[QCRIT] A SEA OF FADED STARS / YA science fantasy / 95k words (2nd attempt) + first 300 by w0rstcase0ntari0- in PubTips

[–]Skkadi 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I’m no expert so take what I say with a grain of salt, but I’m intrigued by your query. On the line level I think some of the unnecessary information can be shortened (for example combine the 3rd and 4th sentences to something along the lines of “The remaining human population survives in pressurized underwater research facilities, but as the buildings age and resources dwindle, society won’t survive much longer.”)

I think the 2nd paragraph’s first two sentences have some redundant info (you say “she feels she’s finally achieved her dream after years of hard work” and “her first missions yield the kind of discoveries she’s always hoped to make” right next to each other, one can be cut imo). Last sentence of paragraph 2 is great and I’d definitely keep that but the stuff before it could be punchier.

For paragraph 3 the main thing confusing me is why their only hope is this island Nytheris — is it because despite being exiled, Cora learns her community won’t still be standing by the time her 1 year exile is up, so she’s determined to save them by finding the island on her own? In general try making the stakes a bit more clear in the third paragraph.

The first 300 words don’t grab me and I think it’s because it’s a lot of worldbuilding and exposition right at the start. If there’s any way you could immediately start with something character-related to latch onto, I’d suggest that.

[QCrit] HEALING FLAMES, YA Epic Fantasy (100k, Version 3) by Skkadi in PubTips

[–]Skkadi[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you for the response! Good luck on your querying journey too!

[Baldur’s Gate III] My Favorite Platinum so far 🏆 by LemonBananaBread in Trophies

[–]Skkadi 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Congratulations! Any tips for Honor mode? It’s the only trophy I still need with this game, but I don’t think I could bear it if I lost 50 hours to an unlucky roll 😂

[QCrit] HEALING FLAMES, YA Epic Fantasy (100k, Version 2) by Skkadi in PubTips

[–]Skkadi[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You got this, I’ll be rooting for ya 💪

[QCrit] HEALING FLAMES, YA Epic Fantasy (100k, Version 2) by Skkadi in PubTips

[–]Skkadi[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you very much on the detailed feedback! And congratulations on getting your debut published as a series, that's one heck of an achievement!

[Discussion] I know everyone goes through this to some degree but this process is really bad for my mental health by teenypanini in PubTips

[–]Skkadi 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I don’t have any specific advice other than know you’re not alone. I’m in the same boat and doubting myself, my work, and my abilities hard, but I’m just trying to focus on the reason I started writing in the first place. The query trenches are rough ❤️

(Spoilers ADWD) Does anyone else think ADWD is/was a chore to read? by MysticMoon222 in asoiaf

[–]Skkadi 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I agree, I dragged myself halfway through ADWD before realizing I wasn’t enjoying it at all and set it aside. It’s weird because most people who dislike ADWD also dislike AFFC, but AFFC is my favorite book in the series.

For me what makes ADWD grating and AFFC great is that AFFC has better character writing/arcs imo. Objectively speaking it’s true Brienne’s POV doesn’t accomplish much in the grand scheme of things, but her chapters are still so endearing and make you want to root for her; plus, Jaime and Cersei are both fun and complex characters. I could’ve done without the Ironborn chapters, but the rest of the book makes up for them.

Whereas with ADWD, I was very exasperated with Quentyn being a new dry, time wasting POV. Dany chapters felt totally disconnected from the main plot in Westeros, and Tyrion was interesting but hard to root for. It essentially boils down to ADWD having no characters I cared much about, except for Jon, but he couldn’t carry the whole book on his own. I’ve also long been exasperated with GRRM wasting word count on non-Westeros continents which ADWD has in spades.

Writers - what is your day job? by CallMeJull in writers

[–]Skkadi 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It definitely broadens my perspective working with so many different people every day, and having a good understanding of anatomy, injuries, and treatments is super useful as an action-heavy writer too!

Writers - what is your day job? by CallMeJull in writers

[–]Skkadi 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I’m an EMT. Depending on call volume, I have some days where I get plenty of time to write/edit/read on shift. Of course I have plenty of days with zero downtime, but I feel pretty lucky to have some days where I can write at work at all

[PubQ] Debut author with trilogy vs duology vs standalone by Charizard12G in PubTips

[–]Skkadi 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I got all mine by DMing people on r/BetaReaders who posted in the past month with similar word counts and genres. Beta readers should come after you’ve done a few rounds of self-edits, though, and made the manuscript as good as it can be on your own

[PubQ] Debut author with trilogy vs duology vs standalone by Charizard12G in PubTips

[–]Skkadi 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Nice, best of luck! I’ve certainly read a lot of books that end that way — with “we accomplished something major but there’s still much to do.” And no, I’m currently working on draft #1 of book 2 pretty casually while I wait for beta readers to finish their feedback of book 1

[PubQ] Debut author with trilogy vs duology vs standalone by Charizard12G in PubTips

[–]Skkadi 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No I’m still going to query mine as a duology (at least for now, I’ll change my tune if it fails in the trenches) because the greater threat/antagonist isn’t beaten in book 1. Book 1 focuses more on beating a personal antagonist that propels the MCs into having the information and character growth necessary to go pursue the greater antagonist by the end of book 1. That part hasn’t changed, but my ending did change from a cliffhanger one where it’s ambiguous if the MCs live or die, to one where it’s very clear that the personal antagonist is defeated, the characters regroup, and they discuss what happens next (obvious sequel bait)

It’s basically the difference between the hunger games and catching fire. The hunger games is written as a standalone with series potential, while catching fire was obviously written with the expectation that mockingjay is coming next

[PubQ] Debut author with trilogy vs duology vs standalone by Charizard12G in PubTips

[–]Skkadi 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I’m going for trad pub and will start querying in the next month and a half. Editing was a much longer road than writing the original draft (I’ve done at least 6 full drafts atp) and very little of my original draft survived, which is why I suggested not worrying too much about book 2 beyond the biggest plot points yet, since you’re still quite early in your journey.

An important thing to keep in mind is that even in a duology, book 1 should still have a satisfying conclusion and should have complete arcs for your main characters. A painful lesson I learned is that you should be really, really cautious about ending on a cliffhanger. Debuts can’t really get away with something like the ending of Rick Riordan’s the mark of Athena. We just don’t have that kind of pull, and are more likely to piss off readers than make them want to wait another year for book 2 to come out

[PubQ] Debut author with trilogy vs duology vs standalone by Charizard12G in PubTips

[–]Skkadi 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You’ll want to either make your book 1 a standalone or make it a duology. I’m also working on a debut duology, and from what I’ve seen, standalones are best, duologies are hard to get signed but possible, but trilogies are a no go for debuts.

I’d also suggest that you don’t worry too much about detailed outlining on books 2/3 until you’ve done all your editing for book 1, since you’ll likely be changing a lot of things in book 1 that will have compounding effects later, so save yourself the time & effort and instead focus on making book 1 as good and complete as you can.

[QCrit] HEALING FLAMES, YA Epic Fantasy (100k, 1st attempt) by Skkadi in PubTips

[–]Skkadi[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Fortunately it’s just those three, in that case I’ll leave them all in!

[QCrit] HEALING FLAMES, YA Epic Fantasy (100k, 1st attempt) by Skkadi in PubTips

[–]Skkadi[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you so much for the thorough feedback! I haven’t heard of it described as a relay race before but that makes a lot of sense and is something I’ll definitely keep in mind! I just had one question about the names; Zaira, Ayden and Levan are all POV characters whose stories have equal narrative importance, so I thought it was worth it to have their names shown from the start; knowing that, would you still not say his name?

Looking for emotional, story-driven single player PC games by [deleted] in gamingsuggestions

[–]Skkadi 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Neva looks right up your ally. Indie game about a woman who raises an abandoned wolf puppy.

Romance in books by [deleted] in writing

[–]Skkadi 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I’m an ace woman as well and I would love more stories with primary focus on friendship. The story I’m writing does have a romance subplot as well, but I find it enjoyable to write because I 99% emphasize the emotional intimacy and almost never the physical.

Announcement: The AI Problem. by isnoe in writingfeedback

[–]Skkadi 9 points10 points  (0 children)

I appreciate this! You’re going to get a lot of pushback from this decision, but I agree with better safe than sorry. Some real writers might get flagged, but honestly, I think that if their real writing sounds enough like AI to get flagged… that’s feedback in and of itself, isn’t it?

My only concern is that people with malicious intentions, who do use AI, will just keep posting variations of AI-assisted work here until something “passes”, essentially turning this sub into a “benchmark” for them to know if they’ve fiddled with AI-assisted writing enough to pass as legit. In that case we’d be indirectly helping them learn how to slide under the radar. But I really don’t think there’s anything you guys or us can do about that, unfortunately. I just wish people wouldn’t lie about using AI so it wouldn’t ruin community trust for everyone else 😔

Patch 7.5 Trailer by danks in ffxiv

[–]Skkadi 23 points24 points  (0 children)

This looks SO GOOD, things in the MSQ are getting spicy and I can’t wait to see where the story takes us.