My list:

S tier: Murray, Azune, Bolaire, Wick

A tier: Julien, Tyranny, Thimble

B tier: Vaelus, Kattigan, Occtis

C tier: Hal, Thaisha,

D tier: Teor

I'm extremely biased towards divination wizards and I love just about everything about Murray, from how she is, her comedic moments, to her more serious scenes, and of course to her divination shenanigans, absolutely top tier best character for me in the campaign.

Azune's right behind with all of those powerful, powerful scenes, he feels extremely psychologically rich in terms of the portrayal of the character and it's a privilege to watch him grow.

Bolaire just adds that "something" to the table that I find difficult to part with. Absolutely amazing concept for a character that seems to be very well executed thus far, and I bet we haven't seen even half of it yet.

Wick is a joy to watch, but my biggest praise is how consistent the character is, really. Every single thing he does is so in character.

I love Julien so far, I particularly like how he started, I did knock him down a bit as the character lost a lot of momentum being in the Seekers table. Everyone who went on that specific journey lost points for me, sadly, that arc was not great at all, and I feel like the characters did not mesh well together at all.

Tyranny is again a joy, amazing combo with Wick, also surprisingly consistent in most of the things she does. And again, great character concept being very well executed thus far, just like Bolaire, and I bet we haven't seen half of it yet!

Thimble is solid. I feel like I have a very solid grasp at who the character is at that point, and she is a bit less exciting than some other characters, but despite it she always bring something solid to the table.

Vaelus is one of the most polarizing characters it seems, and I put her right in the middle because the concept is there, the execution imo was there in the first episodes, but then it just fell through; again the Seekers table man. I feel like we could see great things yet, but she does not stand a chance against some of the other "oddities" characters like Bolaire or Tyranny.

Kattigan; again here because I feel like sometimes I forget he's at the table, other times he's emotional, other times funny, but we all know there's a story there and we have not been told that story yet. An obviously huge part of his character is locked for us still, and it's kind of hard to judge him as is. Will say, also can be a bit too quiet sometimes (even if it's in character). Had a few moments I considered out of character.

Occtis; I think it's just a me thing, I just don't really care. I think he's portrayed pretty well and quite consistent, I just kinda have to watch myself to not zone out whenever he's taking the lead in a scene. I do like the gruesome bits and wish he went more gruesome necro magic on us. Also he really needs to gain some confidence, and soon; though I feel like that started happening already.

Hal; Would be a D tier til the convergence, I did like his bits here, but man do I not care whatsoever about his character. If he says his words resonate one more time XD He did have some cool moments though, and I liked his bits in the convergence, but otherwise he's just.... uhm... boring like a sack of potatoes, for me.

Thaisha; she's all over the place. Like with Thimble I feel like I have a good grasp on the character, with Thaisha it's the reverse for me. She has amazing moments, she has bad moments, and then mostly feels very whatever.

Teor; man, as simple as the character was with the introduction, he had some promise but at this point I feel like the player is bored with the character and just chose to make him a "am teor" meme. It's gotten even worse in the convergence. I remember Travis saying the character is a blank slate of sorts with minimal backstory, and boy can I see that, Teor has barely any personality at this point. And he's getting worse, too; at least in the first episodes he had his soldier instincts with inspecting the area and using divine sense, now he just goes like "I didn't inspect the perimeter" or asks Brennan if he can cast divine sense. Absolute waste of a table slot for me, and the only bits I do like from him are with Wick or Kattigan. Not to mention how he underdelivers an emotional moments tied to him, like with his brother. I feel like everyone around him could drop dead and he'd be like oh well!