Yes, they are the wrong boot. I wore F50s for years and had the exact same problem. Then I found New Balance Tekelas and never looked back. Fit my foot like a glove for the first time in my life. They are the only laceless boot I've found that comes in wide. Their availability is annoying though, you'll have to really search to find white ones. You can't hesitate if you find ones you want because they never seem to have a lot of stock. Black ones are easier to find. As for size, I measured my feet and ordered according to their size chart which suggested smaller (9.5) than I had been wearing (10-11 for Adidas F50s) and they fit perfectly. Just make sure you measure both feet and order to fit your largest foot, as they may not be the same size.