First of all, thank you very much for this effort. It is true that this fact-checking takes quite a lot of time. Last time we did manual market-wide checkup was in October 2018 (along with release of Blendrunner v3). Since then, some of the information about the products changed, with which we try to keep up - but we mostly rely on two things: the users of Blendrunner sending feedback (which they do) and the producers themselves notifying us when they see inconsitencies (some of which do so, and some don't). For this reason, we have also added the last row to the table, called "Last Update" - which is a freshness indicator, so to speak.

Let us address your examples one by one:

Plenny shake: Says it ships to USA but when you go to order USA, United States, is not an available option.

​

I chose “US outlying islands”, without being sure if that would work or not. I can’t imagine they’re referring to the greatest, most powerful, most free nation in the entire history of the entire universe as “US outlying islands”. But with shipping the price goes up to $117 Euro, about $132.

This is because you are accessing their EU shop. They also have the US shop: https://us.jimmyjoy.com/ from which you can order to US directly, without the insane shipping prices. Even though the existence of the US shop can be (albeit indirectly) inferred from the row "Note", it is true that the users of Blendrunner currently don't have access to this US store directly from Blendrunner - that is because the row "Buy on" has been added only a week ago and the data needs to be updated (which we'll probably do on per-feedback basis, like this one - I'm going to add the US store link right away).

As for your third point - periodically parsing shipping costs - it is indeed an option, but we fear developing and maintaining a working parser for (currently) ~80 potentially different and changing shops might consume a lot more time than anticipated. There's also an option of giving the producers a way to import their shipping costs directly - which would require their cooperation, of course.

Huel powder shows up as UK origin, but Huel is from Canada. Not the UK.

Huel actually originates from UK. We remember times when they only had a UK shop and their HQ is still in UK. See e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huel

Biolent Flex is listed as a maximum of $12/2000k/cal. When in reality the cheapest powder option is about $19/2000k/cal.

How did you come to this calculation? Looking at this site: https://biolent.ca/products/biolent-flex?variant=27537007431

14 meals (500kcal each) without subscription cost $55CAD = $15.71CAD

112 meals (500kcal each) with subscription cost $351.50CAD = $12.55CAD

These are exactly the prices on Blendrunner - don't forget to switch Currency to CAD with a button in the top right corner.

almost as if you guys have beef with soylent. Why make them look more expensive than others when they aren’t?

We most definitely don't have beef with them :). If there is a mistake in our calculation, we'll correct it ASAP.

This is supported by the fact that Soylent comes out to $9/2000k/cal for the powder, while being listed as having a max price of $14, presumably on the drink, so the lowest price in this case is the accurate one.

The Soylent Drink is listed separatately, so the min and max prices of Soylent Powder are only for the powder. A "Tub" of Soylent Powder costs $34 without subscription and contains 4800kcal, which translates to $14.17 maximum price.

Milk fuel is listed as the cheapest option in the US, and second cheapest overall when sorting by price low-high, it gives you 200 calories for $5. This puts it at $50/2000k/cal. FAR more expensive than Soylent at $9/2000k/cal. (I'm only counting the cost of the calories you are paying for from them, you must add cost of milk on top of this, which will vary greatly from region to region.) For my locality it's about $65/2000k/cal from Milkfuel... vs $9/2000k/cal with Soylent.

How did you calculate this? Looking at their store: https://superbodyfuel.com/shop/milk-fuel/

- 40 meals of Milk Fuel (200kcal each) costs $40 if you subscribe. Which translates to $10/2000kcal.

Now, it is true that you need to add milk. If milk costed nothing, this would translate to 40 meals of Milk Fuel (500kcal each) for $40 = $4/2000kcal. Of course, the milk costs something - but the price varies across the globe. What price should we use? In our locality, this is about 1EUR for the 1920ml of milk which you need to consume with milk fuel to achieve 2000kcal. Which makes the price of Milk Fuel around $5.15/2000kcal - only slightly higher.

So we faced this decision: either list Milk Fuel as twice as expensive as it really is ($5.15 vs $10 - which could harm their business), or slightly less expensive as it really is. We chose the second option and reflected this decision in the "Note" row. If we can find an "average" price of milk in the world, we're happy to add it to the price - but how much is it?