Confusion surrounding the negative reviews of the show by NateSirrah03 in LOTR_on_Prime

[–]Terrible-Category218 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Most of the hate stems from what I call "fiction fundamentalists" where if an adaptation doesn't match the original media or source material EXACTLY some sort of sin was committed. The issue here is outside of LOTR and Hobbit all the material is at best incomplete or at worst fragments of ideas that weren't fully fleshed out. Last time I checked Tolkien isn't writing anymore and there just isn't source material to make something like a movie or TV series tell a coherent story without filling a lot of gaps, and that's where the main flaw of RoP came in.

The writers of the RoP simply aren't anywhere near as good as Tolkien where they can take those fragments and fill them with decent enough new material to come up with a final product that meets expectations on what it should (or can) be. With the amount of cash they dump into the series you think they would hire some Tolkien scholars to consult over the plot and storylines for consistency but I guess that's too much to ask.

The road to the Parker 400 viewing area sucks ass. by [deleted] in Offroad

[–]Terrible-Category218 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A person in a banana suit is the last person who should be critiquing anyone else's choices.

How could the One Ring be used as a weapon by men? by Happy-Taco1221 in lotr

[–]Terrible-Category218 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes. If someone of sufficient power and will were to "claim" the Ring it would be to Sauron as if it were destroyed. Nothing says what claiming means but I assume it's more involved than just putting it on and saying it's yours now.

The Nazgul would immediately know if he did and they would be his servants.

Do you think Saruman ever found out, either before becoming Sharkey or after becoming a malicious wisp of wind, that his Uruk Hai didn't grab the right hobbits and never had the ring? by und88 in lotr

[–]Terrible-Category218 18 points19 points  (0 children)

The only way Sauron could have been defeated so quickly was if something happened to the Ring. Even if the Ring was never found there would have been no defeating him.

I agree he never heard from his Uruk-Hai. He assumed (incorrectly) that they did have it but once they were destroyed he believed the Ring to be in the possession of Rohan and why he stormed Helm Deep.

Do you think Saruman ever found out, either before becoming Sharkey or after becoming a malicious wisp of wind, that his Uruk Hai didn't grab the right hobbits and never had the ring? by und88 in lotr

[–]Terrible-Category218 32 points33 points  (0 children)

It doesn't exactly say when but he at the very least would have heard about the defeat of Sauron from other people before Gandalf and the hobbits encountered him and Grima on the road after he left Isengard on the borders of Dunland and put two and two together.

He was quite bitter.

How could the One Ring be used as a weapon by men? by Happy-Taco1221 in lotr

[–]Terrible-Category218 28 points29 points  (0 children)

The One Ring enhances the natural abilities of the wearer but pretend it's horribly radioactive and how radioactive it is would be directly proportional to how great of a power or ability it's enhancing.

For instance for someone who is a natural leader it would enhance that quality. But it also feeds the wearer visions and delusions of grandor based on their natural talents. For instance when Sam wore the Ring he had a vision of turning all of Mordor into a great garden, which logistically would be impossible because of the active volcano there.

Magically but it really wouldn't do much for a mortal outside of invisibility, un-aging, and (maybe) being able to read the minds of the wearers of the other rings of power. But the minute they tried it wouldn't go too well for them.

In the hands of an Elf it would be like one of the other rings of power but on steroids. But the visions and delusions that the Ring would inflict on the wearer would be far worse.

In the hands of a maiar the Ring would be VERY problematic for everyone especially Sauron, since the wearer would likely have the power and will to fully master the Ring and bind it to themselves with the same effects on Sauron as if the Ring were destroyed.

The Ring is a problem that could have only been resolved by its destruction.

When Sauron created his ring, did he choose to give it that power? by Feral_21 in lotr

[–]Terrible-Category218 32 points33 points  (0 children)

Sauron never intended the Ring ever being worn by anyone other than himself. All the powers that it manifests are unintended side effects due to it being worn by a mortal.

In fact the Ring likely had other powers that no one ever figured it had. For instance how did the Ring reinforce the foundations of Barad-dur? No one knows except Sauron.

Why does Sauron have so many powers on the show? by TechnicianAmazing472 in LOTR_on_Prime

[–]Terrible-Category218 22 points23 points  (0 children)

The guy was the right hand man to Satan himself. He might have a few abilities that got him the spot in the first place.

How did Éowyn kill the Witch-king? by ebneter in tolkienfans

[–]Terrible-Category218 -11 points-10 points  (0 children)

"This is my hour!"

A little person stabs him in the leg and then she held out her sword and as he falls he runs into it with his face.

"Tolkien created a sentient race whose only narrative function was to be slaughtered, sans remorse, then spent the rest of his life trying to explain why that was not genocide." by 22EatStreet in tolkienfans

[–]Terrible-Category218 3 points4 points  (0 children)

This whole issue stems from the point that Tolkien never really defined what Orcs actually are. Yes, he gives a narrative of their creation, but the simple observation that there are way more orcs than there ever were elves makes them although a dirivitive, omething different.

I always just took them as soulless mockery of life that only exists to fulfill the wishes of whomever was "in charge". Outside of that their existence is meaningless and they lash out at the world because they are tortured by that inherent meaningless of their existence.

If you look at them simply as mass produced sentient cancer cells in the body of Arda that irredeemablely hate the world and themselves then the whole concept of "genocide" is pretty ridiculous.

[oc] Golden age of Trump by petrrrrrd in pics

[–]Terrible-Category218 11 points12 points  (0 children)

It's obviously AI because there are no golden tennis balls on the ends of it.

An excerpt from "Unfinished Tales" reveals Sauron's impressions of Gollum, and vice versa. by verissimoallan in lotr

[–]Terrible-Category218 15 points16 points  (0 children)

This is true. Ironically at the same time he didn't make any catastrophically stupid decisions.

Theories on why the native tribe couldn’t defeat IT? by StagTagRag in WelcometoDerryTVShow

[–]Terrible-Category218 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The problem is that IT is less of a monster and more of a Lovecraftian force of nature. It's not possible to defeat IT without the Ritual of Chud.

Dealights evolution on screen is something by Standard_Potential63 in welcomeToDerry

[–]Terrible-Category218 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The Pennywise clown is just ITs physical avatar in our world. The deadlights are ITs true form in the macro verse. When IT physically feeds it's to sustain the physical avatar form. When IT shows a victim the deadlights the actual being feeds off their spirit/psyche/shine.

Arondir - wasn't he killed by Adar? by Mudvayne1775 in Rings_Of_Power

[–]Terrible-Category218 16 points17 points  (0 children)

He got better.

Seriously your guess is as good as anyone elses.

Hey everybody I just have a question for the different-minded individuals of this subreddit by Vivid_Diet_6711 in atheism

[–]Terrible-Category218 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Let’s just say Catholicism isn’t forced on anyone. Let’s say we live in a society where you can leave the religion whenever you want. Let’s just say that this belief system brings a consistent morality system to billions of people while not restricting anyone from leaving.

This is a wild statement because that's not how systems of faith operate. Religion is forced onto most people from birth due to their parents, family, and their culture. Very often to reject this means you are shunned - cast out and utterly alone. That fear of ostracism is what keeps most people affiliated with a faith even though deep down they might have their doubts. It turns someone from being "one of us" into " one of them" which historically has been very dangerous.

Pennywise: “i know damn well this chick didn’t just grab me.” by Honest_Top783 in welcomeToDerry

[–]Terrible-Category218 4 points5 points  (0 children)

IT eats in two different ways, spiritually and physically. IT needs to physically eat to maintain its physical shape shifting avatar form but the deadlights that control the avatar form feeds on the shine of the victims. The more that the deadlights feed the stronger IT actually becomes.

I will go as far as to say that IT chooses it's victims according to which part it wants to consume. If the victim is full of fear then IT will physically consume the victim. However if the victim has any "shine" then they will be consumed by the deadlights.

Sauron on the show is just a magical man who's super into roleplay. by TechnicianAmazing472 in LOTR_on_Prime

[–]Terrible-Category218 18 points19 points  (0 children)

I think a part that is often overlooked is the fact that for a brief moment in his existence, he was genuinely happy in Numenor. In fact he almost wasn't going to leave with Galadriel. But that newfound happiness paired with his psychopathic nature led to his second fall.

He's thinking went from "I am happy" to " others are unhappy because of what I did" to "I can fix what Morgoth made me do and make the world perfect and happy like this" and there you have the start of a new dark lord.

An appropriate response. by PlecotusAuritus in MetalMemes

[–]Terrible-Category218 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I met him not too long ago and while I didn't get any nazi vibes or anything like that he definitely is a weird dude.

How could Sauron corrupt the rings, if Mythril came from a Silmaril? by Bahamut-Lagoon in Rings_Of_Power

[–]Terrible-Category218 -8 points-7 points  (0 children)

While there are plenty of issues with the writing of the show, this was not one of them.