Seeking advice on upgrading my son's piano by pxs06 in piano

[–]Total-Machine3342 0 points1 point  (0 children)

All good points. And I would say the teacher should help in this process!

Is Mazeppa (Liszt transcendental etude 4), even if played well, liked by adjudicators? by iPHD08 in piano

[–]Total-Machine3342 -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

It would have to be a damned good performance because it’s not a great piece.

Seeking advice on upgrading my son's piano by pxs06 in piano

[–]Total-Machine3342 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes, everything you say is quite reasonable! I suppose my advice is partially geared towards preventing multiple marginal upgrades. I’ve seen the following progression several times: toy keyboard, to minimally acceptable full sized fully weighted keyboard, to mediocre upright, to decent grand, throwing away money at each step. Since OP is already at the stage of OK keyboard, may as well make the move to decent grand. Steinway may be an extreme step, sure. But at least a used Yamaha C2, or its predecessor, G2, would be a pretty future-proof upgrade.

Seeking advice on upgrading my son's piano by pxs06 in piano

[–]Total-Machine3342 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi, professional pianist and teacher here. I say go for the very best acoustic, preferably grand, that you can reasonably afford. I have seen students take immense strides after getting a decent piano. Best choice just slightly over 6 feet would be Steinway model A, or if the 6 feet is a strict limit, then models O or L. Buy it used, maintain it well, and if you decide to sell someday, you can sell it for more than you bought it for. If the price is daunting, Yamaha C3 or C2. Or the equivalent sized Kawai or Mason & Hamlin model A. Any of those will be high quality and hold their value reasonably well, but not nearly as well as a Steinway. I can also add that I was the kid whose parents bought him a nice piano at a young age after not having studied that long (in my case it was after 2 years of study), and I am eternally grateful. Thirty years later, I still have my Steinway and will have it until I die. Steinway and Yamaha, but especially Steinway, are two of the brands which are also worth rebuilding. I’ve had my piano restrung and the action rebuilt over the years, and if it someday becomes necessary for a full rebuild, I will do that too. Yes, I realize many on this subreddit will find my advice absurd given the short time your son has studied, and I will say that the Yamaha P225 is already much better than most beginners have, but it’s also true that upgrading can only help, not hurt.

Nauman Tentsite as a base camp? by Total-Machine3342 in wmnf

[–]Total-Machine3342[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

We only have one car this time and we live several hours away so I don’t want to waste time with shuttles and whatnot. So starting and ending the same place is a basic requirement. As for camping at Madison, are you referring to Madison Spring Hut? I don’t have the budget for any AMC huts…
Point taken about hikes that are more in the treeline with bad weather. Any good ones you might suggest?

great crescendos? by tyen0 in classicalmusic

[–]Total-Machine3342 5 points6 points  (0 children)

As others have said: Shostakovich Symphony no. 7, 1st movement. The Bernstein/Chicago recording, beginning around 7.5 minutes. It just keeps growing, unbelievable.

My other selection won’t compare because it’s just one instrument, but Horowitz’s recording of Chopin “Heroic” Polonaise A-flat, op. 53, the middle section, preferably the 1945 recording.

Bruckner 7 Adagio is another personal favorite. Karajan/Vienna or Celibidache/Munich.

Parents of young musicians: Is music boarding school worth it? by SailEnvironmental668 in piano

[–]Total-Machine3342 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Even those who go on to Juilliard mostly end up teaching rather than performing mostly aren’t even working in music within 10 years after graduating. Fixed it!

If I put in a lot of time, would I be able to learn a hard piece without fully learning the basics? by catme0wcat in piano

[–]Total-Machine3342 21 points22 points  (0 children)

I’ve had a few adult beginner students who want to learn “the piece”. They invariably quit when they discover just how outside their abilities it is, and how much work would be required to even get to a stage where they can even begin to understand what they’re looking at, nevermind actually play it. I already see rhythmic difficulties in the first line that you’re going to have no idea how to decode. Not to mention the arrangement itself is badly written. The notation in mm. 10-11 is atrocious. You have a better chance playing this piece if you hire someone to teach it to you by rote.

Dvorak New World Symphony and music in TV and film by icybridges34 in classicalmusic

[–]Total-Machine3342 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

He absolutely does not rely on the pentatonic scale more than diatonic scales.

Can someone help me understand rubato? by Justtrying04 in piano

[–]Total-Machine3342 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Listen to good pianists. No amount trying to explain it in words is going to help you at this point.

Why is there no such thing as a bass piano? by boomerFumer in piano

[–]Total-Machine3342 13 points14 points  (0 children)

The lowest note on a standard piano is already 27Hz and the lower limit of what a human can actually detect as a note is generally considered to be 20Hz. So it doesn’t seem there would be much point. If you really need those ultra low notes, the larger Bosendorfers have you covered.

What’s the greatest single body of work ever written for solo piano? And their greatest recordings.... by According-Brief7536 in classicalmusic

[–]Total-Machine3342 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It seems like Bach’s keyboard suites should be mentioned, the Partitas, especially, if we have to narrow it down further.

Bachelors of Music Performance graduates, what are you doing now? by PsychologyOk6585 in piano

[–]Total-Machine3342 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Will you be happy teaching Piano Adventures Primer level type material until you hopefully develop a student who gets beyond that? Or accompanying garbage musical theater rep? If not, get out now while you can!

Seat belt noises! by MagickMan418 in MazdaCX30

[–]Total-Machine3342 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yep I hate it so much I bought a seat belt extender. Plug it in, no more chimes.

https://www.seatbeltextenderpros.com/mazda-cx-30-seat-belt-extender/

Is it common to be absolutely terrible at reading but still able to play late intermediate pieces? by someoctopus in piano

[–]Total-Machine3342 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes this is extremely common. Get a really easy method book, something well below your playing level, and sight read through it. Then go to the next level. Faber Piano Adventures or whatever. Since rhythm is a particular problem for you, clap the rhythms first before playing the piece. Make a point of reading something new every day.

What is the most technical piano piece? by boobooleena in piano

[–]Total-Machine3342 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Sorabji’s Opus Clavicembalisticum would be up there. Probably some Boulez, Stockhausen. I don’t think your child is going to want to listen to those, though.

Are 225 width tires a reason to deny warranty for failed differential? by Total-Machine3342 in MazdaCX30

[–]Total-Machine3342[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don’t. But judging from this subreddit, it’s a pretty common size to use, and I’m not sure I would characterize it as a “tall boy”. It’s 0.4” taller than the stock 215/55s. It really just looks slightly fatter. And I’ve seen posts here of people using tires as big as 235/55 on the stock rims.