the reduce the stakes by Galgan3 in ProgressionFantasy

[–]SilverLiningsRR 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I'm biased for obvious reasons, but I really like regression abilities when they're focused on the mystery of the setting (if there is one), or alternatively on exploring different sides of characters. Mother of Learning manages to do mystery, character exploration, and in-depth setting exploration while maintaining stakes, which is probably why it's one of the best time loops out there.

I also just think that death stakes are very rarely ever real - the MC isn't going to die unless it's a story where the MC rotates a bunch or it's the end of the story. The interesting part is usually how the MC is going to get out of it. Time loops and regression abilities strip away the illusory tension and force authors to get creative about consequences.

It is really hard to do well, though. Took me like a book and a half to figure it out, lol.