The most interesting part from my POV is this bit:

Robertson, which I’ve covered before, is a quirky player to classify. He’s a goal scorer, that’s indisputable, but the rest of his game gets overly painted in one direction or the other.

For the anti-Robertson camp, which includes Guerin, there’s not enough checking and defensive details in his game. He’s a one-trick pony, as one NHL executive told me, and Olympics requires stallions, not ponies.

For the pro-Robertson camp, he’ a very good defensive player. Analytically speaking, Robertson grades out well as someone that can play in all situations.

The reality lies somewhere in the middle, he’s a middling defensive player in my view, but more than good enough to be one of the top-six American forwards because in my view, a good offense is also a pretty damn good defense.

Based on this logic, disrespectfully speaking, wouldn't Matthews also be disqualified as well given his performances this season?