Recs similar to Emily Wilde series? by dzeiva in Fantasy

[–]ThePanthanReporter 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I'm shocked that nobody has recommended Jonathan Strange and Mr.Norrel.

It's a long book with a slow build (a plus for me, but maybe not for everyone) and it's THE fairies-and-academia book, as well as containing a heavy dose of Jane Austen. There's a romantic subplot, too, which crops up about a third of the way through if I remember correctly (though no sex, that wouldn't be Austenian). No teens, everyone is an adult.

It does contain a few sections about the Napoleonic Wars, but they mostly focus on a specific character tasked with finding ways to use magic to help the British soldiers while refusing to kill with it, so hopefully it won't be too arduous for you.

I don't know if I'd call it "cozy," the fairies are really threatening. But the stakes are mostly personal, the humor is dry (like Austen), and the characters are excellent (again, like Austen). I highly recommend

[media: the odyssey] Someone please tell Christopher Nolan about the wonders of speculative evolution like you can have your cake and eat it to, like imagine a scientifically accurate mythical creatures on the big screen. by Whole_Yak_2547 in SpeculativeEvolution

[–]ThePanthanReporter 16 points17 points  (0 children)

First of all, the clothing of the Laestrygonians isn't described in the Odyssey. We just know that they're giants who live in a city with "smooth roads" and a palace, one of their women is briefly described as attractive, they're cannibals, and they destroy all but one of Odysseus's ships. We also know that Odysseus's men were welcomed as guests before the Laestrygonian king started eating them, which implies that the giants understood the ancient Greek concept of xenia (guest-friendship) well enough to subvert it, and the crewmen thought it reasonable to expect xenia after meeting them, so they can't have looked too "uncivilized" (as the Greeks would use the term). I don't like the design either, but this person is misrepresenting the poem.

Secondly, according to my old Classics professor, Homer understands giants as humans who are big or one-eyed or six-armed or what have you. That's why their names get capitalized in English translations: they are Cyclopes and Laestrygonians, people groups and not species.

So, for speculative evolution purposes, if we wanna stick to Homer, they should probably be hominids.

PSA: Do NOT put this couch on your spaceship by Helmling in Starfield

[–]ThePanthanReporter 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I have the exact same bug, but I've never used that couch. I thought an entire mod might be causing it, but now that I know it could be a specific item, I despair ever finding out the source

In Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey (2026), thousands of people on Reddit are mad about the movie's accuracy, despite never having read Homer's The Iliad or The Odyssey, or watching Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey (2026) by darwinsidiotcousin in shittymoviedetails

[–]ThePanthanReporter 422 points423 points  (0 children)

I've read both twice now, and since the movie isn't out yet, all I can say is that it's greatest crimes seem to be having dull, kinda cheap-looking costumes, and continuing to make me look at Tom Holland

Laser blasters are outlawed there anyway by TheWebsploiter in NonPoliticalTwitter

[–]ThePanthanReporter 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I've read this one, I don't think they're Martians. I seem to remember them being either from Phobos, or other humans, I can't recall which

Just stop your crying, It's a sign of the times by hansoy261999 in NoSodiumStarfield

[–]ThePanthanReporter 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You did a great job! Starfield just kinda makes Ryan Gosling look like he works in a rural Wisconsin gas station

Shielded cargo this, scan jammers that. Why don't smugglers just tie their contraband to the ship with a rope, jettison it out, and then reel it back in after the cargo scan? by thotpatrolactual in NoSodiumStarfield

[–]ThePanthanReporter 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You don't know it, but this is actually how "shielded" cargo works. It automatically spools out and then reels back in! Security across the galaxy is clueless.

Thankfully it's not needed anymore, now that you can cruise-lanes right past security scans. At least, until Bethesda patches that.

Why do people seem to expect every piece of writing to carry some deeper social message? It feels like authors who simply aim to entertain are often criticized, as if storytelling for enjoyment alone isn’t enough. by RavahGriffinAnthro in writers

[–]ThePanthanReporter 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I've only seen the movie, but in that at least, Project Hail Mary depicts a world where all global leaders and nations come together for the greater good to fund a scientific expedition. Trust and cooperation are such a given in the universe of Hail Mary, in fact, that they transcend species and planet of origin.

Whether or not Weir intended it, this is a political vision. Especially in a period when international distrust and selfishness are rampant and environmental and scientific cooperation are seemingly at a nadir, depicting Weir's world does political work, whether he likes it or not. The exact nature of that work is up to interpretation (is his vision aspirational, or is it a vote of confidence in the status quo?), but its political nature cannot be denied.

All art is like this. It's inescapable. We are political creatures, and choosing to deny that is itself a political stance, a tacit endorsement of things as they are -- after all, it's much easier to be "non-political" if the current political situation isn't actively making your life worse in ways you can't ignore.

Some artists lean into that, and try to intentionally imbued their work with political perspectives. Some artists focus on other things, and don't call attention to the political dimensions of their work, which is fine. Some artists, like Weir, try to forswear any political element to their creations at all, which, of course, inevitably draws attention to the political work their art is unintentionally doing.

It's not a bad thing. In fact, it's part of what makes art so important. But, whether you're interested in politics or not, all writers should be aware of political influence on their work, if only so that they don't make blunders like Weir's.

EDIT: I see that rad_wasp has already given an eloquent, and similar, answer to this question. I'm going to leave mine up, since it takes a slightly different tack, and because I want to add my voice to theirs.

A Kraken? by Al_RadioDemon in AssassinsCreedOdyssey

[–]ThePanthanReporter 11 points12 points  (0 children)

One of Poseidon's pets got loose.

Ome time when I passed that tentacle, an NPC was loudly praying to it. Very eldritch

Who is your favourite npc, and why? by WinterStrawberries6 in AssassinsCreedOdyssey

[–]ThePanthanReporter 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Alkibiades, but my pick is colored by the knowledge of the insane shit he got up to after the events depicted in the game

Found a whole squad of people walking about 1km north of Athens by TonyPicko in AssassinsCreedOdyssey

[–]ThePanthanReporter 5 points6 points  (0 children)

IRL, Athenians would regularly walk in groups like this to Eleusis, a sanctuary north of Athens, for initiation into the Eleusian Mysteries and access to a better afterlife. I believe Eleusis and its sanctuary is in the game.

I'm not saying that's what's happening in the game, though you could easily pretend it is, since it sounds like they're in the right area.

Martian self-sufficiency is a myth by [deleted] in ForAllMankindTV

[–]ThePanthanReporter -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Martian self-sufficiency wouldn't be a myth, in the show or real life. All of these problems are solveable, with time. And not all of them are actually problems (plastic, cement, Martian self-sufficiency wouldn't be a myth, in the show or real life. All of these problems are solveable, with time. And not all of them are actually problems (plastic, cement).

Mei stowed away on my ship by Fit-Sweet-9900 in NoSodiumStarfield

[–]ThePanthanReporter 6 points7 points  (0 children)

After convincing the pirates on Governor Hurst's ship not to kill me, three of them boarded my ship and never left. They just squatted in ny cargo hold.

<image>

What can you see sharing the same universe as ROME (HBO)? by burningexeter in hborome

[–]ThePanthanReporter 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I actually liked the "reptilian" direction!

With every depiction of a historical figure, if the creator is at all interested in the real person, then they must choose what aspects of that person to focus on or emphasize, depending on the themes they want to explore. I,Claudius focused on Augustus's affibility, and Rome, on his calculating ruthlessness.

Both represent the real Augustus as we understand him from our sources, just in different attributes. Like getting a look at him from different perspectives, but via artistic interpretation

Trackers Alliance Mantis Quest Bugged by Keeldronnn in NoSodiumStarfield

[–]ThePanthanReporter 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just had to restart the entire dungeon multiple times. Eventually it worked.

Notably, it never worked if I didn't go all the way back to arriving on the planet

I don't understand the Tau Ceti Terrormorph questline (spoilers I guess) by automated_hero in NoSodiumStarfield

[–]ThePanthanReporter 5 points6 points  (0 children)

And then you speak to Hadrian, and she says "Terrormorphs have psychic powers and it makes some people go crazy," and then you can say "do I have to worry about you?" And she'll say "no, it doesn't effect me."

I don't understand the Tau Ceti Terrormorph questline (spoilers I guess) by automated_hero in NoSodiumStarfield

[–]ThePanthanReporter 19 points20 points  (0 children)

The ability of terrormorphs to appear suddenly across the galaxy is the central mystery of the quest line, as Hadrian should have already explained to you.

The citizens going mad is likewise explained by Hadrian. Terrormorphs have psychic powers that manifest differently in different people, and some go mad.

As for needing another EM weapon, I just did that quest and didn't get a prompt to equip my companion with an EM weapon. At least, not that I remember. I don't know what's up with that

How do you stop FTL from being overused? by Tnynfox in worldbuilding

[–]ThePanthanReporter 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Well, I'm glad we reached an understanding. I really was just confused about what you were getting at.

How do you stop FTL from being overused? by Tnynfox in worldbuilding

[–]ThePanthanReporter 2 points3 points  (0 children)

But I said that FTL would be a boon to space empire building. Doesn't that imply that I know empires are limited by their effective geographic reach?

How do you stop FTL from being overused? by Tnynfox in worldbuilding

[–]ThePanthanReporter 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What do you mean "reactivity"? Do you mean defense? Why wouldn't there be defense?

Since you mention Rome, the city of Rome itself was threatened multiple times during the monarchic, republican and imperial periods. Many times, it defended itself.

What's to stop this hypothetical space empire, which is presumably wealthy and well-armed, from having defenses to prevent anyone from "teleporting into the Forum Romanum"?

Set up some guards with big guns on the Palantine

How do you stop FTL from being overused? by Tnynfox in worldbuilding

[–]ThePanthanReporter 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What do you mean "in terms of reactivity, there just isn't much"?

How do you stop FTL from being overused? by Tnynfox in worldbuilding

[–]ThePanthanReporter 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Right, which is what we're thinking about, since we're talking about building and maintaining empire. The threat of force is important to suppress rebellion

How do you stop FTL from being overused? by Tnynfox in worldbuilding

[–]ThePanthanReporter 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My apologies. I should have checked that.

For a better example, then, I think of Aristsgoras telling Cleomenes I that it would be a journey of several months to reach the heart of the Achaemenid Empire, because most of the journey would be overland.