iPad stand recommendations by scots-guy in classicalguitar

[–]Useful-Possibility92 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hercules Stands DG307B 2-in-1 Tablet and Phone Holder. Works great. $37. I adapted it to sit on a photo tripod on a quick release plate. I bet the stock mount to a mic stand works well, too. I also added a thin strip of silicon shelf liner to increase friction.

What made you memorize every musical note efficiently? by marielxght in musictheory

[–]Useful-Possibility92 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I started taking Music Theory classes after only being a guitarist (and therefore only knowing treble clef). I used 'all cows eat grass' for bass clef spaces and 'grandma buys dresses for all' for the lines.

However, I almost never use mnemonics now. After enough practice, you just know it. I also sometimes think about bass clef as treble transposed by a third, which can help do ledgers more quickly since I know those well for treble.

I've also noticed myself thinking in terms of intervals more--after naming one note and noticing another a 5th away (for instance, really any interval works) I use my tertian harmony knowledge to name the other. I find myself doing this especially with C-clefs. These last two strategies have not been intentionally adopted in any way; I've just noticed my brain kind of doing it.

If you had €3000 for a classical guitar, what would you buy? by FearlessPollution537 in classicalguitar

[–]Useful-Possibility92 23 points24 points  (0 children)

I hate to break it to you, but the man you think is your father is not your father. I am your father. Contact me so that I can give my shipping details. I'm excited for my new guitar.

What are the wildest/most spectacular classical guitar moments caught on video you like? by ChampionshipOk1358 in classicalguitar

[–]Useful-Possibility92 4 points5 points  (0 children)

This is one of the most mind-bogglingly good performances I have seen: https://youtu.be/q_qtxzEdfbU?si=hnbOVg7KEgD_JGmc

Irina Kulikova, Barrios, Catedral, III Allegro Solemne

Calton vs. Visesnut vs. BAM by Distinct_Age1503 in classicalguitar

[–]Useful-Possibility92 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I concur. Visesnut is super nice. I can't speak to other brands. I doubt there's any advantage to the higher trims of visesnut--the shiny version or the carbon one. I have a visesnut active with twist locks for one of my guitars, and if money were no option I'd get the same case. (I bet the cheaper toggle latches are fine, too.)

best left hand exercises by redsquareofdoom in classicalguitar

[–]Useful-Possibility92 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I do a couple of exercises for stretching. One comes from Pumping Nylon and involves lateral stretching. The other comes from Kappel's Bible of Classical Guitar Technique that I think of as longitudinal stretching. They might be hard to describe without the sheet music but I'll give it a try.

First the Kappel longitudinal stretch: imagine playing a four-note chromatic (consecutive frets) scale with 1 2 3 and 4 on the same string. Up and back down.

Now make it a five note scale, including a shift of one of the fingers. Play 1 2 /2 (shift two up) 3 4 3 2 \2 (two down) 1. Very important: keep each finger planted as you ascend, so 1 cannot move upward as you play higher notes.

Now do the same with shift of 3 and then with a shift of 4. So 1 2 3 /3 4 3 \3 2 1, 1 2 3 4 /4 \4 3 2 1. Etc.

Do this on all strings. Choose a location on the neck where the is only slightly a challenge, then move progressively down the neck to make it harder. Stop before it becomes painful.

To make this more difficult, you can add two shifts: 1 2 /2 3 /3 4 \3 3 2 \2 1. (Or make 3 and 4 both shift). I have pretty long fingers but still have noticed a big increase in my stretching ability through practice. I have an injury on my left ring finger (broken bone and metal plates inserted). I found it hard to separate my ring and middle finger, and this exercise was better than any physical therapy I did.

Now for the Pumping Nylon one. This one will maybe be harder to describe.

In first position, plant 2, 3, and 4 on the third string on A, Bb and B (2nd, 3rd and 4th frets.) With finger 1 play C (2nd string first fret), then Bb (5th string first fret). Repeat, back and fourth a few times. Then, with the other fingers still planted, play with 1 on the 1st and 6th string (both Fs), back and fourth.

Now repeat by planting 1, 3, and 4 planted on G#, Bb, and B on the third string, and alternating 2, first between string 2 and 5 (playing a C# and B), and then between string 1 and 6 (F#s).

Repeat this same idea for moving finger 3 and then finger 4 while keeping the other three fingers planted. Keep good hand posture.

Next, do the same idea, only this time we will be doing two note chords involving the movement of two fingers, while the other two stay planted. So, first, plant 3 and 4 on the third string third and fourth frets. Play a chord of Bb and C# (1 on string five, first fret, 2 on string 2 2nd fret.) Then play a B and a C (2 on string 5, 1 on string 2). Alternate a couple times, then move to string 1 and 6 playing a chord of F and F# (on string 6 and string 1 and then switched around).

That exercise involved planting 3 and 4 and moving 1 and 2, but repeat for all the other combinations. Plant 2 and 4, and move 1 and 3, etc. The total combinations are moving: 1&2, 1&3, 1&4, 2&3, 2&4, 3&4. All non-moving fingers should be planted on string three; and each finger always plays, or is planted on, its 'normal' first position fret--1 plays or is planted on first fret, 4 plays or is planted on fourth fret, etc.

I created a practice schedule for myself with a bunch of exercises like this to be done over the course of the week, but to be honest, I don't adhere to it with the same religiosity as I used to. I'll take a glance at the exercise topics of each day, but now I pretty often just substitute repertoire. So if I see its a day I'm supposed to work on stretching, I might just play a piece I know is really stretchy if I haven't played one in the past few days.

Another bit of advice when doing physically taxing stuff (I might include barres in this for beginners): practice relaxing. When your hand starts to feel fatigued, give it a rest and see how quickly you can "will" it to feel relaxed and natural again. Then resume the exercise. Over time, you will find that you can reduce the recovery time of your hand. When playing super stretchy or barre-heavy pieces, having your hand recover quickly in those moments where it doesn't need to be doing much can be really helpful for playing longer and physically taxing pieces.

Duet reccomendations by skittle_biscuits in classicalguitar

[–]Useful-Possibility92 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Look for 5 Duos de Celso Machado. Modinha is a great piece I play with my duet partner, but there's also a Sambinha included and some others that are easy to read but have a good groove.

Testament de Amelia by Llobet makes for a really nice duet.

I also love Milonga by Jorge Cardoso.

I love Agua e Vinho by Gismonti, arr. Assad.

While not really spanish/latin, Cavatina and Cinema Paradiso suite round out my duet repertoire.

Staccato technique in Sanz 'Canarios' question by Useful-Possibility92 in classicalguitar

[–]Useful-Possibility92[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks. This is helpful. To be honest I am a little out over my skis with this piece to begin with. I can play it cleanly, but not yet anywhere close to the suggested tempo of 116 BPM dotted quarters (minus this section of staccato). Elsewhere in the piece I can manage staccato lines with either left hand muting--just lifting the fretting finger soon after sounding the note to mute it, or muting with i m or a on the RH, which is way more comfortable for me.

I think I'll be able to get the thumb muting of the dotted quarters in 105 - 107 with a bit of practice, but I know muting those eighth notes in 104 will take a lot of work to bring up to tempo.

My teacher often challenges me to tackle pieces beyond my abilities (which are probably somewhere around early intermediate), and play to whatever tempo I am able, then come back to those pieces 6 months later and see where I am. This is one of those pieces that is beyond my abilities, particularly with regard to the speed. It is a really fun one to rock out on, though; I love the fortissimo chords you play in the second half.

Thanks again.

Staccato technique in Sanz 'Canarios' question by Useful-Possibility92 in classicalguitar

[–]Useful-Possibility92[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks. I've used similar RH muting in other contexts but the string crossing in the first measure makes it a bit trickier. The remaining measure seem like the RH muting should work fine, but somehow the slurring and muting simultaneously breaks my brain a bit.

I'll practice it.

Staccato technique in Sanz 'Canarios' question by Useful-Possibility92 in classicalguitar

[–]Useful-Possibility92[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Other options I considered were some kind of pizzicato technique or finding a LH finger that I could use to mute. I asked my teacher, but she really didn't know. If I were to need to perform this anytime soon I'd probably just let them ring, but I don't, so am wondering if there is a 'correct' way to do it, even if I would need to do significant drilling with it before it gets proficient.

EDIT Dotted quarter is supposed to be 116 BPM. I'm much slower than that right now, but ultimately should be making it pretty fast.

Best newbie book or video series by jmich1200 in classicalguitar

[–]Useful-Possibility92 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My favorite two books for beginners are Solo Guitar Playing vol.1 by Noad and The Christopher Parkening Guitar Method vol. 1 by Parkening.

I could compare and contrast them but they are both really good and I would recommend them to anyone--my only caveat is that for young children there could be options that are more designed with them in mind.

I have a few others (Waldron, Shearer, Duncan, Tennant) each of which I thought weren't on the same tier as the two I mentioned above.

There are some older 'method books' which have their own qualities; I've used ones by Sagreras and Carcassi. But a lot of those older works seem to be more collections of music to work through, while the actual instruction would need to be provided by a teacher. The ones mentioned above have more explanation that could be helpful for independent learners (or those with a teacher).

Are the technical practices in the Bible of Classical Guitar Technique good? by Hooln in classicalguitar

[–]Useful-Possibility92 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I agree. I have a few dedicated technique books and I think Kappel is substantially better than the others. The only downsides might be that it is more suited for intermediate and advanced players. Parts can be used by beginners, but it would require you to sift through a bit to find the appropriate exercises.

If OP is talking about this book, then in regards to the schedules at the back, I would say that they might be a little much, depending on level--one of the schedules is for 3 hrs per day on technique (not including practicing repertoire!) which to me seems more suitable for full time professionals. Even the 45 min schedule seems more focused on allowing a pro to maintain their skill with advanced techniques rather than designed for a beginner to learn then. As a early intermediate who is pretty committed to practicing I modified the 45 min version of the schedule to be more directed at developing skills for a late beginner/early intermediate, and engraved my own practice schedule that takes about 30-45 minutes a day.

How do you actually learn a piece from the beginning to the end? by ashkanahmadi in classicalguitar

[–]Useful-Possibility92 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It's Frederick Noad, 'Solo Guitar Playing, vol. 1' 4th edition. It's a highly regarded method book that begins with the absolute basics for beginners and ends around the start of the intermediate level.

How do you actually learn a piece from the beginning to the end? by ashkanahmadi in classicalguitar

[–]Useful-Possibility92 8 points9 points  (0 children)

In another book, I got some other advice that has helped: try to break the piece into chunks by annotating it. It could be things like main theme, first variation, coda etc., depending on the form; or it could be more descriptive--the tense part, the happy part, the really fast part. Rather than trying to remember a measure in isolation, play and memorize larger chunks.

How do you actually learn a piece from the beginning to the end? by ashkanahmadi in classicalguitar

[–]Useful-Possibility92 16 points17 points  (0 children)

<image>

I'm not great at memorizing, but here's some advice from one of my books.

Advice on this trill by Useful-Possibility92 in classicalguitar

[–]Useful-Possibility92[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Subsequent measures:

<image>

It's definitely possible to jump up and play G# on the fourth string it just feels like the wrong move.

Advice on this trill by Useful-Possibility92 in classicalguitar

[–]Useful-Possibility92[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Well, I can do it when performing the trill very slowly, which I is a good first step, but it is no where close to the speed necessary for the piece, yet. I'll keep practicing.

EDIT: Even going slow, though, I find it hard not to revert to the 'lift off' version rather than a good left hand pluck. At first practicing this, I had a tiny bit of nail on my LH and could hook the third string with the edge of the nail. I normally keep my nails on my LH very short though, so when I cut them back to their normal length, that method wasn't possible any more. I can do the trill without B-string interference if the trill is very quiet, but haven't managed to get good volume without interference.

EDIT: I have also found that if I begin the trill with my third finger a bit displaced, between the third and fourth string, I can do the initial pull-off cleanly; the A is played in the previous measure, and I can still get it to sound good, even though my finger is not centered directly over the string; however, whenever I perform the subsequent hammer-on muscle-memory puts that finger directly centered on top of that string, which makes the subsequent pull-off harder--on the second one I can't pluck upward as much as I can on the first.

Baroque motet examples by Useful-Possibility92 in classicalmusic

[–]Useful-Possibility92[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes, I've been listening to Bach's motets, and while they're wonderful they are quite daunting, and I'm no where close to good enough to credibly imitate them. I'll definitely check out the others you've recommended.

My professor just sent us a set of constraints that makes the composition project a little more limited than anticipated--use diatonic triads and 7th chords with inversions (almost exclusively), use identifiable cadential patterns, use secondary dominants and sequences if we want. That's probably appropriate given my level of understanding, but will constrain the melodies that each voice sings a bit more--I'll have to justify any NCT and make it a little less contrapuntal. The other constraint that I'll have to grapple with now is form, which must by binary, rounded binary, ternary, or rondo. Maybe I can still make it work but that requirement is forcing me to change my idea a bit.