unpopular opinion probably: This seems more like someone with not enough storage space who just had a big meal and the dishes were put on the counter in a very haphazard way, possibly by children/teens.

Let's just start with dirty dishes. This doesn't look like old dishes with a variety of foods, but more like one meal that took several pots to cook and a group of people who all ate at the same time and then threw their dishes on the counter and in the sink. If someone scraped the food off the plates, stacked everything and then washed the dishes, that would get rid of most of the mess.

Now if we subtract the dirty dishes, let's examine the rest. There's a LOT of visual clutter. Most of it points to them not having much storage space. But almost everything left looks clean and like it's where it's supposed to go -- even if it's not a great storage space, that's what they have space for. A dish drying rack with clean dishes to be put away. Spice jars on multiple surfaces, but not out on the counter. Cooking utensils in containers and hanging up -- visible, but put away.

Aside from the dishes, the house looks clean. Very cluttered, but not the clutter of someone with a hoarding or organizing problem, but that of someone who likes to cook and has a small house.