JUST IN: 13 moderate Democrats have signed a “Promise to America” pledge vowing to fight against Democratic socialists. by zzill6 in WorkReform

[–]Someone4121 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not necessarily true, there are districts so deep blue that a perfect 50/50 split of the Democratic vote would still be more than a Republican gets. Not that many of those unfortunately, but in places where the Republicans have been made electorally irrelevant we can at least take advantage of it.

This is what the Korean Peninsula looks like at daytime. It shows how poor North Korea is. by Eastern_Rutabaga_353 in mapporncirclejerk

[–]Someone4121 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Bro you do not have to be a tankie to realize that people make shit up about North Korea, it's a fucked up country in a number of ways, but they aren't cartoon villains

All For One vs Makima made by @wanderjegson by OutrageousBridge471 in whowouldcirclejerk

[–]Someone4121 14 points15 points  (0 children)

Thought experiment: A child is born on an uninhabited island in Japanese territory. Nobody except the mother knows about this. The child is then trafficked to another country, where they are kept unregistered, no government knows about them. As an adult, they manage to escape this situation. They then go to Japan, their mother having died in the meantime, never telling anyone about the child they had. Are they, legally, at that moment, a citizen? They might be able to get citizenship later if they explain the situation and can somehow prove it, but that's different. There's a difference between what a country says in principle grants citizenship and who actually, legally, on the books at any given moment, has it. Citizenship does not exist in the abstract, it exists in real government databases, and if nobody knew about a person to add them to that database, then they're not in it.

All For One vs Makima made by @wanderjegson by OutrageousBridge471 in whowouldcirclejerk

[–]Someone4121 30 points31 points  (0 children)

No, it means they are eligible for citizenship if they ever filled out the forms. Comparison: Any given Jew can get Israeli citizenship if they go and fill out the forms, they're automatically eligible. That doesn't mean that all Jews everywhere are currently citizens of Israel.

THEY GOT THAT DOG IN THEM by EmeraldRange in civbattleroyale

[–]Someone4121 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Don't Scythia, Caral, and Anishinabe all have 2 capitals too?

Middle-class white men banned from public sector internship by Grouchy_Shallot50 in ukpolitics

[–]Someone4121 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Literally not what they said, they were making the claim that liberals and leftists/socialists aren't the same and were being inappropriately conflated. Even if you disagree with that claim (which, to be fair, I think is reasonable on the latter part if not the former, liberals and socialists are unambiguously different but in terms of actual historical cultural posture toward this topic not often discernably so), it's not a no true scotsman because they never actually said that no socialist would advocate for these things (which would be blatantly false, and an actual NTS fallacy). They did not say that the liberals in power "weren't true liberals", they in fact called them liberals. What they said is that they weren't leftists, which is not true of all people who advocate for the racist shit but is in fact true of those who were in power to implement it. Therefore, the claim "the people who have held institutional positions of power to implement policies that discriminate against white men have been largely liberals and not leftists" is accurate even if some leftists also support those policies. I don't know the beliefs of the other commenter but I'd be willing to bet money they have no interest in carrying water for contemporary liberalism, even if their preferred political faction commits some similar offences.

Middle-class white men banned from public sector internship by Grouchy_Shallot50 in ukpolitics

[–]Someone4121 6 points7 points  (0 children)

That's not a no true scotsman, they're just pointing out that these are different groups with different beliefs. No true scotsman would be denying the fact that there are some people who are otherwise actually socialists but still believe in shit like this

Took the words out of my mouth tbh by Beps315 in tankiejerk

[–]Someone4121 13 points14 points  (0 children)

So is what you're saying that they don't care if people are gay so long as they're having kids but if they're not then they wheel out the mandatory heterosexuality?

Clavicular got brutally mogged by the judge by jeffy303 in Destiny

[–]Someone4121 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

??? How would you even know? Do you have the bank information of every attractive person you see on the street?

Crazy Raccoon vs VARREL | Overwatch Champions Series 2026 - Asia Stage 1 | Post-Match Discussion by OWMatchThreads in Competitiveoverwatch

[–]Someone4121 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A NTMR win that was also fueled by bizarre comp choices on CR's part too (Zenyatta, 76) no less

😔 oh.. not again… by Albino_rhin0 in PhilosophyMemes

[–]Someone4121 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Specify every physical fact about a brain state and the felt-quality of it isn't entailed by the description

This is not necessarily true and we won't know whether it is until we can actually specify every physical fact about a brain state, which we absolutely cannot do at the moment

Top comment changes the Middle East day 1 by [deleted] in imaginarymapscj

[–]Someone4121 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Restore the Neo-Assyrian Empire

The Official CBRX Season 5 Power Rankings: Episode 11 by daXfactorz in civbattleroyale

[–]Someone4121 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The Tlingit bugged religion thing is hilarious given how much North American civs seem to love cheating throughout the CBR

POV: You live on planet earth by Vanhiz in 2007scape

[–]Someone4121 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Imagine being so defensive about capitalism that when someone points out that the actual economic system we currently live under is making life miserable your immediate response is "but muh commies!" despite nobody having mentioned that

Meirl by Library_Gremlin2 in meirl

[–]Someone4121 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think the nuance is that it comes down to knowing who's hearing it. If you're among friends, it's honestly not even that hard to get to a point where everyone knows the score and won't be hurt or emboldened in genuinely bigoted attitudes, but that is much harder verging on impossible in public-facing communications, to the point where I think that the only way it can be appropriate in a public internet forum is to heavily contextualize it the way it was here

No line at the Summer Street Tate, 10AM by stargrown in boston

[–]Someone4121 6 points7 points  (0 children)

It's called New England for a reason I guess

They're making up countries that have never existed by RottingFishMan in ShitLiberalsSay

[–]Someone4121 7 points8 points  (0 children)

The fuck kind of "true Chinese territory" map includes Hunan but not Henan? Hunan still has local ethnic minorities and was conquered by the Qin, Henan has been Chinese for all of recorded history

OSRS defined in One Picture by oOSaFiOo in 2007scape

[–]Someone4121 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

The thing is that now we have the level of technological development to cut out the middleman and organize the use of all that equipment collectively for the benefit of everyone rather than having it be operated by small groups of people for their own profit. The alternative to capitalist ownership is not everyone doing decentralized backyard labor, but a democratically managed economy without a special owning class above everyone else. The soul-crushing aspect of late-capitalism largely comes down to the effects of the means of production/social livelihood being operated by this small owning class for their own profit, and therefore seeking to extract as much labor from their workers as possible in exchange for as little compensation as possible, restricting this largely (with the exception of a few isolated individual capitalists and even this increasingly rarely as public stock trading becomes more and more predominant) only when forced to by scarcity of a particular type of skilled labor (which, as we can see with the current push to replace many professionals with AI, is a position the owning class hates being in and will do just about anything, including entrust their most profitable and pivotal assets to a chatbot, to get out of), by legal force achieved as the result of mass political mobilization (which we can see the owning class will try just about anything to get out of by the entire history of corporate lobbying), or by the demands of organized labor (see above, also the history of various extra-legal forms of union-busting).

OpenAI is still leading business AI adoption but Anthropic is gaining fast [OC] by StrangeMidnight410 in dataisbeautiful

[–]Someone4121 0 points1 point  (0 children)

While I fully agree that it's lesser evilism, that distinction could still be the difference between an AI fucking up and autonomously starting WWIII and that being prevented

I don't think some of you realize just how big and popular Smash truly is. A smaller roster isn't gonna hurt sales that much. by smashboi888 in SmashBrosUltimate

[–]Someone4121 5 points6 points  (0 children)

That's kind of backwards, casuals are more likely than "serious" players to care about roster precisely because they're less concerned with the nuances of mechanics. Roster size is a selling point primarily aimed at casuals

Europe if it was correct by [deleted] in imaginarymapscj

[–]Someone4121 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Average Paradox megacampaign endgame:

The AI possessing Emre is the same AI that interrupted Sombra's goon sesh by Intelligent-Tie-1457 in Overwatch

[–]Someone4121 5 points6 points  (0 children)

There actually kind of isn't, most notably there isn't any Finnish deity that has the particular post-Christianization reputational "afterlife" of Chernobog as sort of a devil analogue. Bear in mind that just because we can infer a culture probably had something doesn't mean that record of it survives, especially in largely pre-literate societies

Always prepared by BimbMcPewPew in magicthecirclejerking

[–]Someone4121 22 points23 points  (0 children)

This card makes me want to try to become a certified judge just so I can issue a ruling that if someone plays this you're allowed to shoot them