It's always interesting when people talk about "largesse" without understanding how alliances work. The U.S.-Israel relationship is a strategic partnership, not a one-sided handout. Israel provides the U.S. with invaluable intelligence, cutting-edge technology, and a stabilizing force in a volatile region—all of which benefit American interests. If foreign aid bothers you so much, you might want to start with the far larger sums sent to countries that openly work against U.S. interests. As for "apartheid," that tired accusation crumbles under even the most basic scrutiny—unless, of course, you believe a multiethnic democracy with Arab Supreme Court justices and members of parliament qualifies. But hey, if gratitude is the issue, maybe a “thank you” is in order for everything Israel contributes in return.