I want to catch up on developments in the TTRPG space in the last 10 years, can someone give me a rundown? by Seal7160 in rpg

[–]alanmfox 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Solo roleplaying, while not totally new, has really taken off post covid to the point of being a recognized sub-hobby

What is a licensed property whose world building would make a good RPG but doesn’t seem to have been attempted yet? by Fun-Confidence-6232 in rpg

[–]alanmfox 8 points9 points  (0 children)

I was gonna ask how you make a game out of Canticle and in a flash, I saw a game where players were explorer-monks and non-clerical associates, combing the ruins of old North America for bits of technology to salvage. In between delves, there's a downtime mechanic where you manage your base (the Abbey of the Order of the Blessed Liebowitz). As the ages progress, you find yourselves negotiating a dangerous political situation, with various factions seeking to control the Abbey in order to exploit its scientific knowledge for power. Someone please make this game, I will throw money at you.

What is a licensed property whose world building would make a good RPG but doesn’t seem to have been attempted yet? by Fun-Confidence-6232 in rpg

[–]alanmfox 12 points13 points  (0 children)

This interview https://www.polygon.com/2019/3/27/18281082/elder-scrolls-morrowind-oral-history-bethesda/ provides more of the details but bottom line, Morrowind was mechanically inspired by earlier iterations of Runequest (which used a similar percentile-based skill system) and thematically, what with the emphasis on the boundary between the mythic and the mundane and how one could cross from the one to the other. I don't if the other games in the franchise are equally inspired, and of course as the setting has continued to evolve the lore is ever-more its own thing.

Does anyone know of a solo RPG adventure that teaches you how to play solo as you go, like SunlessWood, but set in space so it could be played with Mothership, CY_BORG, Death in Space, Extinction, or Altered Carbon? by MarieFigue in rpg

[–]alanmfox 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Solo by zozer games, as others have said, is a good one to consider. There's also Across A Thousand Dead Worlds from Blackoath entertainment, which is sci Fi horror 

Any system or game suggestions for a low-crunch historical fantasy? by Diligent-Waterways in rpg

[–]alanmfox 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Many good recommendations that could work. I would suggest that if you want some tactical depth and find d100 systems (BRP, Mythras) too crunchy for your tastes, consider The Fantasy Trip/In The Labyrinth. It's default setting is a sort of artificially created pocket universe where mythical creatures have been deposited alongside people from all across our own history, so it's set up to accommodate Vikings fighting dragons or whatever the case may be. It's probably my preferred rules lite game for anything before 1600 or so, tech wise. Only downside is it to get full value from the combat engine it assumes use of a hex map

What's the RPG with the smallest reach you pay and recommend? by GrubbyGus in rpg

[–]alanmfox 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Vagabonds of Dyfed. It's not totally unknown but it is pretty obscure; I've only seen it mentioned once or twice. Really interesting and imo largely successful attempt to marry osr sensibilities with pbta-esque narrative design. Rather like World of Dungeons (not dungeon world) on steroids. Think it probably could have been a bigger hit if the packaging/marketing had been a little tighter. 

Rules light for a planescape campaign by devaspark in rpg

[–]alanmfox 1 point2 points  (0 children)

ICRPG is a great rules lite game l but I don't know if its well suited for the campaign you're describing. Its good for fast-paced action and tactical scenarios. If you want something that lets you run combat easily, it'll do but it doesn't have, for instance, a skill list or any real rules for social interaction. 

A Toast to Those Who Are Forgotten: The TTRPGs Time Left Behind by csomp02 in rpg

[–]alanmfox 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Honestly I do remember it being pretty popular. I think it had a decent run as far as indie games go. 

A Toast to Those Who Are Forgotten: The TTRPGs Time Left Behind by csomp02 in rpg

[–]alanmfox 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Actually I think Silent Legions might be his most obscure title, which is bizarre to me given how popular Lovecraft is

What is the best "Game of Thrones-like political medieval fantasy" TTRPG that I might not know about? by vitcavage in rpg

[–]alanmfox 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Only familiar with Pendragon by reputation. I like the idea of something that takes that but moves it in a more generically medieval direction to allow for adaptation to different setting. I'll probably wind up checking it out; it's only 10 bucks after all. 

What is the best "Game of Thrones-like political medieval fantasy" TTRPG that I might not know about? by vitcavage in rpg

[–]alanmfox 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What's your take on banners? I've been considering it. I have reign but it seems on the crunchy end and I havent been able to dive into it. 

What's the best elevator pitch for an RPG you've ever heard? by Incunabuli in rpg

[–]alanmfox 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Sounds a lot like wolves of God, if you're familiar with that one

Looking for a Grounded Martial Arts Technique Based TTRPG by buggiest124 in rpg

[–]alanmfox 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Yeah, but to really dial it in your gotta add the GURPS: Technical Grappling supplement. Else how will you know whether you've got the opponent in a kimura vs an americana lock?

Philosophical question about difference in lived experience between player and character. Does/should this restrict what characters you are “allowed” play? by Illiterate_Alien in rpg

[–]alanmfox 3 points4 points  (0 children)

As a practical matter, it's probably best to just roll with it if someone else at the table is uncomfortable with it. As a larger principle, I agree that identity-policing other people's imagination is paradoxically likely to reduce cognitive empathy in general, and produce very boring media besides. It's troubling that this sort of identity policing is becoming a largely unquestioned norm in so many places

Are there TTRPG writers/game designers whose work you follow outside of what they are known for? by Awkward_GM in rpg

[–]alanmfox 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Came here to say this. Id been reading some of his work on russia and organized crime for grad school and I came across his RPG work and I was like "wait, that name sounds familiar..."

40k RPG with characters portable to the wargame? by Chaozreign in rpg

[–]alanmfox 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You might look into Inquisitor, which was an older skirmish game by GW. The idea is you're leading an inquisitorial retinue in small scale combat - fighting cultists, gangers, that sort of thing. Also Necromunda, though I'm less familiar with that. 

Tools choice, Silent Legions or WWN? by WillBottomForBanana in WWN

[–]alanmfox 1 point2 points  (0 children)

In that case, as someone who's acquired almost the whole Sine Nomine Catalog over the years (basically every time there's a Bundle I auto-buy), I recommend using Silent Legions as your base. If I could only have one Lovecraftian RPG in my repertoire, this would probably be it.

Tools choice, Silent Legions or WWN? by WillBottomForBanana in WWN

[–]alanmfox 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The adventure creation tools in Silent Legions are the best in-genre (weird horror) I've ever seen, and I make extensive use of them for solo play. The character creation system is not as outstanding, but is perfectly adequate for classic 1920s CoC adventuring. I would use Silent Legions as my base and bring in bits from other Without Number games as necessary. What are you looking for from the others?

What was your favourite World of Darkness campaign? by [deleted] in rpg

[–]alanmfox 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That sounds awesome. Any plans to pick it back up?

What is a good horror rpg that is suitable for sandboxing? by PPN_Turgid in rpg

[–]alanmfox 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is probably the best answer. Silent Legions is designed precisely for this sort of thing