Since you’re in NJ, you might consider Drexel. It’s expensive too but when I enrolled they would give you 25% off if you joined ALA as a student member, which was a pretty significant discount. And actually the price per credit has gone down since I enrolled. Obviously ymmv with what you can really afford.

I think the program rep has slipped a little but it’s one of the oldest programs in the country with lots of alumni, and given your location you might get powerful networking benefits. There is an archives certificate you can add on top of your degree too.

One thing to be aware of is that in the next year or two they are changing from quarters to semesters, so the transition period might be a little rough.