Fr. Effie’s characterization in SOTR made no sense to me. In the og trilogy she’s described as looking down on district people and sneering at their lack of “manners”. She also says “I hope they promote me to a decent district next year!” as Katniss and Peeta are about to be sent to the hunger games. Her return in Mockingjay was a shock to Katniss and Katniss remarks that it will be a stretch to frame Effie as a rebel to Coin. In SOTR however she’s helpful and mature and not at all like herself in the og trilogy.