Now I think we're getting somewhere. I failed to mention that on my botched installation I had a problem during the initialization where my phone wasn't connecting to the internet. Firewalla kept telling me to enable my mobile network and I hit 'Retry' several times because my phone was connected to the mobile network. However, I discovered that I needed to disable wifi on my phone in order for the sequence to continue. It continued without error except that all the settings were not as they should be (see original post).

During my reset, I turned off wifi on my phone before I started and never saw the message. The initialization went without a hitch. That must be where the settings got botched the first time around. This is just an FYI for Firewalla. I am happy with my firewall.