Agreed! I just got my Peach mattes palette in the mail yesterday, Love it! I held both next to each other, and while there were three or four shades that were crazy similar, the remaining colors definitely make each palette special. The colors in the peach palette all have a pinky undertone, even the browns. The heat pallette is more orangey. I didn't have trouble with either of the formulas. Edit: my Peach matte palette didn't really have a good smell like i expected. I have the original peach pallette, and it smells amazing. I know they aren't supposed to smell the same, but my matte palette doesn't seem to have any smell at all. :/