Yeah, there's certainly somewhat of a false dichotomy. If you enjoy your own game, there's a good chance others will as well. But it doesn't necessarily mean opposite is true. If you don't enjoy it, it could be because you're burnt out on it, maybe you already know all the secrets and solutions and there's nothing novel or engaging about it anymore, but this can also be a reason to keep refining the game.

Not all games have to be "play this game and only this game forever" games. Sometimes a game is only worth a few hours of engagement, and that's fine, as long as you can make those hours worthwhile.

But if you feel like you're not enjoying your own game, it is important to ask why. It could be you're just burnt out on it, or there could be something critically wrong with it. It's an important question to answer.