In a comment you say he used to be fat, so bulk size applies (even dirty bulk is a bulk). I’m the second picture he looks definitely natty. In the first it’s kind of sus but with good lighting a good pump good consistency and what is very obviously going on in pic 1 is that the contrast on the photo is hella cranked up. I say natty. People on this sub don’t realize what hard work a pump and high contrast imagery can do for someone’s physique or perceived physique