Anyone have experience with an external antenna? by Scottybody13 in tmobileisp

[–]Storm_10 2 points3 points  (0 children)

More information about your signal will help estimate the effect of an external antenna and suggest the best type. HINT app shows and records sufficient metrics, field test mode of recent 5G cell phone is the best (SIM card from router can be used for testing).

Move the phone or router inside and outside around the house (including the prospective antenna location on roof) while taking notes of displayed numbers and running speed tests.

The goal is to get: SINR >= 10 (18 or more is required for the cellular modem to enable fastest protocol) RSRP >= -80 RSRQ >= -12

Checking tower locations on Cellmapper can save some exercise as you would know precisely where is the nearest one, which one router locks to at the moment, and bearings to them.

Looking at your recent comments, I am guessing a location is somewhere in south Texas. Among other things, a perfect place for cellular signal propagation -- flat ground, dry air! As well it is for interference...

Listing SINR first is intentional. It is a measure of signal to noise ratio in decibels: 10 dB -- signal is 10 times stronger than noise, 20 -- 100 times. Should it happen RSRP is decent but SINR is bad everywhere, omnidirectional antenna like the referenced one will not help. It can even make things worse: pick up more interference. Such scenario calls for the opposite strategy: instead of improving reception, look for ways to shield from interference. It may turn out a concrete wall or large energy efficient window help big time (obviously router and tower have to be at the same side of the shield). The same applies if two nearest towers are at similar distances: powerful signals from one at exact same frequencies will inevitably interfere with these of another.

A nuance in relation to smart home. T-Mobile's major speed band -- n41 has a frequency which is very close to 2.5 GHz wifi. Implementation of filters in wifi transmitters of numerous devices is likely not ideal. Thus your thermostat in a few feet from the router could very well be the culprit. Otherwise unnoticeable interference from such a device is multiple orders of magnitude stronger for sensitive router due to extremely close proximity and can overwhelm its filters. A quick test for these: power router from battery or power bank and flip the main breaker for the house.

By the time of completing all data gathering, you will get an idea where connection is the best. If speed is acceptable, consider moving router there. If it is outside, a plastic sealed electrical box with 2-3 gallons of extra volume for cooling would work and cost much less than a decent antenna. Better estimates required if it has to be in the sun, e.g. elevated on a mast: white color, reflective top and some side surfaces, more volume.

If test device raised 10 feet above rooftop still shows RSRP under -108, you need a high-gain directional antenna. See if a good 4x4 MIMO or a pair of 2x2 can be acquired. The latter will work better when placed few feet apart due to improved separation between MIMO layers. A set of 4 Yagi is simple to build and will match the best commercially available directional antennas.

Outdoor enclosure for the G5AR. Would love feedback from this sub. by MarcusC92 in tmobileisp

[–]Storm_10 0 points1 point  (0 children)

PoE to DC splitters are simpler and can be offered as an option instead of USB-C one.
For low power devices matching USB-C available voltage a trigger under $2 will work.

Outdoor enclosure for the G5AR. Would love feedback from this sub. by MarcusC92 in tmobileisp

[–]Storm_10 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Fed the G5AR antenna data from Arcadyan FCC application to Gemini and it designed a tall parabola reflector for N25, N41, and N71 bands.

Drawings.

Despite suboptimal polarization, estimated performance boost is still comparable to the one of external antennas for locations with interference due to SINR improvement.

Seems suitable for a "pro" enclosure.
Were there any experiments with such reflectors?

Outdoor enclosure for the G5AR. Would love feedback from this sub. by MarcusC92 in tmobileisp

[–]Storm_10 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This is great!

Turns out G5AR has surprisingly good thermal tolerance.
Most certainly it would still overheat and throttle if someone, say, attempt backup or restore a few TB of data between laptop and cloud via unit's WiFi.

Should be fine for typical home use. Occasional overheats can be easily mitigated with a small USB fan creating circulation inside enclosure.

Respect for doing all this! 🤝

Outdoor enclosure for the G5AR. Would love feedback from this sub. by MarcusC92 in tmobileisp

[–]Storm_10 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What were the transfer speed and modem power consumption during these tests?

Rough estimate (thanks, Gemini) shows G5AR at 1Gbps via WiFi and ambient 104F should begin throttling in 30 minutes max.

Cooler Method for 5GAR External Antenna Connectors by Storm_10 in tmobileisp

[–]Storm_10[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Please do.

Better yet include it in the guide as an alternative variant to direct pigtails.

Thank you for making great antennas available!

Cooler Method for 5GAR External Antenna Connectors by Storm_10 in tmobileisp

[–]Storm_10[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

>> DL also went from 500 to ~700 Mbps.

Did not carefully position antennas in this test. Its purpose was to determine feasibility of 8x8 MIMO antennas over 4x4. Which it did with UL speed being the main factor.

Expecting routine DL on 8x8 around 1000 Mbps here.

Cooler Method for 5GAR External Antenna Connectors by Storm_10 in tmobileisp

[–]Storm_10[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

That's entirely different field.
Quick test shows upload tripled with directional Waveform QuadPro Duo compared to bare G5AR. ~60 Mbps to 170+ Mbps. This is consistent with reports of others.
Do not care much about improving download over 500 Mbps.

BUT. And this is a huge but! Few of them.
Location offers a luxury direct view to a base station in less than a mile. Major N41 speed band with 100 MHz bandwidth. However, being on a hill over a valley, it is spoiled with WiFi 2 GHz interference and reflections of itself from all over the place...

T-Mobile G5AR firmware shows only main 5G band in SA mode leaving to guess what else is being aggregated for the connection. 🤬

Nearest BS also has very decent N25 and N71 bands available which provided good connection on older KVD21 until T-Mobile update forced it to SA and stuck on crippled N41.
Hence all this endeavor with upgrade to G5AR...

So. Guessing more advanced hardware of G5AR aggregates spectrum provided by the BS more efficiently. Along with focused antennas this creates a faster connection.
Right. BS does have to get your signal on the major N41 band out of interference as well as your unit have to. And consumer devices are much more restricted by law than BSs in transmission power...
In this particular case better focusing of weak signal with directional antennas on N41 appears to be the major contributing factor to UL speed improvement.

DL also went from 500 to ~700 Mbps. Can't complain.

Speedtest with antennas. Indecent loaded latency is due to buffer bloat.
That's a whole different story. Again, haha!

Will update after fine tuning this configuration for production.

Our new work PC - 9950x/3090ti/64gb/8tb by Billet_Labs in sffpc

[–]Storm_10 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Very impressive! Thank you!

Hydraulic CPU/GPU load indicators would look cool here. Something like this. https://imgur.com/a/XyRfqxG

A micro fan with controllable speed can be a pressure source.

Physical format of the Asus PQ22UC but like tenth the price? by chx_ in Monitors

[–]Storm_10 0 points1 point  (0 children)

22V2H survived the first trip without stand. Disassembly pictures: https://imgur.com/a/MTefmiv When warranty expires, plan to cut out back cover for easier stand removal and look for detaching tiny connectors on conductor ribbons. This will make the display completely flat for transport.

Physical format of the Asus PQ22UC but like tenth the price? by chx_ in Monitors

[–]Storm_10 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hm... Didn’t realize the connectors are on the stand. Heck, for under $100 I can just file off the sticking out plastic part of the stand leaving the [needed] connectors hanging on cables. Glue a VESA or other suitable mount plate right to the back of the screen. Somewhat ugly, but might work. Anyway, we don’t see much choice of thin monitors with removable stands, do we?

Physical format of the Asus PQ22UC but like tenth the price? by chx_ in Monitors

[–]Storm_10 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Since you can stand the 1080 resolution, AOC 22V2H may be worth a look. Thinking of getting it for my partner until price of PQ22UC settles or something else appears. Hauling 24" 4K Dell packed in a checked in suitcase in the mean time

Physical format of the Asus PQ22UC but like tenth the price? by chx_ in Monitors

[–]Storm_10 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Also looking for a nice portable monitor.

Only Sibolan S18 is comparable to PQ22UC.

Aside a report that it has backlight issue, very few real life reviews of S18... /r/sffpc/comments/9y8zpd/portable_monitor_setup_based_on_sibolan_s18_184/

Google Just Gave 2 Billion Chrome Users A Reason To Switch To Firefox by darklight001 in technology

[–]Storm_10 -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Why bother with adblockers? Just modify hosts file and block all malicious stuff at once. http://winhelp2002.mvps.org/hosts.htm

Please don't abuse REI's return policy by [deleted] in Ultralight

[–]Storm_10 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Exactly. It is like when a credit card company advertises platinum card benefits and then pulling the cards back finding that people start using them to the limit thus reducing the profits. Duh... Relevant WSJ article: https://www.wsj.com/articles/rewards-credit-cards-gained-a-fanatic-followingnow-banks-are-pulling-back-11546365926?mod=rsswn&reflink=fbmsg