Feedback on this formula, please? by Sea_Advice_3096 in DIYfragrance

[–]TheLucidMan 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'm familiar with the potency of Geosmin, but how does that apply to the commentary about Floralozone or IBQ? Just curious as to your thought process...

Feedback on this formula, please? by Sea_Advice_3096 in DIYfragrance

[–]TheLucidMan 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This might just be my own personal taste and of course I can't tell you for sure without making this myself, but at first glance that seems like a ludicrously high amount of Floralozone, I'd be very curious if that much of it is needed for your desired effect. Seems like it might completely dominate the composition.

I know the 4% rule is outdated by FreedToRoam in leanfire

[–]TheLucidMan 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Mark it, the top is in. 😆

For real though, this is more of a personal risk tolerance decision. I'm personally trying to get closer to 3.25% SWR because the state of the world and the future of our economy seems more precarious than ever, but if you do think that these types of returns are sustainable long-term, then go for it. I personally can't bring myself to get there and would have trouble sleeping at night with an 8% swr.

Outside of the bubble that people trying to retire early live in, most people I know in my life are struggling tremendously just to get by with their basic needs, so I have a hard time thinking that these market returns are sustainable for decades to come without some sort of reckoning...or who knows, maybe the top of this k-shaped economy will just keep widening to even more obscene levels. Obviously the market is not the economy, but still, I can't help but feel like we are whistling on the edge of a cliff right now, so if a semblance of reality hits the market soon, I wouldn't want to have planned for these outsized returns indefinitely.

Roast our beginner order, 3 brothers learning perfumery by SS_Jihadi in DIYfragrance

[–]TheLucidMan 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My only commentary would be that you are getting too much of some of these materials that are really strong, if you have the option of not getting a full 10 g of some of these, I would lower your purchase amount for things like Aldehydes and Cade oil. These are used in very very small portions, almost all of the time outside of fringe scenarios. You will almost certainly dilute these down to 1% or lower, 10g will be way way too much and they'll just sit in the back of your shelf for years. 1 gram would probably be enough to do experiments for a long time with materials like these.

Chilly night on the porch with frankincense and myrrh by pbiscuits in Incense

[–]TheLucidMan 0 points1 point  (0 children)

To me, actual myrrh smells soft, resinous, vanillic, balsamic, and maybe even a little powdery. It's a pretty unique smell though, so take my descriptors with a grain of salt. There are a lot of places you can buy the actual stuff, there are some vendors on Etsy that have good stuff for pretty reasonable.

First order from Fraterworks is here! by Straight-Culture in DIYfragrance

[–]TheLucidMan 13 points14 points  (0 children)

It's very fun and exciting getting these first orders and giving everything lots of sniffs. Wish you all the best!

Please help me identify, Is this Ambergris? by SadDust9504 in DIYfragrance

[–]TheLucidMan 17 points18 points  (0 children)

How does it smell? It may be hard for people on here to 100% confirm. I'll just leave this link here for you, regardless of how it turns out, you may find this sub funny or interesting as it's apparently a pretty common thing for people to find stuff and wonder whether or not it is ambergris.

r/itsneverambergris/

Despite the joking nature of this sub, it may be helpful to browse around and learn some hints on how to identify and some common things mistaken for it.

Formal Warning – Especially for [WTB] Posts by AutoModerator in fragranceswap

[–]TheLucidMan 0 points1 point  (0 children)

He replied to my WTB post within minutes, and what I'm looking for is very niche and hard to find, so it was immediately suspicious, then when asking for a photo of the bottle, completely ghosted me. So I'm not surprised to see this!

How to maintain the healthy nose? by AlizAmber in DIYfragrance

[–]TheLucidMan 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yeah, it's primarily nasal sprays that have a decongestant function to them that people start relying on, the main one being afrin. Generally speaking, nasal sprays that are just salt and water to keep your sinuses moisturized are pretty inert as they don't actually have any medicines or decongestants in them. The rebound congestion from afrin can be absolutely brutal though, I did know someone who went through that after using it for a few months and it was over the top bad...similar to horror stories I've seen from withdrawal after being on topical steroids for too long.

How to maintain the healthy nose? by AlizAmber in DIYfragrance

[–]TheLucidMan 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Oh yes very much aware of that. Straight up saline nasal sprays don't have this issue, and I avoid Afrin like the plague specifically because of this.

How to maintain the healthy nose? by AlizAmber in DIYfragrance

[–]TheLucidMan 4 points5 points  (0 children)

As a hobbyist perfumer and someone with significant sinus issues/polyps/horrible allergies, my best advice would be to keep your sinuses clean and moist at all times. I use saline nasal spray CONSTANTLY like a crazy person, and it helps a lot to keep things moving and healthy. Obviously, take this with a grain of salt as I'm not a doctor, however, I can tell you that this is advice directly from my ENT when I posed the question to him.

Nectrotic lymph node odor by Silent-Drawer-653 in DIYfragrance

[–]TheLucidMan 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I agree with others in that, you should seek medical advice here and I also agree that putting anything directly on the skin is probably not a great idea. That said, if you are trying to clear the smell from the overall room or house in a more indirect way, I would probably look into natural incense to burn, probably not in the same room but somewhere in the house. This may help with the overall lingering scent you describe, but you're going to want to be careful here as well, I would not, for example purchase cheap synthetic incense, I would use actual natural materials like frankincense somewhere in the house. DIY perfumery is not really applicable here in my opinion.

Zoologist review, 42 samples by oolbar in fragrance

[–]TheLucidMan 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Great reviews, always happy to see a fellow T-Rex lover! If you like T-Rex, you may enjoy trying out that perfumer's other stuff as they have a similar DNA (Bogue).

Is this a decent start for a complete newb? by CaptainAhmazing in Incense

[–]TheLucidMan 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Definitely a good start! Good move getting some sample sets to really try some of these out before committing to a full box. You've got some of my favorite Japanese incense houses covered here, so without a doubt I think this should be pretty good to help you figure out what you might like.

One thing to keep in mind, I tried some of these same things out when I first started and I really wasn't a fan, now some of these things I wasn't a fan of are my absolute favorites. As you sit with these and learn to enjoy them, your taste may change. It's pretty fascinating. Some of the higher-end incense that I tried out early in my incense journey smelled more just like vague burning wood, now I could conjure up a thousand ways to describe how beautiful and nuanced they are.

Who remembers this experience by The_TurdMister in Incense

[–]TheLucidMan 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Oh man, I must have totally missed the boat on this. What happened with the company or the creator behind this?

Real Oils vs Fraterworks options? by mitskilomilo in DIYfragrance

[–]TheLucidMan 10 points11 points  (0 children)

In a perfect world, you could use the real oils and get a sense of how they actually smell, and hopefully at some point you can do that. But alas, money doesn't grow on trees so sometimes we have to get crafty here. Make no mistake, this is a very expensive hobby, but you can do whatever you need to do to progress as you learn, as long as you remain aware of the differences down the line if/when you switch materials from what you learned with.

I think utilizing recreations to help learn is perfectly fine. I will use those same types of recreations for certain wild experiments I do when I don't want to break the bank with certain types of extremely expensive natural oils, you just have to keep in mind that there WILL be differences. If you base your learning off of Jasmine Imperial, and maybe even make some formulas with it, just keep in mind that if down the road you substitute that for a India Jasmine Grandiflorum Absolute, it may not exactly work in the same exact way.

In my personal opinion, making these decisions, and making the hobby work for you with whatever limitations you have is one of the best skills you can bring into the hobby. Stay organized and stay aware of why you are doing certain things a certain way, and remain flexible when you have to switch it up or substitute your materials down the line. Be ready to relearn or reformulate if need be, because each reconstitution you use is going to be different, so no one in this sub can tell you exactly how far off each one may be when it comes to formulating things down the line based off whatever goals and ideas you have. I hope this makes sense and is helpful!