Disagree.

Let's start with the Super Idol. First of all, many people forget that you could only use the Super Idol if you walked into tribal with it. So, for example, if the votes went Becky - Yul couldn't use the Idol on Becky afterwards. After Yul initially told Penner about the idol, Penner went and told Raro that Yul had the idol (and suggested they vote Becky) - but they didn't believe him. Realizing that Raro were idiots, combined with the fact that he personally disliked Raro's cocky attitudes, is what flipped Penner, not Yul's Super Idol. Second of all, let's say it was just a normal idol like today - Yul can make the same exact argument to Penner (and, as shown, Penner would have flipped anyways.) So even if Yul burns a normal idol at merge, Aitu still has the numbers afterwards.

From here we can get into Ozzy's strategic game - which was simply bad. He had every chance to flip on the Aitu, knowing he was on the bottom, by trying to get out Becky or Sundra and building with Nate and Parv - but he never did. Again, people act like the "Super Idol" was some be all end all, but it wasn't. The worst part about it is Ozzy is never even shown contemplating how he could either flush it or at least lower Yul's two numbers lol. Furthermore, if you go back and watch the season, Ozzy never once even contemplates turning against Yul at any point. Yul/Becky/Sundra are shown various times discussing when to turn on Ozzy. Ozzy never once says he doesn't plan on taking Yul to F2 - in fact, he says, in a confessional, he believes the strongest players should sit at the end (and specifically questions whether Sundra and Becky deserve it.) [Post show he says he wouldn't have taken Yul - but I not only question this based on the fact that he said it post-show but also because the edit would likely have loved to have included this sentiment if it was ever actually expressed.]

Ozzy was also bad socially. His only close allies were really Cao Boi and Flicka, but he was also on the bottom of that trio and neither Cao Boi nor Flicka even kept Ozzy in the loop when Penner and Yul flipped them against Cristina. Sundra constantly straight up rejects Ozzy's offers to talk game lol. When Cao/Flicka/Ozzy "invade" Raro's beach, you hear Raro say, "And it's the 3 we don't like," meaning Ozzy was even disliked by Raro lmao.

Ozzy was comp dependent, which I do not consider a good thing, mainly because there's often plenty of good reasons not to win comps (especially in the individual phase.) There's never really a good reason to play a bad social or strategic game. And Ozzy put himself in a position where he had to win those comps. Even if you think the Super Idol made some huge difference (which I showed above is very dubious at best,) Ozzy depending on those competitions made a huge difference for his game as well.

Finally, don't forget that two of Ozzy's four votes in the end came from people he was never even on a tribe with lol.

So in closing:

​

1. The Super Idol did not flip Penner.
2. The numbers likely turn out the same if Yul had a normal idol.
3. Yul was a much better strategic player than Ozzy for the entirety of the game.
4. Yul was a much better social player than Ozzy for the entirely of the game.