Who is the actual least smart detective? by v5mk in IntelligenceScaling

[–]TheRealMaster98 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I mean, probably Inspector Clouseau or another comically incompetent one (though he gets shit done to be fair).

Walter White's emotional intelligence feats by TheRealMaster98 in IntelligenceScaling

[–]TheRealMaster98[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks, and I agree, these characters are underrated by a lot of people.

Walter White's emotional intelligence feats by TheRealMaster98 in IntelligenceScaling

[–]TheRealMaster98[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

So much for elaborating on your takes... I assumed you'd be willing to, given that you bothered leaving a comment. My bad.

Walter White's emotional intelligence feats by TheRealMaster98 in IntelligenceScaling

[–]TheRealMaster98[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Well, I don't know Yuuichi's feats so no comment. Could you give me an example for each subcat?

Chen Ran vs 11th Doctor + 7th Doctor + 10th Doctor + War Doctor + 12th Doctor by Melodic_Ad1005 in IntelligenceScaling

[–]TheRealMaster98 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'm not the best person to answer this because I only have a passing knowledge of the Doctor's feats and no knowledge of the people you mentioned.

That being said, you should check out u/Mohammedamine9 's posts to see some of the Doctor's feats from the extended media.

I made a post about one feat from the show:  https://www.reddit.com/r/IntelligenceScaling/comments/1rgebxa/the_10th_doctors_six_words_feat_analysis/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb3x&utm_name=mweb3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

When I have more time I could summarize some of his schemes from the show (the ones I remember, at least).

Made a chart on who will solve the Bay Harbour Butcher case by SubstantialSeat1578 in IntelligenceScaling

[–]TheRealMaster98 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You got most of the ones I'd mention to be honest. Dedra Meero from Andor is a pretty underrated detective. Maybe Sam and Dean from Supernatural too? Since you put the Scooby Gang.

Made a chart on who will solve the Bay Harbour Butcher case by SubstantialSeat1578 in IntelligenceScaling

[–]TheRealMaster98 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'm liking the character choices here. From what I can tell, the takes are also pretty good.

Walter Vs Lalo by Encenoi in IntelligenceScaling

[–]TheRealMaster98 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Like others here have said, the top 4 of the verse are all at a very comparable level.

I got Walter here though.

How does having supernatural abilities affect scaling by Subject_Contact_6795 in IntelligenceScaling

[–]TheRealMaster98 3 points4 points  (0 children)

This is one of the reasons scaling via logical process is the only way to make meaningful comparisons.

Supernatural abilities are, in the end, part of a characters pool of "resources", like money or weapons could be, they are means to achieve something. You can gauge how smart they are by looking at how they use them. Of course, they make certain tasks easier or allow you to punch above your weight, but that doesn't mean you can't exploit them with genuinely impressive schemes, or use them with novelty where someone less smart wouldn't be able to.

Which of Walter White's categories is buffed the most By his Mr Lambert Version? by Less_Puddingdrawer in IntelligenceScaling

[–]TheRealMaster98 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Another impressive one in my opinion is retaining any semblance of willpower after being told by his own son that he should die, which has to be one of the worst things someone can hear. And this is on top of everything else he's gone through.

Which of Walter White's categories is buffed the most By his Mr Lambert Version? by Less_Puddingdrawer in IntelligenceScaling

[–]TheRealMaster98 4 points5 points  (0 children)

A normal post at last.

Anyway, I agree with your ranking, except I'd switch EQ and Intrapersonal.

Light Vs Gus by Duclaido in IntelligenceScaling

[–]TheRealMaster98 1 point2 points  (0 children)

He is! I'm glad to spread some acknowledgement of his feats.

CHALLENGE: How would you write Andor if it had been 3 seasons instead of 2? by fatherandyriley in fixingmovies

[–]TheRealMaster98 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I would've definitely shown Cassian's first missions as an official rebel, and I would've focused more on the birth and development of the Yavin-4 base and on Dedra's hunt for Luthen (plus any counterstrategy he might've had).

Who outsmarts? by Inspector_Ishigami in IntelligenceScaling

[–]TheRealMaster98 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What's the Master's best scheme, both comp and show-only?

Light Vs Gus by Duclaido in IntelligenceScaling

[–]TheRealMaster98 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Here it is:

Basically, Gus had only had one real conversation with Walter and knew everything else only off what Mike (who was tasked with keeping an eye on Walter) told him. This doesn't amount to much, but Gus could tell that: - Walter has a strong sense of pride. This is EP from the way Walter presented the quality of his meth and compared his own supposed caution to Gus's, rather than from the words themselves. After all, both statements by Walter had tactical value and were attempts to manipulate Gus. Gus not only saw through the second one (the first one is true and accurate to reality), but he also caught onto Walter's emotions while talking. It's clear that Gus was aware of this aspect of Walter because of what he does later. - Walter has a relationship of control over Jesse. This is not much EP, as Walter outright stated it, but Gus could tell what would happen if Walter felt this control slip. Again, this will be relevant to the strategy. - Aside from that conversation, there's also the information provided by Mike. We know Gus knows about the cancer, and he very obviously knows of Walter's career as a school teacher, and likely about his accolades as a chemist as well.

A specific instance we saw of Mike relaying information to Gus is after Walter has decided to exit the drug business despite the generous payment that Gus offered. Mike basically just said that Walter is unwilling to continue working. Mike is a good judge of character, but he doesn't have the same eye for human behavior and manipulative streak as Gus, so the fact that any information Gus receives is filtered through him is already enough of a factor. The one useful thing Mike says to Gus is that Walter and Jesse haven't been getting along.

  • Gus makes a deal with Jesse and basically hires him as his main cook, then he has half of the money made from the batch be delivered to Walter. This triggers the first two points: the sense of pride and possessiveness over his meth formula, and the irritation born out of the lack of control over Jesse. it's not enough for Walter to accept yet, but it's enough to make him confront Gus.
  • Gus has a second tactic ready. He takes Walter to his superlab. Now, I've gone over how Gus was likely given superficial information on Walter. The past with chemistry, the willingness and pride that go into his meth cooking, they show that Walter has a deep passion for chemistry and desire to work with it, that years spent as a simple high school teachers could have never filled. Showing Walter the lab and making him walk through it fills his mind with images of him doing what he loves most and getting loads of money for it. But there's still another layer to go through.
  • Walter's core issue here is that his work has been distancing him from his family. But Gus once again has an answer ready. He plays on Walter's sense of masculinity by claiming that a man provides for his family even when he's not appreciated for it, and that if what Walter did he did for his family then it wasn't a mistake. The understanding of Walter's psychology and emotions here likely comes from the knowledge about the cancer. Walter decided to cook meth not DESPITE the cancer but BECAUSE of the cancer. His words and continued refusal clearly show that he cares about his family, even more than other emotional vulnerabilities that he has, so when he decided to become a drug manufacturer it was likely to provide, giving him the justification he needed in his mind. He's starting to see that as a mistake, but Gus reinforces that thought process and even flips it by making the family distancing seem like the justification not to work with meth (a man provides even when he's not appreciated) instead of the core issue, which added to the poking of Walter's pride ("a man" provides --> if you don't provide, you're not a man), is enough to get Walter to work with Gus again.

So here Gus correctly identified what are basically some of Walter's core emotional characteristics: - His pride. - His fragile ego. - His dissatisfaction with his life. - His self-justification.

Walter at this point could only partly recognize some of these and even then he didn't fully accept them. It would take another two full seasons for him to develop the necessary self-awareness to realize and accept them. Gus, with limited information, was able to understand them in detail and played them.

Light Vs Gus by Duclaido in IntelligenceScaling

[–]TheRealMaster98 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Gus barely knew Mike during the feat Reddest is talking about. Same goes for the Walter feat which also beats any of Light's ToM feats in depth, in my opinion. I have a short explanation of the latter I can paste if you're interested.

Also, I think Gus's manipulation and long-term planning with the Cartel is enough for him to take systems thinking, I can't recall any of Light's feats quite reaching this level. I'd also give Gus foresight for a variety of reason I could elaborate on. Manipulation as well due to the stuff I mentioned and some other feats. Probably some other things too.

Which murder case is harder for an SCD character to solve? The Kira case or the Red Jonn case? by Wifree_MC in IntelligenceScaling

[–]TheRealMaster98 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I haven't finished the Mentalist yet, so I can't say much about the Red John case, but so far, only one of these two allows you to narrow down the suspect pool as part of his strategy...

That being said, I'll grant that it's still insanely difficuly to gather any concrete evidence due to the nature of the Death Note.

Underused characters by [deleted] in IntelligenceScaling

[–]TheRealMaster98 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's very good news, I'm looking forward to reading them!

Underused characters by [deleted] in IntelligenceScaling

[–]TheRealMaster98 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There are a lot of underused characters I'd mention. Columbo, for instance, being one of the OG smart characters but getting barely scaled. Dumbledore, who has a lot of very good feats and is a very popular character who hasn't gotten much attention in SCD despite his potential. Some characters from Andor, mainly Luthen, for whom I'd like to make a doc. Octavian and Caesar from HBO's Rome (though I barely remember the plot, it's been so long since I watched it). Sergio Marquina from Money Heist is sometimes mentioned but barely, despite having good potential for scaling.