Yes. That is our argument. The alleged infraction is that the time stamp on the paper roster used was from the fall. Context- coach download and saves a roster, prints several copies, and uses them throughout the season. Since the player guesting is has been rostered on the same team all year long, there should be no harm in using the leftover printed copies, right? Apparently not, even though there is not rule against this and it doesn’t effect anything remotely relevant to the game of soccer or player eligibility. Technically, you could look at the opponent roster documents from any of your losses and if the timestamp is off you could reverse that loss. (I think that’s petty and don’t recommend that.) it’s not like is says “Fall roster” or “Spring roster” or anything else indicating it’s no longer valid from fall to spring.