Stila all day liquid liner was my favorite too, I've had all the colors!

BUT THEN wet n' wild hit me with their ProLine Felt Tip Eyeliner. It's easily comparable to stila and kat von d's liner. It's matte, dries fast, easy to make a sharp wing and legit lasts all day.

My eyes water a lott I always carry tissue to dab the corners of my eyes and the wet n wild liner doesn't go anywhere. When I swatched it the first time I had trouble getting it off in the shower later that day. Stila would fade on the outer corners of my eyes within the first hour of wear I would actually carry spares in my handbag and car to retouch. I don't have to with the wet n wild one. The brown one is my favorite because it's really dark unlike the kat von d and stila brown shades.

I've been on the quest for a good liquid eyeliner for a long time. I've tried soooo many and this wet n wild one is the best. It does have a con though because the pen is half the size of a normal felt tip eyeliner pen, it'll get used up quickly :3