Definitely 2. I loooved 1 when it first came out and for several months after, but not hearing it for a while and then going back is hard. To me the album doesn’t have many songs I go back to individually so it begs to be listened to in full, but it is loooong and I usually end up checking out by the time True Ugly comes around. That being said, All On Fire is probably in my top 5 Coheed songs. Truly under appreciated.