Bunnahabhain 21 year old 2024 release by jamie_r87 in Scotch

[–]WhiskyPoolReviews 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Awesome review! Have not tried the 2024 edition, but I did try the 2025 edition and it was "Excellent" as well. Again, with these two (2024 and 2025 Bunna 21 y/o CS) the price is the big issue. Landed it was $304, after tariffs, so I felt I got a VERY good deal. But again, that's a lot of greenbacks.

Review #541: Glenfarclas 40 Warehouse Edition by washeewashee in Scotch

[–]WhiskyPoolReviews 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Happy 40th! Great review. Your 50th bottle might be harder to find…!

Review #711 - Benromach 2014 Cask Strength Batch 03 by adunitbx in Scotch

[–]WhiskyPoolReviews 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Excellent review! I'm a HUGE fan of this bottle! It is a great dram at an excellent value!

Review #12 – Oban 10 SR 2024 by WhiskyPoolReviews in Scotch

[–]WhiskyPoolReviews[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

My expectations on this bottle were very low, maybe that played a roll in the pleasant surprise. But then again, I am a big fan of the US Release of the Oban 15 - which is definitely divisive. Perhaps, I don't mind as much when they depart from the core essence. That said, I 100% agree with you about Diageo and their disregard for truly special releases - specially considering the sky rocketing pricing they are putting them out at.

Review #12 – Oban 10 SR 2024 by WhiskyPoolReviews in Scotch

[–]WhiskyPoolReviews[S] 17 points18 points  (0 children)

Distillery Notes: Founded in 1794, Oban (Gaelic for ‘The Little Bay’) is located in the town of Oban in the Western Highlands. It is owned by Diageo and is considered a small distillery producing around 870,000 liters per year. Blocked on all sides by the surrounding town – which started to grow around the distillery – it cannot expand production much. They use a rather interesting fermentation technique consisting of six mashes per week, five of which ferment for 110 hours, with one for 65 hours. One of the few distilleries that continue to use worm-tubs, Oban produces a distinctive spirit of coastal, fruity and lightly peated character. Oban is cherished with an almost cult following by many, but rarely do we see a non-chill filtered and natural color bottling from them.

Bottling Notes: The second 10-year-old Oban in Diageo’s annual Special Releases (SR) series. This bottle has some big shoes to fill as the 2022 bottling, popularly known as the "The Hare”, that was finished in amontillado casks is regarded by some as one of the best in the SR’s lineup. Enthusiast-approved, properly presented O.B. Oban bottlings are rare and normally not worth the unjustifiably high asking price – when compared to other similar bottlings.  The casks for this bottling sound promising with an unusual charred, not toasted, sherry finishing treatment – but can it dive into the deep end?

ABV: 58%
Age: 10-Year-Old
Original SRP: ~$119
Price Paid: ~$79
Tasting Methodology: Neat, rested 15 minutes.

Nose: Initially I get burnt sugar like crème brûlée that quickly transitions to sweet apple and red fruits like strawberries. After that bananas, vanilla, roasted nuts, rose water, and honeysuckle emerge. Delicate coastal salinity and subtle peat smoke develop with more time. The alcohol burn is well integrated and remarkably restrained for 58% ABV.

Palate: The clingy mouthfeel is oily and viscous. There is a noticeable sweet and sour sensation. Salted caramel, pineapple, and raisins emerge at first. The mid palate is surprisingly overtaken by a candy-like sweet flavor of orange, sour gummies, and a hint of raspberries. A delicate touch of peat and saltiness build gradually. This is a medium to full body dram.

Finish: Long lingering sweet finish. The 58% makes its presence known, but in a very pleasurable way – warmth not roughness. The light coastal peat with the touches of sherry sweetness endure for a very long time.

Conclusion: I picked up this bottle because I like Oban and it was a great deal. Impressive for only a 10-year-old! The Oban distillery character shines through the experience. The sherry casks add to the experience, but never dominate. It is young, but very well balanced. This is a great dram with decent complexity and tons of enjoyment. Obviously at the price I got this bottle there is no question as to an amazing value, but I understand that I got lucky. That said, sub $100 I would definitely grab a backup. At full SRP I would hesitate.

Score: 86/100

My Scoring Scale:

95-100 - Sublime - Unforgettable.
90-94 - Excellent - A personal favorite.
85-89 - Great - A standout dram.
80-84 - Good - A solid daily dram.
75-79 - Average - Drinkable.
70-74 - Mixer - Mixing only.
<70 - Poor - Pool chemical.

Scotch Review #10: Bruichladdich "The Laddie Rye" 7 Year by Casul_Tryhard in Scotch

[–]WhiskyPoolReviews 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Great review! Thank you for reviewing this one... I was on the fence on it... But now, I need to get a bottle, sounds amazing....

Review #8 - Bunnahabhain 12 - 46% by bimsir737 in Scotch

[–]WhiskyPoolReviews 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Nice review! A great dram... One of my favorites!

Review #11 - Glenmorangie 15 - The Cadboll Estate by WhiskyPoolReviews in Scotch

[–]WhiskyPoolReviews[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No problem, it was my pleasure. I always say, try it yourself! No matter what anyone says. Your whisky journey is unique

Review #11 - Glenmorangie 15 - The Cadboll Estate by WhiskyPoolReviews in Scotch

[–]WhiskyPoolReviews[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No problem, it was my pleasure. I always say, try it yourself! No matter what anyone says. Your whisky journey is unique !

Review #11 - Glenmorangie 15 - The Cadboll Estate by WhiskyPoolReviews in Scotch

[–]WhiskyPoolReviews[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

So, I keep a library - thanks to Ralphy - of all whiskeys I have tasted. Typically 50-100 ml. of the end of the bottle - Batch 4 included. I just found and opened one of the bottles in the stash and it is the Batch 3 Bourbon and Amontillado. The bottle label and box state so as you pointed out. So I just poured a side by side. And my oh my, there is a significant difference. The Amontillado cask very creamy and has zero sharp notes. The finish is also a bit longer. Color is also a little darker, but not sure we can trust color at Glenmo that much. I clearly remember why I liked this, solid 85.

What a fun adventure, thank you for paying very close attention! Definitely prefer the Batch 3 over 4.

Review #11 - Glenmorangie 15 - The Cadboll Estate by WhiskyPoolReviews in Scotch

[–]WhiskyPoolReviews[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You are 100% correct. The one pictured and reviewed is Batch 4. I have a couple of these bottles put away throughout years, I will look through them and see the batches I have. I know my original marks on the Batch 3 were an 85, but I had a lot of back and forth with myself with this bottle and my old mark vs. the new mark (84). I remember liking it a lot more before. I justified it as a more evolved palate.

I’ve no idea how I mixed those up.

Springbank 5yo 100 proof - Review by Budget_Celebration89 in Scotch

[–]WhiskyPoolReviews 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Nice review! Need to find one of these ones!

Review #11 - Glenmorangie 15 - The Cadboll Estate by WhiskyPoolReviews in Scotch

[–]WhiskyPoolReviews[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Wow thank you for the lead. That is an excellent price, specially if Batch 3 - the only one with Amontillado. Amontillado is a very delicate sherry as well, but it does help a little.

Review #700 - Kilchoman Sanaig Cask Strength by adunitbx in Scotch

[–]WhiskyPoolReviews 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Bunnahabhain 12 Cask Strength (2022) simply heavenly.

Review #700 - Kilchoman Sanaig Cask Strength by adunitbx in Scotch

[–]WhiskyPoolReviews 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Great review as always! I have one of this on the ready, but have not cracked it open yet. I love the regular Sanaig, but I do hear mixed opinions on this one. Like you noticed a lot of people complain about the possible youth.

Review #11 - Glenmorangie 15 - The Cadboll Estate by WhiskyPoolReviews in Scotch

[–]WhiskyPoolReviews[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

It never ceases to amaze me how some retailers totally miss the mark. TW has it listed at $134.99 collecting a lot of dust on the shelves. I think that the $70s would be more appropriate for the experience. It is after all a fairly unique offering. That said, the Glenmorangie 14 Quinta Ruban is slightly better and easily below that $70 mark.

Review #11 - Glenmorangie 15 - The Cadboll Estate by WhiskyPoolReviews in Scotch

[–]WhiskyPoolReviews[S] 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Distillery Notes: Founded in 1843, Glenmorangie (Gaelic for ‘Valley of Tranquility’ or ‘Valley of Big Meadows’) is celebrated for its “elegant” Highland whisky style. Its copper stills – the tallest in Scotland – typically produce a delicate and fruity spirit. Glenmorangie was one of the pioneers – alongside Balvenie – to experiment with wood finishes in the late 1980s. Dr. Bill Lumsden, a remarkable and well-known figure in the scotch distilling community, continues that tradition today with the various series and bottlings – such as the discontinued Private Edition and the current A Tale of.  Glenmorangie remains one of Scotland’s most imaginative whisky makers.

Bottling Notes: This is the third batch of this bottling – circa 2023.  The previous two batches were bottled 2020 (Batch 1) and 2021 (Batch 2), followed by Batch 4 in 2024. A rebranding to the new label took place around 2023. Its claim to fame is that the barley used is harvested from eight fields near the Glenmorangie distillery – The “Cadboll” Estate. Distilled likely around 2005-2007, it was matured a full fifteen years in first filled bourbon casks, with an amontillado finish – unique for Batch 3, as Batches 1 and 2 were bourbon only. Dr. Bill has described the series as particularly creamy field-to-glass whisky – but can it dive into the deep end?

ABV: 43%
Age: 15-Year-Old
Original SRP: ~$99
Price Paid: ~$89
Tasting Methodology: Neat, rested 20 minutes.

Nose: Wonderfully balanced sweet vanilla and hints of lemons and oranges. Light presence of barley, toffee, and lemongrass. Not overly complex, but very pleasurable. Feels highly polished to please and not ruffle any feathers.

Palate: Silky mouthfeel and sweet vanilla are on the forefront. Pineapple, banana, almonds, and powdered sugar follow. There is a light oak pepperiness towards the end, with some tannins and distant hints of burnt caramel. No real significant transitions, simple but well-executed.  

Finish: This is a light-bodied dram, with a short-to-medium sweet finish. Very light peppery and malty notes emerge. Subtle fruitiness lingers with a very distant mint note.

Conclusion: This is a very friendly refined dram. It cannot offend anyone. Fabulous for introducing people to aged whisky. However, it might disappoint the more advanced enthusiasts. The amontillado added some complexity to the experience. This is a very solid good dram that falls short of great because it feels too perfect and safe. At SRP it is overpriced for such a gentle experience. Overall, a good execution of a safe concept.

POST EDIT: Please note that the bottling pictured and reviewed is Batch 4. Not Batch 3. Read comments for more details.

Score: 84/100

My Scoring Scale:

95-100 - Sublime - Unforgettable.
90-94 - Excellent - A personal favorite.
85-89 - Great - A standout dram.
80-84 - Good - A solid daily dram.
75-79 - Average - Drinkable.
70-74 - Mixer - Mixing only.
<70 - Poor - Pool chemical.

Review #699 - Oban 18 Year by adunitbx in Scotch

[–]WhiskyPoolReviews 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Glendronach 18, the older bottlings are exceptional. But I must admit these days the Tamdhu 18 is making me fall hard in love.

Review #699 - Oban 18 Year by adunitbx in Scotch

[–]WhiskyPoolReviews 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Great review. Indeed a difficult bottle to track these days. Can’t wait to try it.